Internationalize the key binding for selecting a parent way #8298
Labels
accessibility
Relates to personal ability or assistive tools
keyboard
An issue with keyboard navigation, shortcuts, or input
localization
Adapting iD across languages, regions, and cultures
Milestone
ddf8682 changed the key binding for selecting a parent way (#8264) from ⌘↑ to | and made it so that repeatedly pressing | would toggle between a vertex and its parent way. | makes some sense on an English QWERTY keyboard, where
|
is strongly associated with{
and}
, but it’s problematic for users of other languages and keyboard layouts. For example, among Mac keyboard layouts:|
⌘↑ would’ve been more universal while remaining reasonably intuitive to English speakers. It could’ve formed part of a system of arrow shortcuts for navigating “up” and “down” among nodes, ways, and relations. It would be pretty straightforward to restore ⌘↑ as an alternative key binding for |, but it wouldn’t make sense to keep the toggling behavior with ⌘↑ – it would be necessary to introduce a ⌘↓ as well. Separate ⌘↑ and ⌘↓ shortcuts would be easier to describe in help than the current | toggle.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: