Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

025 RYF inputs differ from others #162

Closed
aekiss opened this issue Aug 21, 2019 · 5 comments
Closed

025 RYF inputs differ from others #162

aekiss opened this issue Aug 21, 2019 · 5 comments

Comments

@aekiss
Copy link
Contributor

aekiss commented Aug 21, 2019

Breaking this out as a separate issue:

Inputs for 025deg_jra55_ryf now differ from the other 0.25 and 1 deg JRA configs. They should probably be brought into alignment (but not before checking!)

@aekiss
Copy link
Contributor Author

aekiss commented Aug 22, 2019

See #39 - the standard configs currently use these:

01deg_jra55_iaf/config.yaml:input: /short/public/access-om2/input_08022019
01deg_jra55_ryf/config.yaml:input: /short/public/access-om2/input_08022019
025deg_core2_nyf/config.yaml:input: /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505
025deg_jra55_iaf/config.yaml:input: /short/public/access-om2/input_236a3011
025deg_jra55_ryf/config.yaml:input: /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505
1deg_core_nyf/config.yaml:input: /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505
1deg_jra55_iaf/config.yaml:input: /short/public/access-om2/input_236a3011
1deg_jra55_ryf/config.yaml:input: /short/public/access-om2/input_236a3011
minimal_01deg_jra55_iaf/config.yaml:input: /short/public/access-om2/input_08022019
minimal_01deg_jra55_ryf/config.yaml:input: /short/public/access-om2/input_08022019

So the 1 deg and 0.25 deg core inputs also use input_337f4505 (from Nov 30 2018) rather than the newer input_236a3011 (Dec 13 2018).
(The 0.1 deg configs use input_08022019 which is incorrect for 1 and 0.25 deg: #159)

Here's how they differ:

diff -r /short/public/access-om2/input_236a3011 /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505
Only in /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505: common_025deg_core
Binary files /short/public/access-om2/input_236a3011/mom_01deg/topog.nc and /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/mom_01deg/topog.nc differ
Binary files /short/public/access-om2/input_236a3011/mom_025deg/ocean_temp_salt.res.nc and /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/mom_025deg/ocean_temp_salt.res.nc differ
Binary files /short/public/access-om2/input_236a3011/mom_025deg/ocean_vgrid.nc and /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/mom_025deg/ocean_vgrid.nc differ
Binary files /short/public/access-om2/input_236a3011/mom_025deg/topog.nc and /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/mom_025deg/topog.nc differ
Binary files /short/public/access-om2/input_236a3011/mom_1deg/ocean_temp_salt.res.nc and /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/mom_1deg/ocean_temp_salt.res.nc differ
Binary files /short/public/access-om2/input_236a3011/mom_1deg/ocean_vgrid.nc and /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/mom_1deg/ocean_vgrid.nc differ
Binary files /short/public/access-om2/input_236a3011/mom_1deg/topog.nc and /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/mom_1deg/topog.nc differ
Only in /short/public/access-om2/input_236a3011: mom_1deg-old_grid
Only in /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/yatm_025deg: ncar_precip.0001.nc
Only in /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/yatm_025deg: ncar_rad.0001.nc
Only in /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/yatm_025deg: q_10.0001.nc
Only in /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/yatm_025deg: rmp_daitren_runoff_MOM025_conserve2nd.nc
Only in /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/yatm_025deg: runoff.daitren.clim.10FEB2011.nc
Only in /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/yatm_025deg: slp.0001.nc
Only in /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/yatm_025deg: t_10.0001.nc
Only in /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/yatm_025deg: u_10.0001.nc
Only in /short/public/access-om2/input_337f4505/yatm_025deg: v_10.0001.nc
Only in /short/public/access-om2/input_236a3011: yatm_1deg_bkp

so it looks like input_236a3011 can be used with 025deg_jra55_ryf, but the core configs 025deg_core2_nyf, 1deg_core_nyf require files only found in input_337f4505. These would need to be moved to the release candidate /short/public/access-om2/input_rc/.

@aekiss
Copy link
Contributor Author

aekiss commented Aug 22, 2019

Actually the core files from input_337f4505 are already in /short/public/access-om2/input_rc/.

@aekiss
Copy link
Contributor Author

aekiss commented Dec 16, 2019

closing issue - all latest configs on ak-dev branch use the same input_rc.

@aekiss
Copy link
Contributor Author

aekiss commented Apr 22, 2020

Commit COSIMA/025deg_jra55_ryf@bff309d changed input_337f4505 to input_236a3011 in the master branch of 025deg_jra55_ryf

@aekiss
Copy link
Contributor Author

aekiss commented May 18, 2020

More details on inputs for 025deg_jra55_ryf:

025deg_jra55_ryf used input_337f4505 (Nov 30 2018), whereas all
other 1deg & 0.25deg used input_236a3011 (Dec 13 2018).

In the ak-dev configs they all now use input_rc.

The only changes in input_rc relevant to 025deg_jra55_ryf are:

  • Binary files input_337f4505/cice_025deg/i2o.nc and input_rc/cice_025deg/i2o.nc differ - OK: input_rc/cice_025deg/i2o.nc is updated for JRA55-do 1.4.0 support
  • Only in input_337f4505/common_025deg_jra55: rmp_jra55_cice_conserve.nc - OK: same as input_rc/common_025deg_jra55/rmp_jra55_cice_2nd_conserve.nc
  • Only in input_337f4505/common_025deg_jra55: rmp_jra55_cice_smooth.nc - OK: same as input_rc/common_025deg_jra55/rmp_jra55_cice_patch.nc
  • Binary files input_337f4505/mom_025deg/ocean_temp_salt.res.nc and input_rc/mom_025deg/ocean_temp_salt.res.nc differ - OK: input_337f4505 had the wrong initial condition: Incorrect initial conditions for most configurations #39
  • Binary files input_337f4505/mom_025deg/ocean_vgrid.nc and input_rc/mom_025deg/ocean_vgrid.nc differ - OK: input_rc uses the KDS50 grid
  • Binary files input_337f4505/mom_025deg/salt_sfc_restore.nc and input_rc/mom_025deg/salt_sfc_restore.nc differ - OK: input_rc is patch-interpolated: 'patch' interpolation for salt_sfc_restore.nc #74
  • Binary files input_337f4505/mom_025deg/topog.nc and input_rc/mom_025deg/topog.nc differ - these are different, particularly in the deep ocean. input_rc is newer (2018 vs 2012) and presumably set up for KDS50. the input_rc version is from input_236a3011/mom_025deg

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant