Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Incorrect parsing of function parameters and return values #128

Open
FotiadisM opened this issue Aug 15, 2023 · 1 comment
Open

Incorrect parsing of function parameters and return values #128

FotiadisM opened this issue Aug 15, 2023 · 1 comment

Comments

@FotiadisM
Copy link

Description

The parser fails to identify discrete parameter declarations and combines them under a single one. This behavior only occurs in unnamed parameters and when using the language built-in type map.

To reproduce

go mod init treesitter-error

create a main.go file with contents:

// main.go
package main

func namedParameters(s []string, i int, m map[int]int, e error) {
}

func unamedParameters([]string, int, map[int]int, error) {
}

func inReturns() ([]string, int, map[int]int, error) {
	return nil, 0, nil, nil
}

func main() {
	namedParameters(nil, 0, nil, nil)
	unamedParameters(nil, 0, nil, nil)
	_, _, _, _ = inReturns()
}

I am using the latest stable version of neovim, with the latest version of the go parser. The tree looks like this:

package_clause [0, 0] - [0, 12]
  package_identifier [0, 8] - [0, 12]
function_declaration [2, 0] - [3, 1]
  name: identifier [2, 5] - [2, 20]
  parameters: parameter_list [2, 20] - [2, 63]
    parameter_declaration [2, 21] - [2, 31]
      name: identifier [2, 21] - [2, 22]
      type: slice_type [2, 23] - [2, 31]
        element: type_identifier [2, 25] - [2, 31]
    parameter_declaration [2, 33] - [2, 38]
      name: identifier [2, 33] - [2, 34]
      type: type_identifier [2, 35] - [2, 38]
    parameter_declaration [2, 40] - [2, 53]
      name: identifier [2, 40] - [2, 41]
      type: map_type [2, 42] - [2, 53]
        key: type_identifier [2, 46] - [2, 49]
        value: type_identifier [2, 50] - [2, 53]
    parameter_declaration [2, 55] - [2, 62]
      name: identifier [2, 55] - [2, 56]
      type: type_identifier [2, 57] - [2, 62]
  body: block [2, 64] - [3, 1]
function_declaration [5, 0] - [6, 1]
  name: identifier [5, 5] - [5, 21]
  parameters: parameter_list [5, 21] - [5, 56]
    parameter_declaration [5, 22] - [5, 30]
      type: slice_type [5, 22] - [5, 30]
        element: type_identifier [5, 24] - [5, 30]
    parameter_declaration [5, 32] - [5, 48]                             // NOTE THE ERROR HERE
      name: identifier [5, 32] - [5, 35]
      name: identifier [5, 37] - [5, 40]
      type: array_type [5, 40] - [5, 48]
        length: identifier [5, 41] - [5, 44]
        element: type_identifier [5, 45] - [5, 48]
    parameter_declaration [5, 50] - [5, 55]
      type: type_identifier [5, 50] - [5, 55]
  body: block [5, 57] - [6, 1]
function_declaration [8, 0] - [10, 1]
  name: identifier [8, 5] - [8, 14]
  parameters: parameter_list [8, 14] - [8, 16]
  result: parameter_list [8, 17] - [8, 52]
    parameter_declaration [8, 18] - [8, 26]
      type: slice_type [8, 18] - [8, 26]
        element: type_identifier [8, 20] - [8, 26]
    parameter_declaration [8, 28] - [8, 44]                            // NOTE THE ERROR HERE
      name: identifier [8, 28] - [8, 31]
      name: identifier [8, 33] - [8, 36]
      type: array_type [8, 36] - [8, 44]
        length: identifier [8, 37] - [8, 40]
        element: type_identifier [8, 41] - [8, 44]
    parameter_declaration [8, 46] - [8, 51]
      type: type_identifier [8, 46] - [8, 51]
  body: block [8, 53] - [10, 1]
    return_statement [9, 1] - [9, 24]
      expression_list [9, 8] - [9, 24]
        nil [9, 8] - [9, 11]
        int_literal [9, 13] - [9, 14]
        nil [9, 16] - [9, 19]
        nil [9, 21] - [9, 24]
function_declaration [12, 0] - [16, 1]
  name: identifier [12, 5] - [12, 9]
  parameters: parameter_list [12, 9] - [12, 11]
  body: block [12, 12] - [16, 1]
    expression_statement [13, 1] - [13, 34]
      call_expression [13, 1] - [13, 34]
        function: identifier [13, 1] - [13, 16]
        arguments: argument_list [13, 16] - [13, 34]
          nil [13, 17] - [13, 20]
          int_literal [13, 22] - [13, 23]
          nil [13, 25] - [13, 28]
          nil [13, 30] - [13, 33]
    expression_statement [14, 1] - [14, 35]
      call_expression [14, 1] - [14, 35]
        function: identifier [14, 1] - [14, 17]
        arguments: argument_list [14, 17] - [14, 35]
          nil [14, 18] - [14, 21]
          int_literal [14, 23] - [14, 24]
          nil [14, 26] - [14, 29]
          nil [14, 31] - [14, 34]
    assignment_statement [15, 1] - [15, 25]
      left: expression_list [15, 1] - [15, 11]
        identifier [15, 1] - [15, 2]
        identifier [15, 4] - [15, 5]
        identifier [15, 7] - [15, 8]
        identifier [15, 10] - [15, 11]
      right: expression_list [15, 14] - [15, 25]
        call_expression [15, 14] - [15, 25]
          function: identifier [15, 14] - [15, 23]
          arguments: argument_list [15, 23] - [15, 25]

Screenshot from 2023-08-10 12-25-50

@amaanq
Copy link
Member

amaanq commented Aug 15, 2023

This isn't really solvable without the external scanner or reserved words api, I think the latter is a better solution but no clue when that could land.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants