Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Arbitrum Foundation Grant #184

Open
amanwithwings opened this issue Dec 7, 2023 · 7 comments
Open

Arbitrum Foundation Grant #184

amanwithwings opened this issue Dec 7, 2023 · 7 comments
Assignees
Labels
grant Related to complying with the terms and deliverables of a received grant priority: high High priority

Comments

@amanwithwings
Copy link
Collaborator

amanwithwings commented Dec 7, 2023

Commencement date: December 5

Milestone #1: [due March 5, '24] A minimum of 3 DAOs on Arbitrum achieve EIP-4824 compliance by publishing a daoURI.
Milestone #2: [due June 5, '24] Development and deployment of the Regulatory Interface.
Milestone #3: [due September 5, '24] Release of the tax standard V1.0.

_"Milestone #1: First round of EIP-4824 adoption drive through Arbitrum
The milestone involves driving the adoption of EIP-4824 among DAOs in the
Arbitrum ecosystem. DAOstar is currently in the initial stages of this drive,
reaching out to DAOs and providing them with the necessary resources and
support to adopt EIP-4824.
KPIs: a minimum of 3 DAOs on Arbitrum achieve EIP-4824 compliance by
publishing a daoURI.
How to track KPIs: The Foundation will measure progress by tracking the
number of DAOs that have successfully adopted EIP-4824 and published a
daoURI. This information will be picked up by a subgraph that listens to
events from a RegistrationFactory contract that the Grant Recipient will
deploy on Arbitrum.

Milestone #2: Implementation of the Regulatory Interface
This milestone involves the development and deployment of the Regulatory
Interface. The Grant Recipient has already developed a prototype of the
interface, which can be viewed here:
https://develop.d61skfzwobmxx.amplifyapp.com/ (Lab tab here)
KPIs: successful deployment of the interface, the number of DAOs writing
information to it, and the number of regulators, policymakers, and legal teams
leveraging it.
How to track KPIs: The Grant Recipient should provide the Foundation with
the feedback gathered from users to ensure the interface is meeting its
intended purpose and is user-friendly.

Milestone #3: Authoring of the DAO tax standard
This milestone involves the creation of a comprehensive tax standard for
DAOs. The Grant Recipient is in the early stages of this task, conducting
research and gathering input from various stakeholders.
KPIs: the successful release of the tax standard V1.0.

How to track KPIs: The Grant Recipient should provide the Foundation with
the feedback gathered from stakeholders to ensure it meets the needs of DAOs
and complies with existing tax regulations. The Foundation will also measure
the number of DAOs that adopt the framework."_

_"Milestone #1 - within three (3) months from the Effective Date of the

Agreement;
Milestone #2 - within six (6) months from the Effective Date of the
Agreement;
Milestone #3 - within nine (9) months from the Effective Date of the
Agreement."_

@amanwithwings amanwithwings self-assigned this Dec 7, 2023
@amanwithwings amanwithwings added the priority: high High priority label Dec 7, 2023
@amanwithwings
Copy link
Collaborator Author

amanwithwings commented Dec 8, 2023

DAOs on Arbitrum (Sourced from https://portal.arbitrum.io/projects/defi?chains=arbitrum-one_arbitrum-nova):

  1. Badger DAO
  2. Balancer
  3. Aura Finance
  4. Curve
  5. Kromatika Finance
  6. Uniswap
  7. 1inch
  8. Beefy Finance
  9. Galxe
  10. B Protocol
  11. Compound
  12. dForce
  13. Impermax Finance
  14. Lodestar Finance
  15. Notional Finance
  16. Silo
  17. DeFrag DAO
  18. OOKI
  19. Angle Protocol
  20. MakerDAO
  21. Frax Finance
  22. Lybra Finance
  23. Vesta Finance
  24. Gains Network
  25. GMX
  26. Handle Finance
  27. Mux Protocol
  28. Cryptex
  29. Instadapp

@thelastjosh
Copy link
Member

thelastjosh commented Dec 13, 2023

How do we vastly accelerate / scale up our ability to onboard new DAOs?

  • onboarding a 4824-compliant DAO framework
  • finding other use-cases for daoURI (maybe even individuals registering?!)

@amanwithwings
Copy link
Collaborator Author

We have the proposal live at Lodestar, soon at 1inch and hopefully Balancer, Gitcoin and Treasure.

@thelastjosh thelastjosh added the grant Related to complying with the terms and deliverables of a received grant label Jan 26, 2024
@thelastjosh
Copy link
Member

Note from discussion today: planning on a Snapshot partnership for the Snapshot X launch, but we need to ask for an extension from Arbitrum for this.

@thelastjosh
Copy link
Member

Plan for milestone 2: we have a working prototype but still need to improve it, I'd suggest going with new minimal MVP that reflects the new standard that DOES NOT require additional technical resources, and then once we have a good MVP we can tap mendes or rashmi or others to implement.

@thelastjosh
Copy link
Member

In discussion with Joni and @amanwithwings , we discussed the best way of resolving Milestone 2, "Development and deployment of the Regulatory Interface".

If this is fully specified, it should only take Rashmi a week to implement.

  • Publish a MINIMAL VERSION of the specification, that specifies complianceURI and endorsed legal representative.
  • Add a field in daoURI, probably complianceURI or regulatoryURI.
  • In complianceURI, a list of attestations made somewhere, for regulatory purposes.
  • That list of attestations MUST include an endorsed legal representative attestation.
  • Display this information on the explore interface.
  • EITHER direct people to an EAS interface to make the attestation OR integrate it ourselves into the daostar.org registration interface.

For milestone 3, the initial version of the tax standard has already been largely written as part of the DAOstar Policy Trilemma report.

@amanwithwings
Copy link
Collaborator Author

amanwithwings commented Jun 12, 2024

Josh <> Joni <> Aman (12.06.2024)

  • Standard is 90% ready - it needs some work. Josh will do this and hand it over to Joni - she will shop it around a few regulators and collect their feedback on the regulatory interface.

  • take the registration interface that exists at labs.daostar.org (it exists here or somewhere else), and host is somewhere else. This could be similar to the EAS attestation method.

  • IDEA: have a seperate section on the website saying "regulatory interface" and have an EAS method "register as DAO legal representative".

  • Milestones 2, 3 will be complete before Sept 5 '24 but we need more time for milestone 2 - try August.

  • Val (sec/ iosco) Joni has their contact. Joni also knows a few other lawyers in the US. Once the standard is done - she'll send it out to people and try to schedule calls with them.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
grant Related to complying with the terms and deliverables of a received grant priority: high High priority
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants