Remix - Leaving page after nuqs URI manipulation gives a 404.

[geemanjs]

Context

What's your version of nuqs?

2.3.1

What framework are you using?

• ✅ Remix

Which version of your framework are you using?

2.15.2

Description

404 returned after clicking on a Link after a page using nuqs has been loaded. It's relatively inconsistent but downgrading nuqs to 2.2.3 and the issue goes away. I would take a punt that nuqs is plugging into a listener / event and overwriting something that remix uses behind the scenes. I originally thought it was something to do with Lazy route discover as the issue manifests in a similar way to some of the remix errors being talked about others have seen. But I disabled this flag and the 404's kept on coming before realising it only happened after visiting a page where nuqs was in use.

On a unrelated note:
I also had issue with the change in behaviour between 2.2.3 and 2.3.0 of shallow:true/false with remix. It was basically a "breaking change" for remix apps in a "minor version" upgrade.

Reproduction

I'll work to try and do this - very busy this week - but thought I'd raise the issue here in case anyone else sees it. The solution for me was to downgrade nuqs 2.2.3 for now.

[franky47]

Thanks for the report, is the page you are linking to also using nuqs or not at all? I'm going to try and replicate this on my end, although it would help to find a consistently reproducible case that I can e2e test against to avoid regressions.

I also had issue with the change in behaviour between 2.2.3 and 2.3.0 of shallow:true/false with remix. It was basically a "breaking change" for remix apps in a "minor version" upgrade.

This "breaking change" was a fix of an incorrect behaviour introduced in 2.0.0. Documentation states that updates with shallow: true (the default) are client-only and should not call the server, which wasn't the case when we first introduced Remix / React Router support.

[franky47]

I can't immediately reproduce it in #885, feel free to review the differences if you find a reproducible case on your end.