[Bug report] macOS 11.3: GrandOrgue crashes from time to time

[ghost]

I observe GrandOrgue crashes from time to time. GrandOrgue disappears from the screen without an error message. Attached is a crash report.

GrandOrgue_2021-04-30-034234.crash.zip

[oleg68]

Do you use GO built by you or the one from Github release? Does the problem still exist?

[ghost]

Yes, I use the version from your website. And yes, it happens quite often. In most cases when closing the application, but sometimes when I open a window.

[oleg68]

Could you reproduce it with a build with debug info included and attach the crsash report ?https://github.com/oleg68/GrandOrgue/suites/2634692559/artifacts/57801114

[ghost]

Attached you will find an archive with the screenshot of an error message and a crash report. I had to start GO only twice.

Archiv.zip

[oleg68]

@uctcs Please try the build from there https://github.com/oleg68/GrandOrgue/actions/runs/807546730

Seems I've fixed the crashes.

[oleg68]

Progress bar is another crashing cause. I've pushed the fix. Try the build https://github.com/oleg68/GrandOrgue/actions/runs/807731228 when it becomes ready (green).

[oleg68]

@uctcs the new build is ready: https://github.com/oleg68/GrandOrgue/actions/runs/807731228

[ghost]

Still the same. I have to hide (cmd-h) and unhide GO once before it works correctly.

And I had one crash report less.

GrandOrgue_2021-05-03-210508.crash.zip

[oleg68]

What action was you doing when GO crashed?

[ghost]

This is hard to say. I do not see any crash, but when I look for the log files, the report is there.

I will try to leave this folder open to see when the report is created.

[oleg68]

Does GO crashes when opening or resizing pannels?

[oleg68]

This is hard to say. I do not see any crash, but when I look for the log files, the report is there.

The time logged in https://github.com/oleg68/GrandOrgue/files/6417073/GrandOrgue_2021-05-03-210508.crash.zip was 2021-05-03 19:51:33.152 +0200. But the build finished at Mon, 03 May 2021 18:47:27 GMT, i.e. 20:47:27 +0200. So your crash report is from previous build.

[ghost]

Attached you will find 3 more crash reports, all running your latest build (12). The first two reports were triggered as follows:

• I started GO
• I clicked the green button --> black screen
• Hitting Esc (twice)

The program crashes without an error message.

The third crash report was triggered as follows:

• I started the GO
• I hit cmd-h (the menu bar changes to another program, e.g. finder, but the window is still on the screen).
• I clicked on the GO icon in the dock
• I opened and closed a few panels
• I closed GO

After I closed GO the report appeared in the console. GO seemed to work normally until then.

Archive.zip

[oleg68]

@uctcs

I clicked the green button --> black screen

Which window did you click the green button on?

I closed GO

How did you close GO exactly? I cann't reproduce your stack of closing mentioned in the crash report.

[oleg68]

@uctcs Please try https://github.com/oleg68/GrandOrgue/actions/runs/809779497

The build has a workaround that prevents crashing on exit GO with the stack above.

I could not catch the root cause of the crash: seems some windows events are set in incorrect order or are sent twice, but I cann't reproduce it in my environment.

So it is possible that crash will appear with some another stack. If so attach the new crash report.

[ghost]

Yes, the close program crash seems to be tackled.

The other, which happens, when I go fullscreen without having hit cmd-h before is still present.

GrandOrgue_2021-05-04-214956.crash.zip

[ghost]

@uctcs

I clicked the green button --> black screen

Which window did you click the green button on?

The green button of the panel window. This main window, which has all menus does not need to be fullscreen. I tried it anyhow. Same effect -- the screen turns black.

I closed GO

How did you close GO exactly? I can't reproduce your stack of closing mentioned in the crash report.

Two options. When I move the mouse to the top of the screen I can close the program with the menu. If cmd-tab out of the black screen, I can right-click on the GO icon and choose 'Quit'.

[oleg68]

Try https://github.com/oleg68/GrandOrgue/actions/runs/812987602

[ghost]

Oleg, I am very sorry, but it still does not work. These videos used your latest build 18. I created 2 videos, which depict the problem.

Video 1: I started the video after GO was fully loaded. I clicked the green button and the screen turns black. I did not yet find a way to come out of the black screen apart from quitting the program. This is what I did.

Video 2: I started the video again after GO was fully loaded. At about 2 s I hit cmd-h. Normally the windows should disappear. But they stay on screen. But you see that the menu bar changes to the Finder. I click then on the dock icon and the menu changes back to GO. Now the green button work as expected. Side note: when the green button works correctly, the panels also open correctly.

Working with GO currently works pretty well after hitting once cmd-h and bringing GO back to front.

Video1.mov

The second video is too large for upload. You can download it here: https://www.dropbox.com/t/aQxpFitGky8wekfJ

[oleg68]

This issue is about crashing, not about the black screen. Are there still crashing or no?

[ghost]

My apologies! I got those 2 issues messed up.

No, I have not yet managed to crash GO again, although I tried hard.

[oleg68]

https://github.com/oleg68/GrandOrgue/releases/tag/0.3.1.2338-4.os