Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Taxonomy relationships error re: tribes & subfamilies #2074

Closed
DerekSikes opened this issue May 9, 2019 · 9 comments
Closed

Taxonomy relationships error re: tribes & subfamilies #2074

DerekSikes opened this issue May 9, 2019 · 9 comments

Comments

@DerekSikes
Copy link

Issue Documentation is http://handbook.arctosdb.org/how_to/How-to-Use-Issues-in-Arctos.html

Describe the bug
A clear and concise description of what the bug is.

http://arctos.database.museum/name/Leiodinae
Leiodinae → potential alternate spelling → Leiodini
Leiodini → potential alternate spelling → Leiodinae

In animals, subfamilies end in "-inae" and tribes (which are children of subfamilies) end in "-ini"

The above relationship assumption is erroneous - a tribe is not an alternate spelling of a subfamily. I assume since this happened here it's a widespread problem (all tribes and subfamilies are indicated as alternate spellings of each other)? In any case, it needs to be fixed with these relationships removed.

To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Go to '...'
  2. Click on '....'
  3. Scroll down to '....'
  4. See error

Expected behavior
A clear and concise description of what you expected to happen.

Screenshots
If applicable, add screenshots to help explain your problem.

** Data**
If this involves external data, attach the actual data that caused the problem. Do not attach a transformation or subset. You may ZIP most formats to attach, or request a Box email address for very large files.

Desktop (please complete the following information):

  • OS: [e.g. iOS]
  • Browser [e.g. chrome, safari]
  • Version [e.g. 22]

Additional context
Add any other context about the problem here.

Priority
Please assign a priority-label.
high

@dustymc
Copy link
Contributor

dustymc commented May 9, 2019

See #757 and http://arctos.database.museum/info/ctDocumentation.cfm?table=CTTAXON_RELATION

I don't think this is a problem; the source of the data is clearly documented, false positives are not unexpected, and the tools these data drive are exclusively for discovery where false positives are the least-evil evil.

#757 (comment) is a path to prevent these; new Issue if we want to go there.

Here's what 'Arctos' subfamilies end in:

SELECT  SUBSTR(term, -4) last4, count(*) c FROM taxon_term where term_type='subfamily' and source='Arctos' group by SUBSTR(term, -4) order by SUBSTR(term, -4);

LAST4		    C
---------- ----------
aina		    1
ceae		    1
cini		    1
dina		    1
edis		  160
hina		    2
idae		  188
idea		    1
iini		    1
inae	       445862
ites		    1
les'		    8
lini		    1
nae		    1
neae		    1
niae		    1
nida		    1
nina		    2
nnae		    1
omae		    1
pida		    1
reae		    1
rina		    1
rini		   22
tain		    1
ubae		    1
unae		    1
ynae		    2
zini		    1

and tribes

SELECT  SUBSTR(term, -3) last3, count(*) c FROM taxon_term where term_type='tribe' and source='Arctos' group by SUBSTR(term, -3) order by SUBSTR(term, -3);

LAST3		    C
---------- ----------
ata		   32
dis		    2
hon		    1
ina		   74
ini	       183257
nae		    2
nea		  195
nii		   17


Here are the names with the most 'interesting' subfamily.


UAM@ARCTOS> select scientific_name from taxon_name where taxon_name_id in (select taxon_name_id from taxon_term where term='Didymozoidae ''juveniles''' and source='Arctos');

SCIENTIFIC_NAME
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Monilicaecum
Torticaecum
Torticaecum fenestratum
Torticaecum nipponicum
Allomonilicaecum
Pseudoanacetabulum
Anesophagus
Monilicaecum ventricosum

Looks like they came from #1936

@dustymc dustymc added this to the Needs Discussion milestone May 9, 2019
@DerekSikes
Copy link
Author

DerekSikes commented May 10, 2019 via email

@sharpphyl
Copy link

I agree with Derek that the two names should be in the same rank to be considered alternative spellings. We have a similar example:

Cypraeini → potential alternate spelling → Cypraeinae
Cypraeinae → potential alternate spelling → Cypraeini

But both appear at their appropriate rank in the WoRMS (via Arctos) classification

Screen Shot 2019-05-13 at 9 50 13 AM

@dustymc
Copy link
Contributor

dustymc commented May 13, 2019

Relationships are between names.

Names are not ranked.

The metadata do not necessarily contain the name at all, or may re-use it in various capacities.

A few thousand of these involve infraspecific rank variations.

@sharpphyl
Copy link

It sounds like you don't know if the two terms appear in the same classification, but would be something to exclude if possible. Or does your code allow you to exclude words that only differ by the ending "i" vs. "ae". That would help with the subfamily vs tribe concern that Derek raised.

@dustymc
Copy link
Contributor

dustymc commented May 15, 2019

I very explicitly don't CARE about classifications for this. Classifications come and go, and those that exist contain all sorts of garbage. This is an attempt - a surprisingly successful one from my perspective - to provide a pathway to 'dark' specimens obscured by a broken system (and the occasional 'everyone accepting what some random person did a few times for some reason'). Looking at anything beyond the name is going to hinder that. ~160K names now, possibly for the first time ever, do what they are intended to do! 212,542 specimens suddenly become discoverable! There's some 'bycatch' but I think it's fairly minimal, is clearly documented, and there's a path to separate the wheat from the chaff if someone with the knowledge to do so wants to.

I can add or remove patterns to the code. This one would drop at least the below, which I think are not intended to be different things. I'm not sure how many of these there are (or how many will be introduced with our next import), this is just the first I found.

Nitzschia zabelinae Nitzschia zabelini

@dustymc
Copy link
Contributor

dustymc commented May 15, 2019

I think I may have found a workable compromise. If I don't create relationships for monomials ending in [ini/inae] and consisting only of letters, I think I'll avoid creating the most obvious "cross-rank" relationships and still get the binomials, botanical hybrids, and things that contain dashes (all of which are otherwise involved and used interchangeably so need relationships).

Does that sound reasonable, and are there any other patterns I should add to this?

Here's what I intend to remove relationships for. Do any of these look like anything other than 'same root, different rank'?

select a.scientific_name an,b.scientific_name bn from taxon_name a,taxon_name b, taxon_relations
where a.taxon_name_id=taxon_relations.taxon_name_id and
 b.taxon_name_id=taxon_relations.related_taxon_name_id and
taxon_relationship='potential alternate spelling' and
a.scientific_name like '%inae' and
b.scientific_name like '%ini' and
not regexp_like(b.scientific_name,'[^[:alpha:]]') and
not regexp_like(a.scientific_name,'[^[:alpha:]]')
order by 
a.scientific_name ,b.scientific_name 
 11  ;

AN			       BN
------------------------------ ------------------------------
Abacioninae		       Abacionini
Abderitinae		       Abderitini
Acanthopetalinae	       Acanthopetalini
Achatininae		       Achatinini
Adacninae		       Adacnini
Agelaiinae		       Agelaiini
Aglycyderinae		       Aglycyderini
Agriotheriinae		       Agriotheriini
Ailuropodinae		       Ailuropodini
Akidinae		       Akidini
Alcelaphinae		       Alcelaphini
Alcinae 		       Alcini
Aleocharinae		       Aleocharini
Aleuropteryginae	       Aleuropterygini
Allaeochelyinae 	       Allaeochelyini
Alleculinae		       Alleculini
Alogolykinae		       Alogolykini
Alophinae		       Alophini
Alopiinae		       Alopiini
Alysiinae		       Alysiini
Amblyoponinae		       Amblyoponini
Ambrysinae		       Ambrysini
Amoriinae		       Amoriini
Amplininae		       Amplinini
Anaptomorphinae 	       Anaptomorphini
Anarthrurinae		       Anarthrurini
Anaspidinae		       Anaspidini
Anatinae		       Anatini
Ancylinae		       Ancylini
Aneuretinae		       Aneuretini
Anguinae		       Anguini
Anobiinae		       Anobiini
Anomalinae		       Anomalini
Anomaloninae		       Anomalonini
Anourosoricinae 	       Anourosoricini
Anserinae		       Anserini
Anthracinae		       Anthracini
Anthroleucosomatinae	       Anthroleucosomatini
Anzoplaninae		       Anzoplanini
Aotinae 		       Aotini
Aphelidesminae		       Aphelidesmini
Aphidinae		       Aphidini
Aphodiinae		       Aphodiini
Apoderinae		       Apoderini
Archepyginae		       Archepygini
Archiulinae		       Archiulini
Ardeinae		       Ardeini
Arenariinae		       Arenariini
Artacaminae		       Artacamini
Arthrosphaerinae	       Arthrosphaerini
Arvicolinae		       Arvicolini
Astartilinae		       Astartilini
Atelinae		       Atelini
Atomariinae		       Atomariini
Atoportuninae		       Atoportunini
Attemsiinae		       Attemsiini
Aulatornoceratinae	       Aulatornoceratini
Aulonocneminae		       Aulonocnemini
Auriculispininae	       Auriculispinini
Australiosomatinae	       Australiosomatini
Autolytinae		       Autolytini
Avitortorinae		       Avitortorini
Aythyinae		       Aythyini
Baeinae 		       Baeini
Baeninae		       Baenini
Bagoinae		       Bagoini
Banchinae		       Banchini
Belinae 		       Belini
Belostomatinae		       Belostomatini
Bembidiinae		       Bembidiini
Bilselibatinae		       Bilselibatini
Bistolidinae		       Bistolidini
Blacinae		       Blacini
Blaniulinae		       Blaniulini
Blattellinae		       Blattellini
Bombyliinae		       Bombyliini
Borophaginae		       Borophagini
Bostrichinae		       Bostrichini
Botaurinae		       Botaurini
Brachyderinae		       Brachyderini
Brachyericinae		       Brachyericini
Bradybaeninae		       Bradybaenini
Bromiinae		       Bromiini
Brontinae		       Brontini
Broscinae		       Broscini
Bruchinae		       Bruchini
Buccininae		       Buccinini
Buccinulinae		       Buccinulini
Buprestinae		       Buprestini
Busyconinae		       Busyconini
Buzoniinae		       Buzoniini
Bythoscopinae		       Bythoscopini
Caenolestinae		       Caenolestini
Calliotropinae		       Calliotropini
Calyptophyllinae	       Calyptophyllini
Camelinae		       Camelini
Campodinae		       Campodini
Camponotinae		       Camponotini
Campopleginae		       Campoplegini
Candoninae		       Candonini
Cantharinae		       Cantharini
Capreolinae		       Capreolini
Carabinae		       Carabini
Cassidinae		       Cassidini
Castanotheriinae	       Castanotheriini
Castoroidinae		       Castoroidini
Catantopinae		       Catantopini
Catharosomatinae	       Catharosomatini
Cephalciinae		       Cephalciini
Cephalophinae		       Cephalophini
Cerastodermatinae	       Cerastodermatini
Ceratocanthinae 	       Ceratocanthini
Cereopsinae		       Cereopsini
Cervinae		       Cervini
Chaoiellinae		       Chaoiellini
Chauliognathinae	       Chauliognathini
Cheliferinae		       Cheliferini
Chelodesminae		       Chelodesmini
Cheloninae		       Chelonini
Chilecarinae		       Chilecarini
Chironominae		       Chironomini
Chlamydinae		       Chlamydini
Chonaphinae		       Chonaphini
Choneiulinae		       Choneiulini
Choraginae		       Choragini
Chrysidinae		       Chrysidini
Chrysochroinae		       Chrysochroini
Chrysopinae		       Chrysopini
Chrysopsinae		       Chrysopsini
Cicadellinae		       Cicadellini
Cimberidinae		       Cimberidini
Clastopterinae		       Clastopterini
Clausiliinae		       Clausiliini
Cleonyminae		       Cleonymini
Clunioninae		       Clunionini
Clytrinae		       Clytrini
Coelometopinae		       Coelometopini
Coelozoninae		       Coelozonini
Colinae 		       Colini
Colubrinae		       Colubrini
Colymbetinae		       Colymbetini
Comatulinae		       Comatulini
Conchoeciinae		       Conchoeciini
Corixinae		       Corixini
Cornalatinae		       Cornalatini
Corophiinae		       Corophiini
Corticariinae		       Corticariini
Cretatermitinae 	       Cretatermitini
Cretochodaeinae 	       Cretochodaeini
Cretogeotrupinae	       Cretogeotrupini
Cretomelolonthinae	       Cretomelolonthini
Cricetodontinae 	       Cricetodontini
Criocerinae		       Criocerini
Crocidosoricinae	       Crocidosoricini
Crocidurinae		       Crocidurini
Crouzeliinae		       Crouzeliini
Cryphocricinae		       Cryphocricini
Cryptinae		       Cryptini
Cryptocephalinae	       Cryptocephalini
Cryptodesminae		       Cryptodesmini
Cryptophaginae		       Cryptophagini
Cryptorhynchinae	       Cryptorhynchini
Ctenodactylinae 	       Ctenodactylini
Culicinae		       Culicini
Cybocephalinae		       Cybocephalini
Cyclominae		       Cyclomini
Cyclophorinae		       Cyclophorini
Cyclostremellinae	       Cyclostremellini
Cydninae		       Cydnini
Cylapinae		       Cylapini
Cylindroiulinae 	       Cylindroiulini
Cymbiinae		       Cymbiini
Cyphagoginae		       Cyphagogini
Cypraeinae		       Cypraeini
Cypridininae		       Cypridinini
Cyrtacanthacridinae	       Cyrtacanthacridini
Cytherinae		       Cytherini
Darniopseinae		       Darniopseini
Dasypodainae		       Dasypodaini
Dasyurinae		       Dasyurini
Dendrocygninae		       Dendrocygnini
Denticollinae		       Denticollini
Deraeocorinae		       Deraeocorini
Derbinae		       Derbini
Dermestinae		       Dermestini
Desmatosuchinae 	       Desmatosuchini
Desmoninae		       Desmonini
Desmoscolecinae 	       Desmoscolecini
Diaperinae		       Diaperini
Dicerorhininae		       Dicerorhinini
Dictyoclostinae 	       Dictyoclostini
Dictyopterinae		       Dictyopterini
Didymozoinae		       Didymozoini
Dinidorinae		       Dinidorini
Diodontodesminae	       Diodontodesmini
Discocephalinae 	       Discocephalini
Dolabriferinae		       Dolabriferini
Dolichoderinae		       Dolichoderini
Dolisteninae		       Dolistenini
Donaciinae		       Donaciini
Doryctinae		       Doryctini
Dorypetalinae		       Dorypetalini
Drosophilinae		       Drosophilini
Dryophthorinae		       Dryophthorini
Dryopithecinae		       Dryopithecini
Durgellinae		       Durgellini
Dytiscinae		       Dytiscini
Eccoptarthrinae 	       Eccoptarthrini
Eccoptothoracinae	       Eccoptothoracini
Elampinae		       Elampini
Elaphrinae		       Elaphrini
Elasmatininae		       Elasmatinini
Elaterinae		       Elaterini
Elephantinae		       Elephantini
Eninae			       Enini
Entiminae		       Entimini
Eodichrominae		       Eodichromini
Eolachesillinae 	       Eolachesillini
Eotomariinae		       Eotomariini
Ephemerellinae		       Ephemerellini
Ephialtinae		       Ephialtini
Ephydrinae		       Ephydrini
Epilachninae		       Epilachnini
Epyrinae		       Epyrini
Erinaceinae		       Erinaceini
Erirhininae		       Erirhinini
Eristalinae		       Eristalini
Erroneinae		       Erroneini
Erythrhacinae		       Erythrhacini
Erythropinae		       Erythropini
Euaesthetinae		       Euaesthetini
Eualopiinae		       Eualopiini
Euarchistigmatinae	       Euarchistigmatini
Eucneminae		       Eucnemini
Eucradinae		       Eucradini
Eugnominae		       Eugnomini
Eulophinae		       Eulophini
Eumerinae		       Eumerini
Euparagiinae		       Euparagiini
Euphractinae		       Euphractini
Euryurinae		       Euryurini
Euxinopetalinae 	       Euxinopetalini
Evacanthinae		       Evacanthini
Eviulisomatinae 	       Eviulisomatini
Falcitornoceratinae	       Falcitornoceratini
Felinae 		       Felini
Ferrissinae		       Ferrissini
Flaviagaminae		       Flaviagamini
Formicinae		       Formicini
Fraterculinae		       Fraterculini
Gabbioceratinae 	       Gabbioceratini
Galericinae		       Galericini
Galerucinae		       Galerucini
Garnieriinae		       Garnieriini
Gastrosaccinae		       Gastrosaccini
Geomitrinae		       Geomitrini
Geosaurinae		       Geosaurini
Gerrinae		       Gerrini
Ghilarovitinae		       Ghilarovitini
Giganotosaurinae	       Giganotosaurini
Gigantoproductinae	       Gigantoproductini
Glomerinae		       Glomerini
Glossomorphitinae	       Glossomorphitini
Glyptapinae		       Glyptapini
Glyptodontinae		       Glyptodontini
Gomphaeschninae 	       Gomphaeschnini
Gomphodesminae		       Gomphodesmini
Gonapodasmiinae 	       Gonapodasmiini
Gondvanoaphidinae	       Gondvanoaphidini
Grammatodontinae	       Grammatodontini
Graphisterninae 	       Graphisternini
Greenideinae		       Greenideini
Gryllinae		       Gryllini
Gryphaeinae		       Gryphaeini
Haploglomerinae 	       Haploglomerini
Harpagophorinae 	       Harpagophorini
Harpalinae		       Harpalini
Hauttecoeuriinae	       Hauttecoeuriini
Helicellinae		       Helicellini
Helicinae		       Helicini
Helicocryptinae 	       Helicocryptini
Helminthoglyptinae	       Helminthoglyptini
Hemerodromiinae 	       Hemerodromiini
Hemirhipidiinae 	       Hemirhipidiini
Hertigiinae		       Hertigiini
Hesioninae		       Hesionini
Heteromysinae		       Heteromysini
Heteropezinae		       Heteropezini
Hippotheriinae		       Hippotheriini
Hirudisomatinae 	       Hirudisomatini
Hispinae		       Hispini
Hodotermitinae		       Hodotermitini
Holdhausiellinae	       Holdhausiellini
Holocompsinae		       Holocompsini
Holoptilinae		       Holoptilini
Hormiinae		       Hormiini
Humboldtianinae 	       Humboldtianini
Hyainailourinae 	       Hyainailourini
Hybotinae		       Hybotini
Hydnocerinae		       Hydnocerini
Hydrophilinae		       Hydrophilini
Hydroporinae		       Hydroporini
Hygromiinae		       Hygromiini
Hypolestinae		       Hypolestini
Hyriinae		       Hyriini
Ichneutinae		       Ichneutini
Idiocerinae		       Idiocerini
Ischyrocerinae		       Ischyrocerini
Julinae 		       Julini
Karadagithyridinae	       Karadagithyridini
Kararhynchinae		       Kararhynchini
Koellikeriinae		       Koellikeriini
Kudakrumiinae		       Kudakrumiini
Kurmademydinae		       Kurmademydini
Labrinae		       Labrini
Lachninae		       Lachnini
Lagomerycinae		       Lagomerycini
Lagriinae		       Lagriini
Lagrioidinae		       Lagrioidini
Laminiferinae		       Laminiferini
Lamprosomatinae 	       Lamprosomatini
Lampyrinae		       Lampyrini
Larrinae		       Larrini
Lasiopterinae		       Lasiopterini
Leiinae 		       Leiini
Leptarctinae		       Leptarctini
Leptaxinae		       Leptaxini
Leptodesminae		       Leptodesmini
Leptoiulinae		       Leptoiulini
Leptomysinae		       Leptomysini
Leptorussinae		       Leptorussini
Lepturinae		       Lepturini
Lindeniinae		       Lindeniini
Lissopyginae		       Lissopygini
Lithurginae		       Lithurgini
Lixinae 		       Lixini
Lobodontinae		       Lobodontini
Lomatiinae		       Lomatiini
Lottiinae		       Lottiini
Luriinae		       Luriini
Lysinoinae		       Lysinoini
Macraulacinae		       Macraulacini
Macropidinae		       Macropidini
Macropodaphidinae	       Macropodaphidini
Macropsinae		       Macropsini
Magdalinae		       Magdalini
Mancomysinae		       Mancomysini
Manitshinae		       Manitshini
Marginellinae		       Marginellini
Marioutinae		       Marioutini
Marmosinae		       Marmosini
Marptodesminae		       Marptodesmini
Mastiginae		       Mastigini
Mastigophorophyllinae	       Mastigophorophyllini
Megachilinae		       Megachilini
Megaspilinae		       Megaspilini
Megatominae		       Megatomini
Megatrematinae		       Megatrematini
Melanosaurinae		       Melanosaurini
Melaphinae		       Melaphini
Meloinae		       Meloini
Melolonthinae		       Melolonthini
Mentissoideinae 	       Mentissoideini
Mephitinae		       Mephitini
Merganettinae		       Merganettini
Merginae		       Mergini
Mesoblaniulinae 	       Mesoblaniulini
Mesocupedinae		       Mesocupedini
Mesophyletinae		       Mesophyletini
Metaconchoeciinae	       Metaconchoeciini
Meteorinae		       Meteorini
Metopininae		       Metopinini
Metrioxeninae		       Metrioxenini
Micracidinae		       Micracidini
Microbrachysomatinae	       Microbrachysomatini
Microcystinae		       Microcystini
Microdontomerinae	       Microdontomerini
Migadopinae		       Migadopini
Mirinae 		       Mirini
Mogoplistinae		       Mogoplistini
Molytinae		       Molytini
Monachinae		       Monachini
Mongolochamopinae	       Mongolochamopini
Monodontomerinae	       Monodontomerini
Mordellinae		       Mordellini
Muntiacinae		       Muntiacini
Mustelinae		       Mustelini
Mutillinae		       Mutillini
Myophorellinae		       Myophorellini
Myrmicinae		       Myrmicini
Mysinae 		       Mysini
Mystriosuchinae 	       Mystriosuchini
Mythicomyiinae		       Mythicomyiini
Nanophyinae		       Nanophyini
Nebriinae		       Nebriini
Necydalinae		       Necydalini
Neilsoniinae		       Neilsoniini
Nemasomatinae		       Nemasomatini
Nematinae		       Nematini
Nematobothriinae	       Nematobothriini
Neniinae		       Neniini
Neoatractosomatinae	       Neoatractosomatini
Neoatractosominae	       Neoatractosomini
Neodidymozoinae 	       Neodidymozoini
Neolepadinae		       Neolepadini
Neophyllaphidinae	       Neophyllaphidini
Nilioninae		       Nilionini
Niponiinae		       Niponiini
Nipponortheziinae	       Nipponortheziini
Nitidulinae		       Nitidulini
Nopoiulinae		       Nopoiulini
Notarchinae		       Notarchini
Noterinae		       Noterini
Notonectinae		       Notonectini
Nyctoporinae		       Nyctoporini
Nymphalinae		       Nymphalini
Nyssoninae		       Nyssonini
Ochthebiinae		       Ochthebiini
Odobeninae		       Odobenini
Odontopyginae		       Odontopygini
Odostomiinae		       Odostomiini
Okeanobatinae		       Okeanobatini
Omaliinae		       Omaliini
Omophroninae		       Omophronini
Omorginae		       Omorgini
Oncoiulinae		       Oncoiulini
Ophiodrominae		       Ophiodromini
Oposispinae		       Oposispini
Orbiculopectininae	       Orbiculopectinini
Orcinae 		       Orcini
Orgilinae		       Orgilini
Origmatogoninae 	       Origmatogonini
Orodesminae		       Orodesmini
Ortheziinae		       Ortheziini
Orthocentrinae		       Orthocentrini
Orthochordeumatinae	       Orthochordeumatini
Orthognathinae		       Orthognathini
Otodesminae		       Otodesmini
Otomyinae		       Otomyini
Oxydesminae		       Oxydesmini
Oxytelinae		       Oxytelini
Pachybolinae		       Pachybolini
Pachycephalosaurinae	       Pachycephalosaurini
Pachydominae		       Pachydomini
Pachyiulinae		       Pachyiulini
Pachyrhinosaurinae	       Pachyrhinosaurini
Pacificellinae		       Pacificellini
Paectophyllinae 	       Paectophyllini
Paederinae		       Paederini
Palaeoaphalarinae	       Palaeoaphalarini
Palaeosiphoninae	       Palaeosiphonini
Palaeotraginae		       Palaeotragini
Paleocartinae		       Paleocartini
Palliolinae		       Palliolini
Palpomyiinae		       Palpomyiini
Pancolinae		       Pancolini
Pandirodesminae 	       Pandirodesmini
Paracypridinae		       Paracypridini
Paradacninae		       Paradacnini
Paradoxosomatinae	       Paradoxosomatini
Paramyinae		       Paramyini
Parandrinae		       Parandrini
Passalinae		       Passalini
Patelloidinae		       Patelloidini
Patrobinae		       Patrobini
Paurophlebiinae 	       Paurophlebiini
Pectininae		       Pectinini
Pediculariinae		       Pediculariini
Pedinae 		       Pedini
Pelecotominae		       Pelecotomini
Peradectinae		       Peradectini
Peridontopyginae	       Peridontopygini
Petrolestinae		       Petrolestini
Phaedusinae		       Phaedusini
Philanthinae		       Philanthini
Philopinninae		       Philopinnini
Phloeocharinae		       Phloeocharini
Phygadeuontinae 	       Phygadeuontini
Phyllobaeninae		       Phyllobaenini
Piestinae		       Piestini
Pimeliinae		       Pimeliini
Pimplinae		       Pimplini
Pissodinae		       Pissodini
Planorbinae		       Planorbini
Platypleurinae		       Platypleurini
Platyrhacinae		       Platyrhacini
Pleistacanthinae	       Pleistacanthini
Pleuronectinae		       Pleuronectini
Plicatiferinae		       Plicatiferini
Podagrioninae		       Podagrionini
Polistinae		       Polistini
Polyglyphanodontinae	       Polyglyphanodontini
Polyzoniinae		       Polyzoniini
Pomatiopsinae		       Pomatiopsini
Priacminae		       Priacmini
Productinae		       Productini
Productininae		       Productinini
Proerrhominae		       Proerrhomini
Promecopinae		       Promecopini
Prometheomyinae 	       Prometheomyini
Prosotropinae		       Prosotropini
Psaphodesminae		       Psaphodesmini
Psectrosciarinae	       Psectrosciarini
Pselaphinae		       Pselaphini
Pseudocypraeinae	       Pseudocypraeini
Pterocyclinae		       Pterocyclini
Pterodesminae		       Pterodesmini
Pteromyinae		       Pteromyini
Pterostichinae		       Pterostichini
Ptininae		       Ptinini
Ptyoiulinae		       Ptyoiulini
Pustulariinae		       Pustulariini
Pycnodontinae		       Pycnodontini
Pycnomerinae		       Pycnomerini
Pyramidellinae		       Pyramidellini
Pyrgomatinae		       Pyrgomatini
Pyrophorinae		       Pyrophorini
Quadratotrigoniinae	       Quadratotrigoniini
Rhinorhynchinae 	       Rhinorhynchini
Rhynchodeminae		       Rhynchodemini
Rhynchophorinae 	       Rhynchophorini
Rothenbuehleriinae	       Rothenbuehleriini
Rygmodinae		       Rygmodini
Saltasaurinae		       Saltasaurini
Saurolophinae		       Saurolophini
Scaphidiinae		       Scaphidiini
Scaritinae		       Scaritini
Scelioninae		       Scelionini
Sceliphrinae		       Sceliphrini
Schizochoerinae 	       Schizochoerini
Schizopetalinae 	       Schizopetalini
Sciomyzinae		       Sciomyzini
Sciophilinae		       Sciophilini
Scleroderminae		       Sclerodermini
Sclerogibbinae		       Sclerogibbini
Scolytinae		       Scolytini
Scutinae		       Scutini
Scymninae		       Scymnini
Sebekinae		       Sebekini
Seguenziinae		       Seguenziini
Sehirinae		       Sehirini
Selengarhynchinae	       Selengarhynchini
Serrulininae		       Serrulinini
Shansiodontinae 	       Shansiodontini
Sinokannemeyeriinae	       Sinokannemeyeriini
Siphonotinae		       Siphonotini
Siriellinae		       Siriellini
Sivapithecinae		       Sivapithecini
Skleroprotopodinae	       Skleroprotopodini
Slonikinae		       Slonikini
Sminthopsinae		       Sminthopsini
Sphaeridiinae		       Sphaeridiini
Sphaeropoeinae		       Sphaeropoeini
Sphaerotheriinae	       Sphaerotheriini
Sphecinae		       Sphecini
Spilopsyllinae		       Spilopsyllini
Spirorbinae		       Spirorbini
Spirostreptinae 	       Spirostreptini
Spondylidinae		       Spondylidini
Staphylininae		       Staphylinini
Stenodermatinae 	       Stenodermatini
Stictonettinae		       Stictonettini
Suclocypraeinae 	       Suclocypraeini
Sulciferinae		       Sulciferini
Symphrasinae		       Symphrasini
Synthetoceratinae	       Synthetoceratini
Syrnolinae		       Syrnolini
Syrphinae		       Syrphini
Tabaninae		       Tabanini
Tachyoryctinae		       Tachyoryctini
Tachyporinae		       Tachyporini
Tadorninae		       Tadornini
Talpinae		       Talpini
Tayassuinae		       Tayassuini
Tenthredininae		       Tenthredinini
Terebellinae		       Terebellini
Tetralichinae		       Tetralichini
Tettigarctinae		       Tettigarctini
Tettigoniinae		       Tettigoniini
Thelaxinae		       Thelaxini
Thelepinae		       Thelepini
Thripinae		       Thripini
Thylamyinae		       Thylamyini
Thylodriinae		       Thylodriini
Tornatellininae 	       Tornatellinini
Trachelodesminae	       Trachelodesmini
Trachypachinae		       Trachypachini
Tragelaphinae		       Tragelaphini
Trameinae		       Trameini
Trechinae		       Trechini
Trepobatinae		       Trepobatini
Triadomerinae		       Triadomerini
Triaenostreptinae	       Triaenostreptini
Triassolestinae 	       Triassolestini
Trichiinae		       Trichiini
Trichoblaniulinae	       Trichoblaniulini
Trichocerinae		       Trichocerini
Triculinae		       Triculini
Tridactylinae		       Tridactylini
Trimerophorinae 	       Trimerophorini
Trinodinae		       Trinodini
Triplectidinae		       Triplectidini
Trissexodontinae	       Trissexodontini
Tritominae		       Tritomini
Trizochelinae		       Trizochelini
Truncatellininae	       Truncatellinini
Truxalinae		       Truxalini
Tupinambinae		       Tupinambini
Tynommatinae		       Tynommatini
Typhlocybinae		       Typhlocybini
Uncigerinae		       Uncigerini
Urocyclinae		       Urocyclini
Urostylidinae		       Urostylidini
Volutinae		       Volutini
Xantholininae		       Xantholinini
Xiphiorhynchinae	       Xiphiorhynchini
Xyletininae		       Xyletinini
Xylocopinae		       Xylocopini
Xylotinae		       Xylotini
Xystodesminae		       Xystodesmini
Zephroniinae		       Zephroniini
Zidoninae		       Zidonini
Zygaeninae		       Zygaenini
Zygopinae		       Zygopini

624 rows selected.

@DerekSikes
Copy link
Author

DerekSikes commented May 15, 2019 via email

@dustymc
Copy link
Contributor

dustymc commented May 15, 2019

Those 624 relationships and their reciprocals are gone, and the creator-scripts should ignore names like them in the future.

I can't find any ina/ini or ina/inae related letter-only monomials - we have a path now, we can deal with them when/if they pop up.

Tentatively closing....

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

4 participants