Differences in formatting between ktlint and Android Studio

[PPetka]

Hi, I am having trouble with setting Android Studio so it exactly follows formatting applied by ktlint.
The style is set to official kotlin one.

I've done everything as described in your readme file (try to apply settings via --apply-to-idea-project Option1 , and also Option 2 and 3https://github.com/pinterest/ktlint#option-3

I guess the problem could be probably solved by applying some settings into .editorconfig file,
but I am not sure what property can cause it.
I had the same inconsistency with max line lenght property. Adding max_line_length=100 did solved the issue.

Screenshots before formatting

after formatting via Android Studio:

Any suggestions?

ktlint version: 0.32.0

[shashachu]

Hm.. I kind of surprised that AS formats it without that extra indent. What version of AS are you using?

[PPetka]

The newest one:

Android Studio 3.5.3
Build #AI-191.8026.42.35.6010548, built on November 15, 2019
JRE: 1.8.0_202-release-1483-b49-5587405 x86_64
JVM: OpenJDK 64-Bit Server VM by JetBrains s.r.o
macOS 10.14.6

But In older versions, it was exactly the same. Just didn't have time to take care of that.

[PPetka]

@shashachu I am posting my Code style settings imported from AS
I took it from Preferences -> Editor -> Code Style
Then there is a Scheme: where I can export settings.

I removed all languages but Kotlin, and left other settings that may be important.

Can you please check the diff with yours? Or at least post your configuration so I can manually spot the differences?

Thanks

kotlin-official-code-style.codestyle.json

{
  "schemeName": "kotlin-official-code-style",
  "version": "1.0",
  "codeStyle": {
    "all": {
      "formatter_off_tag": "@formatter:off",
      "formatter_on_tag": "@formatter:on",
      "formatter_tags_accept_regexp": false,
      "formatter_tags_enabled": false,
      "max_line_length": 100,
      "wrap_on_typing": false
    },
    "editorconfig": {
      "align_group_field_declarations": false,
      "space_after_colon": false,
      "space_after_comma": true,
      "space_before_colon": false,
      "space_before_comma": false,
      "spaces_around_assignment_operators": true
    },
    "kotlin": {
      "align_in_columns_case_branch": false,
      "align_multiline_binary_operation": false,
      "align_multiline_extends_list": false,
      "align_multiline_method_brackets": false,
      "align_multiline_parameters": false,
      "align_multiline_parameters_in_calls": false,
      "assignment_wrap": "normal",
      "blank_lines_after_class_header": 0,
      "blank_lines_around_block_when_branches": 0,
      "block_comment_at_first_column": true,
      "call_parameters_new_line_after_left_paren": true,
      "call_parameters_right_paren_on_new_line": true,
      "call_parameters_wrap": "on_every_item",
      "catch_on_new_line": false,
      "class_annotation_wrap": "split_into_lines",
      "code_style_defaults": "KOTLIN_OFFICIAL",
      "continuation_indent_for_chained_calls": false,
      "continuation_indent_for_expression_bodies": false,
      "continuation_indent_in_argument_lists": false,
      "continuation_indent_in_elvis": false,
      "continuation_indent_in_if_conditions": false,
      "continuation_indent_in_parameter_lists": false,
      "continuation_indent_in_supertype_lists": false,
      "continuation_indent_size": 4,
      "else_on_new_line": false,
      "enum_constants_wrap": "off",
      "extends_list_wrap": "normal",
      "field_annotation_wrap": "split_into_lines",
      "finally_on_new_line": false,
      "if_rparen_on_new_line": true,
      "import_nested_classes": false,
      "indent_size": 4,
      "indent_style": "space",
      "insert_whitespaces_in_simple_one_line_method": true,
      "keep_blank_lines_before_right_brace": 0,
      "keep_blank_lines_in_code": 1,
      "keep_blank_lines_in_declarations": 1,
      "keep_first_column_comment": true,
      "keep_indents_on_empty_lines": false,
      "keep_line_breaks": true,
      "lbrace_on_next_line": false,
      "line_comment_add_space": true,
      "line_comment_at_first_column": false,
      "method_annotation_wrap": "split_into_lines",
      "method_call_chain_wrap": "normal",
      "method_parameters_new_line_after_left_paren": true,
      "method_parameters_right_paren_on_new_line": true,
      "method_parameters_wrap": "on_every_item",
      "name_count_to_use_star_import": 2147483647,
      "name_count_to_use_star_import_for_members": 2147483647,
      "parameter_annotation_wrap": "off",
      "smart_tabs": false,
      "space_after_comma": true,
      "space_after_extend_colon": true,
      "space_after_type_colon": true,
      "space_before_catch_parentheses": true,
      "space_before_comma": false,
      "space_before_extend_colon": true,
      "space_before_for_parentheses": true,
      "space_before_if_parentheses": true,
      "space_before_lambda_arrow": true,
      "space_before_type_colon": false,
      "space_before_when_parentheses": true,
      "space_before_while_parentheses": true,
      "spaces_around_additive_operators": true,
      "spaces_around_assignment_operators": true,
      "spaces_around_equality_operators": true,
      "spaces_around_function_type_arrow": true,
      "spaces_around_logical_operators": true,
      "spaces_around_multiplicative_operators": true,
      "spaces_around_range": false,
      "spaces_around_relational_operators": true,
      "spaces_around_unary_operator": false,
      "spaces_around_when_arrow": true,
      "tab_width": 4,
      "variable_annotation_wrap": "off",
      "while_on_new_line": false,
      "wrap_elvis_expressions": 1,
      "wrap_expression_body_functions": 1,
      "wrap_first_method_in_call_chain": false
    },
    "properties": {
      "align_group_field_declarations": false
    }
  }
}

[xserxses]

I'm facing similar problem. :(

[romtsn]

I have a feeling that it was fixed in the recent versions, could you try it out with 0.36.0 @PPetka ?

[romtsn]

Closing this for now. If the issue is still existing in the latest version, please provide a reproducible code snippet.

[PPetka]

@romtsn I've done some testing and It feels like the problem was solved indeed!! Thank you!