Update section on relevant DC terms

[kleihan]

Section 3.2.1 Provenance contains a subset of DC terms that are relevant in the context of electronic interfaces. The proposal is to update this section to make a clear recommendation of DC terms to be used and their semantics. This is linked to the existing issue FIXTradingCommunity/fix-orchestra#186 about version attributes.

[kleihan]

See also #39 Metadata usage guidelines

[martinswanson]

As discussed at the previous Orchestra subcommittee meeting, here are our recommendations for the DC Terms.

Note: In general, we favour a permissive approach that avoids forcing users to specify lots of required fields, but being clear about the default behaviour if certain elements are not specified.

1. Change the recommended elements for an Orchestra spec from [title, publisher, date issued, and rights] to [title, creator, created, conformsTo, and source].

• title: Should be a required element. If missing, should default to using the repository name.
• creator: The recommended role should be creator not publisher, as not all specs are published (e.g. private specs)
• created: The recommended date should be created not issued, as not all specs reach issuance in their lifecycle
• conformsTo: Tools processing Orchestra files need to know which version of the technical spec the XML conforms to, hence conformsTo should be a recommended element. If missing, should default to the latest official version (currently Orchestra v1.0).
• source: URL to another Orchestra file. Should be a recommended element if a reference file was used to create the specification. This helps to preserve provenance, and allows validation across specifications e.g. if a scenario variant in a derived spec is valid with respect the reference specification.

2. Additional elements recommended to support document generation (covers both PDF and EPUB formats)

• alternative - Subtitle for the resource.
• subject - List of keywords used for search and categorisation.
• abstract - A summary of the resource.
• issued - If missing, default to created date.
• dateAccepted - if missing, default to issued date. If issued date is also missing, default to created date.
• contributor - Secondary author, in addition to the creator.
• publisher - Distributor of the Orchestra file or document. If missing, default to creator.

3. Additional recommended elements

• rights - optional, identifies the copyright holder of the Orchestra file
• licence - optional, URL to a licence file
• isFormatOf - URL to original resource that the Orchestra spec is based on (e.g. a PDF spec published by an Exchange).

We have confirmed that the above is sufficient to correctly set all the relevant metadata attributes for both PDF and EBUP documentation formats.