symfony/console recipe needs symfony/runtime as a dependency

[DanielBadura]

Hello here 👋
I just update some recipes via composer recipes:install --force -v vendor/package-name and a part of it was to update the symfony/console recipe (5.3.7). Now this concluded in a change of the bin/console file since #787 to use the runtime component.

To this point everything is fine, im just wondering if the recipe should use something which is not a dependency by the library itself. Because symfony/console is not requiring symfony/runtime i get now an error that the component is missing. I mean this is a simple fix to require the runtime component for sure but should the recipe have such an indirect dependency?

[nicolas-grekas]

Recipes can't help here as they don't define deps between packages they relate to.
I guess we cannot do anything, especially since this is a once in years kind of issue.

[DanielBadura]

I'm not so familiar with the recipes etc. just wondering if there is a possibility with checking if symfony/console and symfony/runtime is installed, then put these things there or something as a meta-recipe thing.

But im fine with "wont fix" was more a meta question :)