Skip to content

Patching Chromium

Jump to bottom
Brian Johnson edited this page Mar 6, 2020 · 39 revisions

One of the primary goals of brave-core is to do changes in a way that makes it easy for Chromium rebases. This is because speed of updating to a new Chromium version is important to us.

Please follow this order when doing patching from best to worst:

Changes only inside brave-core

If changes can be made inside existing subclasses and code inside src/brave, then that is preferred.

Subclass and override

When you can't make a change directly in existing brave-core code, it's often best to simply subclass a Chromium class, and override the functions needed.

You will need to patch (see the below documentation) for some small trivial things in this case:

  • Create instances of your class instead of the Chromium class.
  • Possibly add a friend member to the base class you're subclassing.
  • Possibly add a virtual keyword to functions you'd like to subclass - example

Header patches should use preprocessor defines when possible. The define should always be the last thing in public so you can change to protected or private inside the define.

  bool ShouldRunUnloadListenerBeforeClosing(content::WebContents* web_contents);
  bool RunUnloadListenerBeforeClosing(content::WebContents* web_contents);

  // Set if the browser is currently participating in a tab dragging process.
  // This information is used to decide if fast resize will be used during
  // dragging.
  void SetIsInTabDragging(bool is_in_tab_dragging);

  BRAVE_BROWSER_H
 private:

with chromium_src override

#ifndef BRAVE_CHROMIUM_SRC_CHROME_BROWSER_UI_BROWSER_H_
#define BRAVE_CHROMIUM_SRC_CHROME_BROWSER_UI_BROWSER_H_

#define BRAVE_BROWSER_H \
 private: \
  friend class BookmarkPrefsService;

#include "../../../../../chrome/browser/ui/browser.h"  // NOLINT

#undef BRAVE_BROWSER_H

#endif  // BRAVE_CHROMIUM_SRC_CHROME_BROWSER_UI_BROWSER_H_

Using the preprocessor to use base implementations inside override files

One strategy that's preferred over patching is to use src/brave/chromium_src which overrides .cc and .h files but still use the source in the original Chromium code too. To do that you can rename a function with the preprocessor in Chromium, and then provide your own real implementation of that file and use the Chromium implementation inside of it.

Here's an example: https://github.com/brave/brave-core/blob/5293f0cab08816819bb307d02e404c2061e4368d/chromium_src/chrome/browser/browser_about_handler.cc

No BUILD.gn changes are needed for this.

Making methods virtual

There are two methods depending on whether you have a pointer or non-pointer return value. For pointer return values

#define GetExtensionAction           \
  UnusedMethod() { return nullptr; } \
  virtual ExtensionAction* GetExtensionAction

and for non-pointer types https://github.com/brave/brave-core/commit/a85a399a16df59b99b18382e2a4106d63e1a32c1#diff-925a04f8f2bcee20b47c338c1a3c70b9

Override a .cc file completely

If you want to provide a completely different implementation of a file, it is often not safe, but sometimes applicable. You can just provide the alternate implementation inside the src/brave/chromium_src directory.

One way electron went wrong is they copied entire files for changes inside a similar setup, do NOT do this. This will lead to newer Chromium rebases over time using old stale code which causes problems and makes rebasing much harder.

No BUILD.gn changes are needed for this.

Patch the Chromium files

When other options are exhausted, you can patch the code directly in src/. After making the changes, you can run the npm command npm run update_patches. This will update the patches which are stored in src/brave/patches. Please note that removed changes in src currently will not update the patches, so you will have to do that manually.

We aim to make the only patches required to be trivial changes, and not nested logic changes. If possible write the patch to add a new line vs appending/prepending to an existing line.

For example, instead of

-  return !url.is_empty() && !url.SchemeIs(content::kChromeUIScheme) &&
+  return IsBraveTranslateEnabled() && !url.is_empty() && !url.SchemeIs(content::kChromeUIScheme) &&
!url.SchemeIs(content::kChromeDevToolsScheme) &&

it should be

return !url.is_empty() && !url.SchemeIs(content::kChromeUIScheme) &&
+  IsBraveTranslateEnabled() &&
!url.SchemeIs(content::kChromeDevToolsScheme) &&

Do not add comments in patches and ignore lint line length rules to squash patches onto one line whenever possible

Patch changes which affect the flow of execution should ideally be wrapped in #if defined(BRAVE_CHROMIUM_BUILD) and #endif blocks.

You should almost never patch in two methods calls in a row. We should prefer extensible patches. For instance https://github.com/brave/brave-core/pull/2693/files#diff-a9c9a8da7aa4df821394352a0ca04a27R12:

CopyBraveExtensionLocalization(config, staging_dir, g_archive_inputs)
CopyBraveRewardsExtensionLocalization(config, staging_dir, g_archive_inputs)

inside CopyAllFilesToStagingDir would be collapsed to

CopyBraveFilesToStagingDir

Make sure you do NOT have the following in your ~/.gitconfig:

[apply]
        whitespace = fix

as trailing whitespace can be essential in patch files.

Patching gn/gni files

We should also prefer extensible patches in gn files where possible.

Multiple deps should never be added to the same target. Always create a generic brave dep and then add other deps (public_deps if needed) inside that.

The same thing goes for sources, but those should be added as sources += my_brave_sources where my_brave_sources is defined in a brave gni file. We have a gni file that is already included in nearly every gn build file in chromium through a patch in chrome_build.gni (import("//brave/build/config/brave_guild.gni"). Add new gni imports inside brave_guild.gni instead of patching them into another gn/gni file

Patching java files

Try to extend Java class like in that example https://github.com/brave/brave-core/blob/master/android/java/org/chromium/chrome/browser/BraveActivity.java or https://github.com/brave/brave-core/blob/master/android/java/org/chromium/chrome/browser/toolbar/top/BraveToolbarLayout.java. After that just create the new class via new ... where the old class created.

Patching java files

Many java patches can be replaced by using asm. In order to use asm properly you have to ensure that things compile correctly pre-asm and then make the changes in the asm step that will produce the actual calls you want. Examples: Changing private methods to public - https://github.com/brave/brave-core/pull/4716/files more examples to follow

Patching Android xml files

Clone this wiki locally