node-api: segregate nogc APIs from rest via type system

We define a new type called `node_api_nogc_env` as the `const` version
of `napi_env` and `node_api_nogc_finalize` as a variant of
`napi_finalize` that accepts a `node_api_nogc_env` as its first
argument.

We then modify those APIs which do not affect GC state as accepting a
`node_api_nogc_env`. APIs accepting finalizer callbacks are modified to
accept `node_api_nogc_finalize` callbacks. Thus, the only way to attach
a `napi_finalize` callback, wherein Node-APIs affecting GC state may be
called is to call `node_api_post_finalizer` from a
`node_api_nogc_finalize` callback.

In keeping with the process of introducing new Node-APIs, this feature
is guarded by `NAPI_EXPERIMENTAL`. Since this feature modifies APIs
already marked as stable, it is additionally guared by
`NODE_API_EXPERIMENTAL_NOGC_ENV`, so as to provide a further buffer to
adoption. Nevertheless, both guards must be removed upon releasing a
new version of Node-API.

PR-URL: #50060
Reviewed-By: Chengzhong Wu <legendecas@gmail.com>
Reviewed-By: Vladimir Morozov <vmorozov@microsoft.com>
Reviewed-By: Michael Dawson <midawson@redhat.com>

doc/api/n-api.md

@@ -78,7 +78,7 @@ it still gets the benefits of the ABI stability provided by the C API.
 When using `node-addon-api` instead of the C APIs, start with the API [docs][]
 for `node-addon-api`.
 
-The [Node-API Resource](https://nodejs.github.io/node-addon-examples/) offers
+The [Node-API Resource](https://nodejs.github.io/node-addon-examples/) offers
 an excellent orientation and tips for developers just getting started with
 Node-API and `node-addon-api`. Additional media resources can be found on the
 [Node-API Media][] page.
@@ -175,7 +175,8 @@ developers have run into limitations in node-gyp.
 [CMake.js][] is an alternative build system based on [CMake][].
 
 CMake.js is a good choice for projects that already use CMake or for
-developers affected by limitations in node-gyp.
+developers affected by limitations in node-gyp. [`build_with_cmake`][] is an
+example of a CMake-based native addon project.
 
 ### Uploading precompiled binaries
 
@@ -237,6 +238,18 @@ Some of the Node-API surface is experimental and requires explicit opt-in:
 In this case the entire API surface, including any experimental APIs, will be
 available to the module code.
 
+Occasionally, experimental features are introduced that affect already-released
+and stable APIs. These features can be disabled by an opt-out:
+
+```c
+#define NAPI_EXPERIMENTAL
+#define NODE_API_EXPERIMENTAL_<FEATURE_NAME>_OPT_OUT
+#include <node_api.h>
+```
+
+where `<FEATURE_NAME>` is the name of an experimental feature that affects both
+experimental and stable APIs.
+
 ## Node-API version matrix
 
 Up until version 9, Node-API versions were additive and versioned
@@ -419,7 +432,7 @@ napi_value create_addon(napi_env env) {
 #include <node_api.h>
 #include "addon.h"
 
-NAPI_MODULE_INIT() {
+NAPI_MODULE_INIT(/* napi_env env, napi_value exports */) {
   // This function body is expected to return a `napi_value`.
   // The variables `napi_env env` and `napi_value exports` may be used within
   // the body, as they are provided by the definition of `NAPI_MODULE_INIT()`.
@@ -464,7 +477,7 @@ napiVersion: 6
 -->
 
 ```c
-napi_status napi_set_instance_data(napi_env env,
+napi_status napi_set_instance_data(node_api_nogc_env env,
                                    void* data,
                                    napi_finalize finalize_cb,
                                    void* finalize_hint);
@@ -496,7 +509,7 @@ napiVersion: 6
 -->
 
 ```c
-napi_status napi_get_instance_data(napi_env env,
+napi_status napi_get_instance_data(node_api_nogc_env env,
                                    void** data);
 ```
 
@@ -598,6 +611,22 @@ when an instance of a native addon is unloaded. Notification of this event is
 delivered through the callbacks given to [`napi_add_env_cleanup_hook`][] and
 [`napi_set_instance_data`][].
 
+### `node_api_nogc_env`
+
+> Stability: 1 - Experimental
+
+This variant of `napi_env` is passed to synchronous finalizers
+([`node_api_nogc_finalize`][]). There is a subset of Node-APIs which accept
+a parameter of type `node_api_nogc_env` as their first argument. These APIs do
+not access the state of the JavaScript engine and are thus safe to call from
+synchronous finalizers. Passing a parameter of type `napi_env` to these APIs is
+allowed, however, passing a parameter of type `node_api_nogc_env` to APIs that
+access the JavaScript engine state is not allowed. Attempting to do so without
+a cast will produce a compiler warning or an error when add-ons are compiled
+with flags which cause them to emit warnings and/or errors when incorrect
+pointer types are passed into a function. Calling such APIs from a synchronous
+finalizer will ultimately result in the termination of the application.
+
 ### `napi_value`
 
 This is an opaque pointer that is used to represent a JavaScript value.
@@ -762,32 +791,36 @@ typedef napi_value (*napi_callback)(napi_env, napi_callback_info);
 Unless for reasons discussed in [Object Lifetime Management][], creating a
 handle and/or callback scope inside a `napi_callback` is not necessary.
 
-#### `napi_finalize`
+#### `node_api_nogc_finalize`
 
 <!-- YAML
-added: v8.0.0
-napiVersion: 1
+added: REPLACEME
 -->
 
+> Stability: 1 - Experimental
+
 Function pointer type for add-on provided functions that allow the user to be
 notified when externally-owned data is ready to be cleaned up because the
-object with which it was associated with has been garbage-collected. The user
-must provide a function satisfying the following signature which would get
-called upon the object's collection. Currently, `napi_finalize` can be used for
+object it was associated with has been garbage-collected. The user must provide
+a function satisfying the following signature which would get called upon the
+object's collection. Currently, `node_api_nogc_finalize` can be used for
 finding out when objects that have external data are collected.
 
 ```c
-typedef void (*napi_finalize)(napi_env env,
-                              void* finalize_data,
-                              void* finalize_hint);
+typedef void (*node_api_nogc_finalize)(node_api_nogc_env env,
+                                      void* finalize_data,
+                                      void* finalize_hint);
 ```
 
 Unless for reasons discussed in [Object Lifetime Management][], creating a
 handle and/or callback scope inside the function body is not necessary.
 
 Since these functions may be called while the JavaScript engine is in a state
-where it cannot execute JavaScript code, some Node-API calls may return
-`napi_pending_exception` even when there is no exception pending.
+where it cannot execute JavaScript code, only Node-APIs which accept a
+`node_api_nogc_env` as their first parameter may be called.
+[`node_api_post_finalizer`][] can be used to schedule Node-API calls that
+require access to the JavaScript engine's state to run after the current
+garbage collection cycle has completed.
 
 In the case of [`node_api_create_external_string_latin1`][] and
 [`node_api_create_external_string_utf16`][] the `env` parameter may be null,
@@ -796,11 +829,39 @@ shutdown.
 
 Change History:
 
+* experimental (`NAPI_EXPERIMENTAL`):
+
+  Only Node-API calls that accept a `node_api_nogc_env` as their first
+  parameter may be called, otherwise the application will be terminated with an
+  appropriate error message. This feature can be turned off by defining
+  `NODE_API_EXPERIMENTAL_NOGC_ENV_OPT_OUT`.
+
+#### `napi_finalize`
+
+<!-- YAML
+added: v8.0.0
+napiVersion: 1
+-->
+
+Function pointer type for add-on provided function that allow the user to
+schedule a group of calls to Node-APIs in response to a garbage collection
+event, after the garbage collection cycle has completed. These function
+pointers can be used with [`node_api_post_finalizer`][].
+
+```c
+typedef void (*napi_finalize)(napi_env env,
+                              void* finalize_data,
+                              void* finalize_hint);
+```
+
+Change History:
+
 * experimental (`NAPI_EXPERIMENTAL` is defined):
 
-  Node-API calls made from a finalizer will return `napi_cannot_run_js` when
-  the JavaScript engine is unable to execute JavaScript, and will return
-  `napi_exception_pending` if there is a pending exception.
+  A function of this type may no longer be used as a finalizer, except with
+  [`node_api_post_finalizer`][]. [`node_api_nogc_finalize`][] must be used
+  instead. This feature can be turned off by defining
+  `NODE_API_EXPERIMENTAL_NOGC_ENV_OPT_OUT`.
 
 #### `napi_async_execute_callback`
 
@@ -1002,7 +1063,7 @@ napiVersion: 1
 
 ```c
 napi_status
-napi_get_last_error_info(napi_env env,
+napi_get_last_error_info(node_api_nogc_env env,
                          const napi_extended_error_info** result);
 ```
 
@@ -1821,7 +1882,7 @@ napiVersion: 3
 -->
 
 ```c
-NODE_EXTERN napi_status napi_add_env_cleanup_hook(napi_env env,
+NODE_EXTERN napi_status napi_add_env_cleanup_hook(node_api_nogc_env env,
                                                   napi_cleanup_hook fun,
                                                   void* arg);
 ```
@@ -1851,7 +1912,7 @@ napiVersion: 3
 -->
 
 ```c
-NAPI_EXTERN napi_status napi_remove_env_cleanup_hook(napi_env env,
+NAPI_EXTERN napi_status napi_remove_env_cleanup_hook(node_api_nogc_env env,
                                                      void (*fun)(void* arg),
                                                      void* arg);
 ```
@@ -1880,7 +1941,7 @@ changes:
 
 ```c
 NAPI_EXTERN napi_status napi_add_async_cleanup_hook(
-    napi_env env,
+    node_api_nogc_env env,
     napi_async_cleanup_hook hook,
     void* arg,
     napi_async_cleanup_hook_handle* remove_handle);
@@ -2038,7 +2099,7 @@ You can also use the `NAPI_MODULE_INIT` macro, which acts as a shorthand
 for `NAPI_MODULE` and defining an `Init` function:
 
 ```c
-NAPI_MODULE_INIT() {
+NAPI_MODULE_INIT(/* napi_env env, napi_value exports */) {
   napi_value answer;
   napi_status result;
 
@@ -2052,6 +2113,9 @@ NAPI_MODULE_INIT() {
 }
 ```
 
+The parameters `env` and `exports` are provided to the body of the
+`NAPI_MODULE_INIT` macro.
+
 All Node-API addons are context-aware, meaning they may be loaded multiple
 times. There are a few design considerations when declaring such a module.
 The documentation on [context-aware addons][] provides more details.
@@ -5416,7 +5480,7 @@ napiVersion: 5
 napi_status napi_add_finalizer(napi_env env,
                                napi_value js_object,
                                void* finalize_data,
-                               napi_finalize finalize_cb,
+                               node_api_nogc_finalize finalize_cb,
                                void* finalize_hint,
                                napi_ref* result);
 ```
@@ -5454,7 +5518,7 @@ added: v20.10.0
 > Stability: 1 - Experimental
 
 ```c
-napi_status node_api_post_finalizer(napi_env env,
+napi_status node_api_post_finalizer(node_api_nogc_env env,
                                     napi_finalize finalize_cb,
                                     void* finalize_data,
                                     void* finalize_hint);
@@ -5524,7 +5588,7 @@ Once created the async worker can be queued
 for execution using the [`napi_queue_async_work`][] function:
 
 ```c
-napi_status napi_queue_async_work(napi_env env,
+napi_status napi_queue_async_work(node_api_nogc_env env,
                                   napi_async_work work);
 ```
 
@@ -5616,7 +5680,7 @@ napiVersion: 1
 -->
 
 ```c
-napi_status napi_queue_async_work(napi_env env,
+napi_status napi_queue_async_work(node_api_nogc_env env,
                                   napi_async_work work);
 ```
 
@@ -5637,7 +5701,7 @@ napiVersion: 1
 -->
 
 ```c
-napi_status napi_cancel_async_work(napi_env env,
+napi_status napi_cancel_async_work(node_api_nogc_env env,
                                    napi_async_work work);
 ```
 
@@ -5841,7 +5905,7 @@ typedef struct {
   const char* release;
 } napi_node_version;
 
-napi_status napi_get_node_version(napi_env env,
+napi_status napi_get_node_version(node_api_nogc_env env,
                                   const napi_node_version** version);
 ```
 
@@ -5864,7 +5928,7 @@ napiVersion: 1
 -->
 
 ```c
-napi_status napi_get_version(napi_env env,
+napi_status napi_get_version(node_api_nogc_env env,
                              uint32_t* result);
 ```
 
@@ -5897,7 +5961,7 @@ napiVersion: 1
 -->
 
 ```c
-NAPI_EXTERN napi_status napi_adjust_external_memory(napi_env env,
+NAPI_EXTERN napi_status napi_adjust_external_memory(node_api_nogc_env env,
                                                     int64_t change_in_bytes,
                                                     int64_t* result);
 ```
@@ -6114,7 +6178,7 @@ napiVersion: 2
 -->
 
 ```c
-NAPI_EXTERN napi_status napi_get_uv_event_loop(napi_env env,
+NAPI_EXTERN napi_status napi_get_uv_event_loop(node_api_nogc_env env,
                                                struct uv_loop_s** loop);
 ```
 
@@ -6428,7 +6492,7 @@ napiVersion: 4
 
 ```c
 NAPI_EXTERN napi_status
-napi_ref_threadsafe_function(napi_env env, napi_threadsafe_function func);
+napi_ref_threadsafe_function(node_api_nogc_env env, napi_threadsafe_function func);
 ```
 
 * `[in] env`: The environment that the API is invoked under.
@@ -6454,7 +6518,7 @@ napiVersion: 4
 
 ```c
 NAPI_EXTERN napi_status
-napi_unref_threadsafe_function(napi_env env, napi_threadsafe_function func);
+napi_unref_threadsafe_function(node_api_nogc_env env, napi_threadsafe_function func);
 ```
 
 * `[in] env`: The environment that the API is invoked under.
@@ -6480,7 +6544,7 @@ napiVersion: 9
 
 ```c
 NAPI_EXTERN napi_status
-node_api_get_module_file_name(napi_env env, const char** result);
+node_api_get_module_file_name(node_api_nogc_env env, const char** result);
 
 ```
 
@@ -6544,6 +6608,7 @@ the add-on's file name during loading.
 [`Number.MIN_SAFE_INTEGER`]: https://tc39.github.io/ecma262/#sec-number.min_safe_integer
 [`Worker`]: worker_threads.md#class-worker
 [`async_hooks.executionAsyncResource()`]: async_hooks.md#async_hooksexecutionasyncresource
+[`build_with_cmake`]: https://github.com/nodejs/node-addon-examples/tree/main/build_with_cmake
 [`global`]: globals.md#global
 [`init` hooks]: async_hooks.md#initasyncid-type-triggerasyncid-resource
 [`napi_add_async_cleanup_hook`]: #napi_add_async_cleanup_hook
@@ -6607,6 +6672,8 @@ the add-on's file name during loading.
 [`node_api_create_external_string_latin1`]: #node_api_create_external_string_latin1
 [`node_api_create_external_string_utf16`]: #node_api_create_external_string_utf16
 [`node_api_create_syntax_error`]: #node_api_create_syntax_error
+[`node_api_nogc_finalize`]: #node_api_nogc_finalize
+[`node_api_post_finalizer`]: #node_api_post_finalizer
 [`node_api_throw_syntax_error`]: #node_api_throw_syntax_error
 [`process.release`]: process.md#processrelease
 [`uv_ref`]: https://docs.libuv.org/en/v1.x/handle.html#c.uv_ref

doc/contributing/adding-new-napi-api.md

@@ -51,3 +51,16 @@ Node-API.
       to the decision to take an API out of experimental status.
     * The API **must** be implemented in a Node.js implementation with an
       alternate VM.
+
+Since the adoption of the policy whereby moving to a later version of Node-API
+from an earlier version may entail rework of existing code, it is possible to
+introduce modifications to already-released Node-APIs, as long as the
+modifications affect neither the ABI nor the API of earlier versions. Such
+modifications **must** be accompanied by an opt-out flag. This provides add-on
+maintainers who take advantage of the initial compile-time flag to track
+impending changes to Node-API with
+
+* a quick fix to the breakage caused,
+* a notification that such breakage is impending, and thus
+* a buffer to adoption above and beyond the one provided by the initial
+  compile-time flag.