Compare AI chat like ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude etc

[rufuspollock]

With release of gemini seen a lot of discussion of type "Is Gemini better/worse than ChatGPT". Also personally interested as i use both an a bit tedious to copy and paste prompts between and then compare.

Idea is we can start here just with folks pasting their experiences.

My 2c so far is that i prefer Gemini often. There's something a bit richer about its responses.

Note

Originally started in https://github.com/orgs/datasets/discussions/389 Dec 2023

[rufuspollock]

Example: Bach's choral music

What are some of Bach's best choral music?

Gemini/Bard

Deciding the "best" of Bach's choral music is like picking a favorite star in the Milky Way – they're all brilliant and dazzling in their own way! However, I can guide you towards some of his most beloved and revered choral works, based on their popularity, emotional depth, and technical mastery:

Large-scale choral pieces:

• St. Matthew Passion: This monumental oratorio tells the story of Jesus' crucifixion and resurrection, featuring awe-inspiring choruses like "Kommt, ihr Töchter, helft mir klagen" and the heartbreaking "Erbarme dich, mein Gott."
• St. John Passion: Another powerful oratorio exploring Jesus' Passion, with highlights like the majestic "Christe, du Lamm Gottes" and the dramatic "O hilf, Christe, Gottes Sohn."
• B Minor Mass: One of the most significant sacred choral works ever written, encompassing the entire Ordinary of the Mass. Renowned for its expressive movements and intricate counterpoint, the "Gloria" and "Sanctus" are particularly captivating.
• Magnificat in D Major: A joyful and celebratory setting of the Virgin Mary's song of praise, with vibrant polyphony and uplifting choral passages.

Smaller choral works:

• Motets: Bach's six large-scale motets showcase his virtuosity in choral writing, ranging from the solemn introspection of "Jesu, meine Freude" to the playful energy of "Komm, Jesu, komm."
• Cantatas: With over 200 cantatas, there's a treasure trove to explore! Here are a few noteworthy ones:
  • "Jauchzet, frohlocket, auf zu prangen" (Christmas Oratorio): A festive opening chorus full of jubilation.
  • "Ich hatte viel Bekümmernis" (Cantata No. 21): A poignant expression of faith and resilience.
  • "Ein feste Burg ist unser Gott" (Cantata No. 80): A powerful hymn of steadfastness and trust in God.

Choral melodies:

• Bach's chorales, used both within larger works and as standalone hymns, are renowned for their simplicity and profound beauty. Try listening to a collection of chorales and exploring their subtle variations and emotional textures.

Ultimately, the best way to discover your own favorites is to delve into Bach's choral music yourself! Many recordings are available online or in libraries, so start exploring and let yourself be transported by the genius of his music.

Remember, your personal preferences and context will also influence your favorites. If you'd like further recommendations, feel free to tell me more about what kind of choral music you enjoy!

ChatGPT (4)

Johann Sebastian Bach, a master of Baroque music, composed numerous choral works that are widely celebrated for their complexity and beauty. Some of his best choral music includes:

1. Mass in B Minor (BWV 232): Often considered one of the greatest masterpieces of classical sacred music. The mass is a summation of his writing for voice and contains some of the most beautiful choral music he composed.

2. St. Matthew Passion (BWV 244): A monumental work telling the story of the Passion, from the Gospel of Matthew. It is known for its deep expressiveness and its grand scale.

3. St. John Passion (BWV 245): Similar in style to the St. Matthew Passion but somewhat shorter, this work is notable for its strong dramatic approach and its moving choral sections.

4. Christmas Oratorio (BWV 248): A series of six cantatas intended for performance on six feast days of Christmas. It's known for its joyful and festive music that celebrates the nativity.

5. Magnificat in D Major (BWV 243): A musical setting of the biblical canticle Magnificat. It is one of Bach's most popular vocal works and is often performed at Christmas time.

6. Motets: Bach’s motets, such as "Jesu, meine Freude" (BWV 227) and "Singet dem Herrn ein neues Lied" (BWV 225), are complex and richly textured choral works, known for their contrapuntal mastery.

These pieces represent the pinnacle of Baroque choral music and continue to be widely performed and recorded around the world.

[rufuspollock]

@davidgasquez writes:

The best large scale systematic comparison could be https://chat.lmsys.org

You can "play" with it and it'll send the prompt to a couple of LLMs for you to choose which one is a "better" answerk.

They have a leaderboard where they compute the LLMs ELO and other metrics!