old-runner-migration.md

title	sidebar_position
Migrating from the old Scala runner	15

import {ChainedSnippets} from "../../src/components/MarkdownComponents.js";

Migrating from the old scala runner

As of SIP-46, Scala CLI has been accepted as the new scala command.

In that context, the purpose of this guide is to highlight the key differences between the old scala script and Scala CLI to make the migration as smooth as possible for users.

:::note If you are looking for an overview of Scala CLI basics, refer to the Basics page. If you merely want to get started with Scala CLI, you might want to first look at the Getting started page. :::

How to test Scala CLI as the new scala command?

There is a dedicated scala-experimental distribution of Scala CLI, which can install it as scala on your machine. For instructions on how to try it out, refer to the relevant doc.

How has the passing of arguments been changed from the old scala runner to Scala CLI?

Let us take a closer look on how the old runner handled arguments when compared to Scala CLI.

The old ways

In the old scala runner, the first argument was treated as the input source, while the second and following arguments were considered program arguments.

scala Source.scala programArg1 programArg2

Since everything after the first argument had to be arbitrarily read as a program argument, regardless of format, all runner options had to be passed before the source input.

scala -save script.sc programArg1 programArg2

The ways of Scala CLI

With Scala CLI's default way of handling arguments, inputs and program arguments have to be divided by --. There is no limit for the number of either.

scala-cli Source1.scala Source2.scala -- programArg1 programArg2

Additionally, a Scala CLI sub-command can be passed before the inputs section. For example, to call the above example specifying the run sub-command explicitly, pass it like this:

scala-cli run Source1.scala Source2.scala -- programArg1 programArg2

More on sub-commands can be found here.

Runner options can be passed on whatever position in the inputs section (before --). For example, all the following examples are correct ways to specify the Scala version explicitly as 3.2

scala-cli -S 3.2 Source1.scala Source2.scala -- programArg1 programArg2
scala-cli Source1.scala -S 3.2 Source2.scala -- programArg1 programArg2
scala-cli Source1.scala Source2.scala -S 3.2 -- programArg1 programArg2

:::note The exception to this rule are the launcher options, like --power or --cli-version. Those have to be passed before the inputs section (before any source inputs).

For example, to explicitly specify the launcher should run Scala CLI v0.1.20, pass it like this:

scala-cli --cli-version 0.1.20 Source1.scala Source2.scala -- programArg1 programArg2

Also, if a Scala CLI sub-command is being passed explicitly, all launcher options have to be passed before the sub-command. This is especially important for power mode commands, as those need to be called with the --power launcher option.

For example, to call the package sub-command, do it like this:

scala-cli --power package --help

:::

The Scala CLI shebang sub-command

To provide better support for shebang scripts, Scala CLI has a dedicated shebang sub-command, which handles arguments similarly to the old scala script.

scala-cli shebang Source.scala programArg1 programArg2

The purpose of the shebang sub-command is essentially to only be used in a shebang header (more details on that can be found in a later section of this guide or in the separate shebang scripts' guide), but nothing is really stopping you from using it from the command line, if you're used to how the old scala runner handled arguments. Just bear in mind that it is not the intended user experience.

How are the old scala runner options supported?

For backwards compatibility's sake, Scala CLI accepts all the old scala runner options, although many of them have been deprecated and are no longer supported in the new runner. This includes accepting all the Scala 2.13.x and 3.x respective runners' specific options.

Fully supported old scala runner options

The following old scala runner options are fully supported by Scala CLI, meaning that they deliver similar or expanded functionalities with backwards-compatible syntax:

• -e, which is an alias for Scala CLI's --execute-script and a close synonym for --script-snippet
• -v / -verbose / --verbose, which can be passed multiple times with Scala CLI, increasing the verbosity
• -cp / -classpath / --class-path, which adds compiled classes and jars to the class path
• -version / --version, which prints the currently run Scala CLI version information
• -with-compiler, which adds the Scala compiler dependency to the Scala CLI project
• Scala compiler options (with some requiring to be passed with -O, more info in the section below)
• -J<arg> Java options
• -Dname=prop Java properties

Old scala runner options which have a different meaning in Scala CLI

The following old scala runner options not only are not supported with their old functionalities, but have a different meaning in Scala CLI:

• -i, which is now an alias for Scala CLI's --interactive mode
• -h / -help
  • in the old Scala 2.13.x scala runner, it used to print the help of the runner
  • in the old Scala 3.x scala runner however, it used to print the Scala compiler help instead
  • Scala CLI takes an approach similar to the old Scala 2.13.x runner, and it prints Scala CLI help
  • to view the Scala compiler help with Scala CLI, pass the --scalac-help option instead

Deprecated and unsupported old scala runner options

The following old scala runner options have been deprecated and even though they are accepted by Scala CLI (passing them will not cause an error), they are ignored with an appropriate warning:

• -save, refer to the package sub-command on how to package a Scala CLI project to a JAR
• -nosave, a JAR file is now never saved unless the package sub-command is called
• -howtorun / --how-to-run
  • Scala CLI assumes how a file is to be run based on its file extension (and optionally its shebang header). This cannot be overridden with a command line option, so ensure your inputs use the correct file extension or have the shebang header defined. This is sort of the equivalent of the old -howtorun guess.
  • To run the REPL, refer to the repl sub-command
  • This option has been largely replaced with Scala CLI's sub-commands
• -I, to preload the extra files for the REPL, try passing them as inputs for the repl sub-command
• -nc / nocompdaemon, the underlying script runner class can no longer be picked explicitly, as with the old scala runner
• -run - Scala CLI does not support explicitly forcing the old run mode. Just pass your sources as inputs and ensure they are in the correct format and extension.

Scala compiler options

All compiler options are supported when passed with the --scalac-option flag (or the -O alias for short). However, many compiler options can also be passed directly. For more information, refer to the Scala compiler options section of the compile sub-command doc.

How does Scala CLI detect if it's running a script or a main method?

To answer this question, some disambiguation is necessary. The most important thing to note is that this has been handled differently by the 2 old scala runners (for Scala 2.13.x and for 3.x), so a consistent behaviour hasn't really been established before Scala CLI.

The Scala 2.13.x old scala runner was the most flexible, automatically detecting if what is being run is a script or an object based on the source contents. This automatic detection was also possible to be overridden with the -howtorun runner option (which has been deprecated and is not supported in Scala CLI, as noted in an earlier section). This also means that the 2.13.x old scala runner did not really care about file extensions much.

In contrast, the Scala 3.x old scala runner always expects to find a main method, potentially but not necessarily using the Scala 3 idiomatic @main annotation. This means that the Scala 3.x runner respected main methods defined in .sc files, but did not support script syntax (top level definitions with no explicit main method).

Scala CLI's approach is perhaps the most restrictive here. It accepts explicitly defined main methods in .scala sources and script syntax in .sc sources, without any additional flexibility.

The only exception would be files with no file extension, but with a shebang header, ran with the shebang sub-command. Those are always treated as scripts (more details about this can be found [in the shebang scripts' guide]).

Now, to give some examples.

Main class in a .scala input

Of course, the simplest case is putting a main class into a .scala source, which is supported by both of the old runners and by Scala CLI.

object Main {
  def main(args: Array[String]): Unit = println(args.mkString(" "))
}

scala Main.scala Hello world

scala-cli Main.scala -- Hello world

Hello world

Main class in a .sc input

object Main {
  def main(args: Array[String]): Unit = println(args.mkString(" "))
}

This case has been supported by both of the old scala runners, but is not supported by Scala CLI, which expects a script in a .sc input and wraps its contents in a main class of its own, not inspecting further for a nested one. In other words, when explicitly declaring a main class when working with Scala CLI, you have to do it in a .scala file.

scala-cli main-in-script.sc -- Hello world 
# no output will be printed

Running such an .sc file will not fail by the way, but neither will it print any output, since the appropriate method hasn't been called explicitly in the script.

Script syntax in an .sc file

println(args.mkString(" "))

This syntax is supported by the old Scala 2.13.x runner, but not by the old Scala 3.x one. The Scala 3.x runner does not allow for top level definitions without an explicit main class.

However, it is supported by Scala CLI.

scala-cli script.sc -- Hello world

Hello world

Script syntax in a .scala file

Now for the inverted case, where script-style top level definitions are put in a .scala input.

println(args.mkString(" "))

This has actually been supported by the old Scala 2.13.x runner. However, both the old Scala 3.x runner as well as Scala CLI do not support it.

scala-cli script.scala -- Hello world

[error] ./ScriptInScala.scala:1:1
[error] Illegal start of toplevel definition
[error] println(args.mkString(" "))
[error] ^^^^^^^
Error compiling project (Scala 3.2.2, JVM)
Compilation failed

Inputs with no extension

println(args.mkString(" "))

object Main {
  def main(args: Array[String]): Unit = println(args.mkString(" "))
}

Files with no extensions have been supported in the 2.13.x old runner, but not in 3.x.

Script syntax in files with no extension (or with extensions not indicating other kinds of sources, like .java) are supported in Scala CLI via the shebang sub-command (and not otherwise). However, a shebang header is necessary. An example is given in a later section of this guide.

How to migrate scripts with the old scala runner in the shebang header to Scala CLI?

As described in an earlier section of this guide, the way the old scala runner handles arguments differs from Scala CLI.

The old scala script accepted arguments with syntax making it easy to use it in a shebang header. That is, all arguments starting with the second were treated as program args, rather than input sources. This is in contrast with the Scala CLI default way of handling arguments, where inputs and program arguments have to be divided by --.

scala-cli Source1.scala Source2.scala -- programArg1 programArg2

To better support shebang scripts, Scala CLI has a dedicated shebang sub-command, which handles arguments similarly to the old scala script.

scala-cli shebang Source.scala programArg1 programArg2

For more concrete examples on how to change the shebang header in your existing scripts, look below.

Example shebang script with the Scala 2.13.x old scala runner

This is how an example shebang script could have looked like for the old scala runner with Scala 2.13.x

#!/usr/bin/env scala
println("Args: " + args.mkString(" "))

Example shebang script with the Scala 3.x old scala runner

This in turn is the Scala 3.x equivalent for its own old scala runner.

#!/usr/bin/env scala
@main def main(args: String*): Unit = println("Args: " + args.mkString(" "))

Example shebang script with Scala CLI

This is an example of how a Scala CLI script with a shebang header looks like.

#!/usr/bin/env -S scala-cli shebang
  println("Args: " + args.mkString(" "))

The example above refers scala-cli, as per the current default Scala CLI distribution. If you have Scala CLI installed as scala, then that should be changed to the following:

#!/usr/bin/env -S scala shebang
println("Args: " + args.mkString(" "))

For more information about the shebang sub-command, refer to the appropriate doc. For more details on how to use Scala CLI in shebang scripts, refer to the relevant guide.