Add a builtin to remove a field

[nlewo]

To create a new structure by overriding an existing structure, it would be nice to be able to remove a field from this structure. This field could then be modified with unification.

For instance, let's consider the structure:

s : { a : "a"
      b : { ba : "ba" }
     }

Now suppose I want to create a modified version r of s:

r : { a : "a"
      b : { ba : 2 } //`where 2 is len(r.b.ba)
     }

With a removeField builtin r could be created like:

r = removeField(s.b.ba) & { b ba : len(s.b.ba) }

Note this can be implemented with several nested field comprehensions, but it's really unreadable!

r = { for k, v in s if k != "b" { "\(k)" : v } } &
       { b : { for k, v in s.b if k =! "ba" { "\(k)" : v }} & 
              { ba : len(s.b.ba) }
       }
     }

• Would it be possible to add such kind of builtin?
• How should look like removeField arguments?

[mpvl]

I can imagine something like struct.Sub({a: 3, c d: 4, c e: 5}, {c d: _}) => {a: 3, c e: 5}.

[rudolph9]

This touches on something I presented in @mpvl proposal #165 (comment)

The syntax is still conflicting with other things but in the spirit of what is described in the link you could write ([{a: 3, c d: 4, c: e: 5}] & [{c: d: _|_}]) // => {a: 3, c: e: 5}

[rudolph9]

@mpvl Still a little rough but you can do this with current functionality v0.0.14:

Omit: {
	orig: {}
	pathsToOmit: {[_]: true | {}}
	result: {
		pathsToOmit_ = pathsToOmit
		for k, v in orig {
			valueIsStruct = (isValueStruct & {value: v}).result
			inPathToOmit = (isKeySet & {struct: pathsToOmit_, key: "\(k)"}).result
			definatelyShouldOmit = inPathToOmit && (isValueBool & {value: pathsToOmit_[k]}).result
			if !definatelyShouldOmit {
				if valueIsStruct {
					"\(k)": (Omit & {orig: v, pathsToOmit: pathsToOmit_[k]}).result
				}
				if !valueIsStruct {
					"\(k)": v
				}
			}
		}
	}
}

Keep: {
	orig: {}
	pathsToKeep: {[_]: true | {}}
	result: {
		pathsToKeep_ = pathsToKeep
		for k, v in orig {
			valueIsStruct = (isValueStruct & {value: v}).result
			inPathToKeep = (isKeySet & {struct: pathsToKeep_, key: k}).result
			definatelyShouldKeep = inPathToKeep && (isValueBool & {value: pathsToKeep_[k]}).result
			if definatelyShouldKeep {
				"\(k)": v
			}
			if inPathToKeep && valueIsStruct {
				"\(k)": (Keep & {orig: v, pathsToKeep: pathsToKeep_[k]}).result
			}
		}
	}
}

testOmitAndKeep: {
	data: {a: 3, c: {d: 4}, c: e: 5}
	paths: {c: d: true}
	pathsOmit: (Omit & {orig: data, pathsToOmit: paths}).result
	pathsKeep: (Keep & {orig: data, pathsToKeep: paths}).result
}

isKeySet :: {
	struct: {...} // set the key we're checking
	key:          string
	result:       (struct & {[_]: _ | *_|_})[key] != _|_
}

testIsKeySet: {
	iskeySetFoo:               (isKeySet & {struct: {ban:             "something"}, key:  "foo"}).result
	iskeySetBan:               (isKeySet & {struct: {ban:             "something"}, key:  "ban"}).result
	iskeySetFooStruct:         (isKeySet & {struct: {ban: {asdfafoo:  "something"}}, key: "foo"}).result
	iskeySetBanStruct:         (isKeySet & {struct: {ban: {asdfasfoo: "something"}}, key: "ban"}).result
	iskeySetBanStruct:         (isKeySet & {struct: {ban: {asdfasfoo: "something"}}, key: "ban"}).result
	iskeySetBanStructAnything: (isKeySet & {struct: {ban:             _}, key:            "ban"}).result
	iskeySetPathThing:         (isKeySet & {struct: {c: d:            true}, key:         "c"}).result
}

isValueStruct :: {
	value:  _
	result: ((value & {}) | *_|_) != _|_
}

testIsValueStruct: {
	isValueStructStruct: (isValueStruct & {value: {foo: "bar"}}).result
	isValueStructNull:   (isValueStruct & {value:       null}).result
	isValueStructInt:    (isValueStruct & {value:       int}).result
	isValueStructInt4:   (isValueStruct & {value:       4}).result
	isValueStructString: (isValueStruct & {value:       "foo"}).result
	isValueStructBool:   (isValueStruct & {value:       bool}).result
}

isValueBool :: {
	value:  _
	result: ((value & bool) | *_|_) != _|_
}

testIsValueBoolBool: {
	isValueBoolBoolBool:   (isValueBool & {value:       true}).result
	isValueBoolBoolStruct: (isValueBool & {value: {foo: "bar"}}).result
	isValueBoolStruct:     (isValueBool & {value: {foo: "bar"}}).result
	isValueBoolNull:       (isValueBool & {value:       null}).result
	isValueBoolInt:        (isValueBool & {value:       int}).result
	isValueBoolInt4:       (isValueBool & {value:       4}).result
	isValueBoolString:     (isValueBool & {value:       "foo"}).result
}

:!cue eval % -e testOmitAndKeep
data: {
    a: 3
    c: {
        d: 4
        e: 5
    }
}
paths: {
    c: {
        d: true
    }
}
pathsOmit: {
    a: 3
    c: {
        e: 5
    }
}
pathsKeep: {
    c: {
        d: 4
    }
}

The impl touches on some of our previous threads surrounding comprehensions and structural cycles but I believe falls within what is described in the spec.

[cueckoo]

This issue has been migrated to cue-lang/cue#139.

For more details about CUE's migration to a new home, please see cue-lang/cue#1078.