diff --git a/config/globals.js b/config/globals.js
index 55b4ca2..1662672 100644
--- a/config/globals.js
+++ b/config/globals.js
@@ -102,182 +102,212 @@ module.exports = {
         {
             "id": 133,
             "name": "Athletics",
-            primaryColor: "#003831",
-            secondaryColor: "#EFB21E"
+            "primaryColor": "#003831",
+            "secondaryColor": "#EFB21E",
+            "abbreviation": "OAK"
         },
         {
             "id": 134,
             "name": "Pirates",
-            primaryColor: "#FDB827",
-            secondaryColor: "#27251F"
+            "primaryColor": "#FDB827",
+            "secondaryColor": "#27251F",
+            "abbreviation": "PIT"
         },
         {
             "id": 135,
             "name": "Padres",
-            primaryColor: "#2F241D",
-            secondaryColor: "#FFC425"
+            "primaryColor": "#2F241D",
+            "secondaryColor": "#FFC425",
+            "abbreviation": "SD"
         },
         {
             "id": 136,
             "name": "Mariners",
-            primaryColor: "#005C5C",
-            secondaryColor: "#0C2C56"
+            "primaryColor": "#005C5C",
+            "secondaryColor": "#0C2C56",
+            "abbreviation": "SEA"
         },
         {
             "id": 137,
             "name": "Giants",
-            primaryColor: "#FD5A1E",
-            secondaryColor: "#27251F"
+            "primaryColor": "#FD5A1E",
+            "secondaryColor": "#27251F",
+            "abbreviation": "SF"
         },
         {
             "id": 138,
             "name": "Cardinals",
-            primaryColor: "#C41E3A",
-            secondaryColor: "#0C2340"
+            "primaryColor": "#C41E3A",
+            "secondaryColor": "#0C2340",
+            "abbreviation": "STL"
         },
         {
             "id": 139,
             "name": "Rays",
-            primaryColor: "#8FBCE6",
-            secondaryColor: "#092C5C"
+            "primaryColor": "#8FBCE6",
+            "secondaryColor": "#092C5C",
+            "abbreviation": "TB"
         },
         {
             "id": 140,
             "name": "Rangers",
-            primaryColor: "#003278",
-            secondaryColor: "#C0111F"
+            "primaryColor": "#003278",
+            "secondaryColor": "#C0111F",
+            "abbreviation": "TEX"
         },
         {
             "id": 141,
             "name": "Blue Jays",
-            primaryColor: "#134A8E",
-            secondaryColor: "#1D2D5C"
+            "primaryColor": "#134A8E",
+            "secondaryColor": "#1D2D5C",
+            "abbreviation": "TOR"
         },
         {
             "id": 142,
             "name": "Twins",
-            primaryColor: "#002B5C",
-            secondaryColor: "#D31145"
+            "primaryColor": "#002B5C",
+            "secondaryColor": "#D31145",
+            "abbreviation": "MIN"
         },
         {
             "id": 143,
             "name": "Phillies",
-            primaryColor: "#E81828",
-            secondaryColor: "#002D72"
+            "primaryColor": "#E81828",
+            "secondaryColor": "#002D72",
+            "abbreviation": "PHI"
         },
         {
             "id": 144,
             "name": "Braves",
             "primaryColor": "#CE1141",
-            secondaryColor: "#13274F"
+            "secondaryColor": "#13274F",
+            "abbreviation": "ATL"
         },
         {
             "id": 145,
             "name": "White Sox",
-            primaryColor: "#27251F",
-            secondaryColor: "#C4CED4"
+            "primaryColor": "#27251F",
+            "secondaryColor": "#C4CED4",
+            "abbreviation": "CWS"
         },
         {
             "id": 146,
             "name": "Marlins",
-            primaryColor: "#00A3E0",
-            secondaryColor: "#EF3340",
+            "primaryColor": "#00A3E0",
+            "secondaryColor": "#EF3340",
+            "abbreviation": "MIA"
         },
         {
             "id": 147,
             "name": "Yankees",
-            primaryColor: "#C4CED3",
-            secondaryColor: "#0C2340"
+            "primaryColor": "#C4CED3",
+            "secondaryColor": "#0C2340",
+            "abbreviation": "NYY"
         },
         {
             "id": 158,
             "name": "Brewers",
-            primaryColor: "#FFC52F",
-            secondaryColor: "#12284B"
+            "primaryColor": "#FFC52F",
+            "secondaryColor": "#12284B",
+            "abbreviation": "MIL"
         },
         {
             "id": 108,
             "name": "Angels",
-            primaryColor: "#BA0021",
-            secondaryColor: "#003263"
+            "primaryColor": "#BA0021",
+            "secondaryColor": "#003263",
+            "abbreviation": "LAA"
         },
         {
             "id": 109,
             "name": "D-backs",
             "primaryColor": "#A71930",
-            "secondaryColor": "#E3D4AD"
+            "secondaryColor": "#E3D4AD",
+            "abbreviation": "AZ"
         },
         {
             "id": 110,
             "name": "Orioles",
-            primaryColor: "#DF4601",
-            secondaryColor: "#000000"
+            "primaryColor": "#DF4601",
+            "secondaryColor": "#000000",
+            "abbreviation": "BAL"
         },
         {
             "id": 111,
             "name": "Red Sox",
-            primaryColor: "#BD3039",
-            secondaryColor: "#0C2340"
+            "primaryColor": "#BD3039",
+            "secondaryColor": "#0C2340",
+            "abbreviation": "BOS"
         },
         {
             "id": 112,
             "name": "Cubs",
-            primaryColor: "#0E3386",
-            secondaryColor: "#CC3433"
+            "primaryColor": "#0E3386",
+            "secondaryColor": "#CC3433",
+            "abbreviation": "CHC"
         },
         {
             "id": 113,
             "name": "Reds",
-            primaryColor: "#C6011F",
-            secondaryColor: "#000000"
+            "primaryColor": "#C6011F",
+            "secondaryColor": "#000000",
+            "abbreviation": "CIN"
         },
         {
             "id": 114,
             "name": "Guardians",
-            primaryColor: "#E50022",
-            secondaryColor: "#00385D"
+            "primaryColor": "#E50022",
+            "secondaryColor": "#00385D",
+            "abbreviation": "CLE"
         },
         {
             "id": 115,
             "name": "Rockies",
-            primaryColor: "#333366",
-            secondaryColor: "#C4CED4"
+            "primaryColor": "#333366",
+            "secondaryColor": "#C4CED4",
+            "abbreviation": "COL"
         },
         {
             "id": 116,
             "name": "Tigers",
-            primaryColor: "#0C2340",
-            secondaryColor: "#FA4616"
+            "primaryColor": "#0C2340",
+            "secondaryColor": "#FA4616",
+            "abbreviation": "DET"
         },
         {
             "id": 117,
             "name": "Astros",
-            primaryColor: "#002D62",
-            secondaryColor: "#EB6E1F"
+            "primaryColor": "#002D62",
+            "secondaryColor": "#EB6E1F",
+            "abbreviation": "HOU"
         },
         {
             "id": 118,
             "name": "Royals",
-            primaryColor: "#004687",
-            secondaryColor: "#BD9B60"
+            "primaryColor": "#004687",
+            "secondaryColor": "#BD9B60",
+            "abbreviation": "KC"
         },
         {
             "id": 119,
             "name": "Dodgers",
-            primaryColor: "#005A9C",
-            secondaryColor: "#EF3E42"
+            "primaryColor": "#005A9C",
+            "secondaryColor": "#EF3E42",
+            "abbreviation": "LAD"
         },
         {
             "id": 120,
             "name": "Nationals",
-            primaryColor: "#AB0003",
-            secondaryColor: "#14225A"
+            "primaryColor": "#AB0003",
+            "secondaryColor": "#14225A",
+            "abbreviation": "WSH"
         },
         {
             "id": 121,
             "name": "Mets",
-            primaryColor: "#002D72",
-            secondaryColor: "#FF5910"
+            "primaryColor": "#002D72",
+            "secondaryColor": "#FF5910",
+            "abbreviation": "NYM"
         }
     ],
     HELP_MESSAGE: '`/starters` - examine the starting pitching matchup for the upcoming game.\n'
diff --git a/modules/command-util.js b/modules/command-util.js
index f01b735..ff4262d 100644
--- a/modules/command-util.js
+++ b/modules/command-util.js
@@ -562,6 +562,29 @@ module.exports = {
         }
     },
 
+    resolvePlayerSelection: async (players, interaction) => {
+        const buttons = players.map(player =>
+            new ButtonBuilder()
+                .setCustomId(player.id.toString())
+                .setLabel(`${player.fullName} (${globals.TEAMS.find(team => team.id === player.currentTeam.id)?.abbreviation})`)
+                .setStyle(ButtonStyle.Primary)
+        );
+        const response = await interaction.followUp({
+            content: 'I found multiple matches. Which one?',
+            components: [new ActionRowBuilder().addComponents(buttons)]
+        });
+        const collectorFilter = i => i.user.id === interaction.user.id;
+        try {
+            LOGGER.trace('awaiting');
+            return await response.awaitMessageComponent({ filter: collectorFilter, time: 20_000 });
+        } catch (e) {
+            await interaction.editReply({
+                content: 'Player selection not received within 20 seconds - request was canceled.',
+                components: []
+            });
+        }
+    },
+
     giveFinalCommandResponse: async (toHandle, options) => {
         await (globalCache.values.game.isDoubleHeader
             ? toHandle.update(options)
@@ -671,28 +694,32 @@ module.exports = {
             liveFeed.gameData.teams.home.abbreviation + ' ' + homeScore + '**');
     },
 
-    getClosestPlayer: async (playerName, type) => {
+    getClosestPlayers: async (playerName, type) => {
         const startTime = performance.now();
         const allPlayers = await mlbAPIUtil.players();
         const removeDiacritics = (str) => str.normalize('NFD').replace(/[\u0300-\u036f]/g, '');
         const normalizedPlayerName = removeDiacritics(playerName.toLowerCase());
-        let matchingPlayer;
+        let matchingPlayers = [];
         let smallestDistance = Infinity;
         allPlayers.people.forEach(p => {
             const currentName = removeDiacritics(`${p.fullName}`.toLowerCase());
             const distance = levenshtein(currentName, normalizedPlayerName);
-            if (distance < smallestDistance
+            if (distance <= smallestDistance
                 && (
                     (type === 'Pitcher' && p.primaryPosition.name === 'Pitcher')
                     || (type === 'Batter' && p.primaryPosition.name !== 'Pitcher')
                 )) {
-                matchingPlayer = p;
-                smallestDistance = distance;
+                if (distance < smallestDistance) {
+                    matchingPlayers = [p];
+                    smallestDistance = distance;
+                } else {
+                    matchingPlayers.push(p);
+                }
             }
         });
         const endTime = performance.now();
         LOGGER.trace(`Savant command - getting closest player took ${endTime - startTime} milliseconds.`);
-        return matchingPlayer;
+        return matchingPlayers;
     },
 
     getPitcherEmbed: (pitcher, pitcherInfo, isLiveGame, description, savantMode = false) => {
@@ -791,32 +818,39 @@ module.exports = {
         }
     },
 
-    getBatterFromUserInputOrLiveFeed: async (playerName) => {
-        let batter, currentLiveFeed;
+    getPlayerFromUserInputOrLiveFeed: async (playerName, interaction, type) => {
+        let player, currentLiveFeed, shouldEditReply, pendingChoice;
         if (playerName) {
-            batter = await module.exports.getClosestPlayer(playerName, 'Batter');
-        } else {
-            currentLiveFeed = globalCache.values.game.currentLiveFeed;
-            if (currentLiveFeed && currentLiveFeed.gameData.status.abstractGameState === 'Live') {
-                batter = currentLiveFeed.liveData.plays.currentPlay.matchup.batter;
+            const players = await module.exports.getClosestPlayers(playerName, type);
+            if (players.length > 1) {
+                pendingChoice = await module.exports.resolvePlayerSelection(players.slice(0, 5), interaction);
+                const idString = pendingChoice?.customId;
+                if (idString) {
+                    player = players.find(player => player.id === parseInt(idString));
+                    await pendingChoice.deferUpdate(); // This function says it takes reply options, but it doesn't work?? So I've resorted to editing on the next line.
+                    await interaction.editReply({
+                        content: `Getting stats for ${player.fullName} (${globals.TEAMS.find(team => team.id === player.currentTeam.id)?.abbreviation}). Please wait...`,
+                        components: []
+                    });
+                    shouldEditReply = true;
+                }
+            } else {
+                player = players[0];
             }
-        }
-
-        return batter;
-    },
-
-    getPitcherFromUserInputOrLiveFeed: async (playerName) => {
-        let batter, currentLiveFeed;
-        if (playerName) {
-            batter = await module.exports.getClosestPlayer(playerName, 'Pitcher');
         } else {
             currentLiveFeed = globalCache.values.game.currentLiveFeed;
             if (currentLiveFeed && currentLiveFeed.gameData.status.abstractGameState === 'Live') {
-                batter = currentLiveFeed.liveData.plays.currentPlay.matchup.pitcher;
+                player = type === 'Pitcher'
+                    ? currentLiveFeed.liveData.plays.currentPlay.matchup.pitcher
+                    : currentLiveFeed.liveData.plays.currentPlay.matchup.batter;
             }
         }
 
-        return batter;
+        return {
+            player,
+            pendingChoice,
+            shouldEditReply
+        };
     }
 };
 
diff --git a/modules/interaction-handlers.js b/modules/interaction-handlers.js
index 903c4b3..0a31b4b 100644
--- a/modules/interaction-handlers.js
+++ b/modules/interaction-handlers.js
@@ -380,14 +380,15 @@ module.exports = {
         console.info(`PITCHER command invoked by guild: ${interaction.guildId}`);
         await interaction.deferReply();
         const playerName = interaction.options.getString('player')?.trim();
-        const pitcher = await commandUtil.getPitcherFromUserInputOrLiveFeed(playerName);
-        if (!pitcher) {
+        const playerResult = await commandUtil.getPlayerFromUserInputOrLiveFeed(playerName, interaction, 'Pitcher');
+        const pitcher = playerResult.player;
+        if (!pitcher && !playerName) {
             await interaction.followUp('No game is live right now!');
             return;
         }
         const pitcherInfo = await commandUtil.hydrateProbable(pitcher.id);
         const attachment = new AttachmentBuilder(Buffer.from(pitcherInfo.spot), { name: 'spot.png' });
-        await interaction.followUp({
+        const replyOptions = {
             ephemeral: false,
             files: [attachment],
             embeds: [commandUtil.getPitcherEmbed(
@@ -404,21 +405,23 @@ module.exports = {
                 ))],
             components: [],
             content: ''
-        });
+        };
+        await (playerResult.shouldEditReply ? interaction.editReply(replyOptions) : interaction.followUp(replyOptions));
     },
 
     batterHandler: async (interaction) => {
         console.info(`BATTER command invoked by guild: ${interaction.guildId}`);
         await interaction.deferReply();
         const playerName = interaction.options.getString('player')?.trim();
-        const batter = await commandUtil.getBatterFromUserInputOrLiveFeed(playerName);
-        if (!batter) {
+        const playerResult = await commandUtil.getPlayerFromUserInputOrLiveFeed(playerName, interaction, 'Batter');
+        const batter = playerResult.player;
+        if (!batter && !playerName) {
             await interaction.followUp('No game is live right now!');
             return;
         }
         const batterInfo = await commandUtil.hydrateHitter(batter.id);
         const attachment = new AttachmentBuilder(Buffer.from(batterInfo.spot), { name: 'spot.png' });
-        await interaction.followUp({
+        const replyOptions = {
             ephemeral: false,
             files: [attachment],
             embeds: [commandUtil.getBatterEmbed(
@@ -432,14 +435,16 @@ module.exports = {
             )],
             components: [],
             content: ''
-        });
+        };
+        await (playerResult.shouldEditReply ? interaction.editReply(replyOptions) : interaction.followUp(replyOptions));
     },
 
     batterSavantHandler: async (interaction) => {
         await interaction.deferReply();
         const playerName = interaction.options.getString('player')?.trim();
-        const batter = await commandUtil.getBatterFromUserInputOrLiveFeed(playerName);
-        if (!batter) {
+        const playerResult = await commandUtil.getPlayerFromUserInputOrLiveFeed(playerName, interaction, 'Batter');
+        const batter = playerResult.player;
+        if (!batter && !playerName) {
             await interaction.followUp('No game is live right now!');
             return;
         }
@@ -451,13 +456,14 @@ module.exports = {
                 statcastData.mostRecentStatcast,
                 statcastData.metricSummaryJSON[statcastData.mostRecentMetricYear.toString()],
                 batterInfo.spot)), { name: 'savant.png' });
-            await interaction.followUp({
+            const replyOptions = {
                 ephemeral: false,
                 files: [savantAttachment],
                 embeds: [commandUtil.getBatterEmbed(batter, batterInfo, !playerName, null, true)],
                 components: [],
                 content: ''
-            });
+            };
+            await (playerResult.shouldEditReply ? interaction.editReply(replyOptions) : interaction.followUp(replyOptions));
         } else {
             await interaction.followUp({
                 content: 'There was a problem fetching the savant metrics for this player.'
@@ -468,8 +474,9 @@ module.exports = {
     pitcherSavantHandler: async (interaction) => {
         await interaction.deferReply();
         const playerName = interaction.options.getString('player')?.trim();
-        const pitcher = await commandUtil.getPitcherFromUserInputOrLiveFeed(playerName);
-        if (!pitcher) {
+        const playerResult = await commandUtil.getPlayerFromUserInputOrLiveFeed(playerName, interaction, 'Pitcher');
+        const pitcher = playerResult.player;
+        if (!pitcher && !playerName) {
             await interaction.followUp('No game is live right now!');
             return;
         }
@@ -481,13 +488,14 @@ module.exports = {
                 statcastData.mostRecentStatcast,
                 statcastData.metricSummaryJSON[statcastData.mostRecentMetricYear.toString()],
                 pitcherInfo.spot)), { name: 'savant.png' });
-            await interaction.followUp({
+            const replyOptions = {
                 ephemeral: false,
                 files: [savantAttachment],
                 embeds: [commandUtil.getPitcherEmbed(pitcher, pitcherInfo, !playerName, null, true)],
                 components: [],
                 content: ''
-            });
+            };
+            await (playerResult.shouldEditReply ? interaction.editReply(replyOptions) : interaction.followUp(replyOptions));
         } else {
             await interaction.followUp({
                 content: 'There was a problem fetching the savant metrics for this player.'