Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Is it possible to get the Voltage level in ampere meter mode ? #320

Open
yguel opened this issue Apr 18, 2023 · 10 comments
Open

Is it possible to get the Voltage level in ampere meter mode ? #320

yguel opened this issue Apr 18, 2023 · 10 comments

Comments

@yguel
Copy link

yguel commented Apr 18, 2023

Reading the schematics of the PPK2, it looks like the voltage of the source (VDUT SENSE) is available to the PPK2.
Would-it be possible to get its value in ampere meter mode ?

@wlgrd
Copy link
Collaborator

wlgrd commented Apr 19, 2023

In theory, yes. It is used in a loopback when setting the output voltage, but it can also be read during operation. Unfortunately, this is not implemented but is in our backlog.
It would demand some sacrifices to the readout speed of the current measurement. How often would you think you would need to have the voltage of the DUT updated?

@yguel
Copy link
Author

yguel commented Apr 19, 2023

For our application it is 10Hz, quite low compared to the usual current measurement needs.

@yguel
Copy link
Author

yguel commented Apr 19, 2023

Is that part of the code open source ? We can dedicate ressources to implement the feature.

@wlgrd
Copy link
Collaborator

wlgrd commented Apr 19, 2023

Unfortunately not, this demands a firmware change. I will get back to you when time allows for prioritizing this

@KSt-HW
Copy link

KSt-HW commented Aug 4, 2023

We would need the same, but with a higher frequency. We would like to have it with each current reading, since we are having a very dynamic source and sink as well.
That would probably mean, that the possible sampling speed is at least half the current possible speed, but that would be ok with us.
I addition, it would be handy for the UI, if an area of the measured graph is selected, not only the current and charge are calculated, but also the power by including the measured voltages.

@tmarkson
Copy link

tmarkson commented Aug 4, 2023

Count me as another user that's OK with lower sampling speed when reading Voltage. It's a very enticing feature! I think the only major feature missing from PPK ecosystem.

@frolswe
Copy link

frolswe commented Feb 11, 2024

Voltage measurement would be really useful, please implement that :)
Any possibility for you to opensource the firmware for this device?

@oldgerman
Copy link

The current waveform graph shows the current, which I presume is compensated for by calculations using calibration data, and if the voltage is assumed to be constant in the calculations, the less it reflects the true current when the voltage fluctuates a lot. I hope the new firmware will add the ability to display current and voltage waveforms at the same time, and to switch between the display of these two types of data :)
1: Constant voltage + real time current
2: real-time voltage + real-time current

@MM-Lehmann
Copy link

MM-Lehmann commented Sep 24, 2024

That would be a very useful feature, actually mitigating the most serious disadvantage over other power meters, as indicated by other users above. We could imagine using this device in a number of projects then.
@wlgrd, any chance, you could open source or at least provide the firmware for the controller? We (Fraunhofer IIS) could dedicate some resources implementing the feature in firmware and feed that back to you.

@wlgrd
Copy link
Collaborator

wlgrd commented Oct 23, 2024

Unfortunately not @MM-Lehmann, the firmware will remain closed source. Your feedback is much appreciated, and is resonating well with the rest of the community. I will again try and get this prioritized.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

7 participants