VerticalDivider for PageLayout.Pane always initially renders as style 'none'

[Bestra]

Description

I'm using React Router to render several different pages that are laid out almost identically. They generally look like this:

<PageLayout>
  <PageLayout.Pane divider="line">
    {someContent}
  </PageLayout.Pane>
</PageLayout>

Each route renders a component with the same PageLayout.pane with a 'line' divider. When I switch routes, most of the DOM appears stable to my eyes, but there's a brief period where the vertical divider seems to disappear.

I investigated and found that this happens on initial render, and that I could recreate it via the storybook locally. In the video below I've set a breakpoint when the VerticalDivider renders. You'll see that in the first few renders, the divider doesn't show at all. On the third render it pops into view as a line the way I'd expect.

pagelayout-divider-rerenders.mp4

From the React devtools profiler , the VerticalDivider renders a total of 4 times. On the third render it finally becomes visible.

I set a logpoint in the PageLayout.Pane component to record its props over its renders. You'll see the responsiveVariant value changes from none to line. Each logpoint shows up twice since we're in strict mode.

This corresponds to the useMedia() hooks used by useResponsiveValue() going from false to true.

Under the hood useResponsiveValue() calls useMedia() with a defaultState value of false for all three viewport widths

react/src/hooks/useResponsiveValue.ts

Lines 52 to 54 in 1fd6d32

	const isNarrowViewport = useMedia(viewportRanges.narrow, false)
	const isRegularViewport = useMedia(viewportRanges.regular, false)
	const isWideViewport = useMedia(viewportRanges.wide, false)

and this basically forces us to return the fallback value on initial render, which is none for the VerticalDivider.

If I modify useResponsiveValue so that it doesn't pass a default, like this:

  const isNarrowViewport = useMedia(viewportRanges.narrow)
  const isRegularViewport = useMedia(viewportRanges.regular)
  const isWideViewport = useMedia(viewportRanges.wide)

The component initially renders as I'd expect. Would a change like this be possible or will it create problems for SSR? I see this comment:

react/src/hooks/useMedia.tsx

Lines 25 to 28 in 1fd6d32

	// Prevent a React hydration mismatch when a default value is provided by not defaulting to window.matchMedia(query).matches.
	if (defaultState !== undefined) {
	return defaultState
	}

Steps to reproduce

1. Open the storybook and navigate to /?path=/story/components-pagelayout--default
2. Set your Pane.divider.regular to be line

3. Remount the component by clicking the button on the top left

Version

v35.25.1

Browser

Chrome

[amrinder1189]

Hi @lesliecdubs @Bestra , can you please assign this bug to me .

[lesliecdubs]

@amrinder1189 thanks for offering to contribute! I'll assign to you. Let us know if you have questions while you work on this.

[github-actions]

Hi! This issue has been marked as stale because it has been open with no activity for 180 days. You can comment on the issue or remove the stale label to keep it open. If you do nothing, this issue will be closed in 7 days.

[github-actions]

Hi! This issue has been marked as stale because it has been open with no activity for 180 days. You can comment on the issue or remove the stale label to keep it open. If you do nothing, this issue will be closed in 7 days.