[BUG] - withdrawal doesn't work with transaction build command

[mkoura]

Internal/External
Internal

Area
Other Any other topic (Delegation, Ranking, ...).

Summary
I'm using the cardano-cli transaction build command to build a transaction that withdraws from reward address. The transaction is build and submitted successfully, however no rewards are withdrawn.

# query UTxO and reward account balance
$ cardano-cli query utxo --address addr_test1qryajf46462yd40wpvwqwc33aavyc6v3vyyyjzxw6qnmf6wcp6xvu536j8j7q4nvt4lnur455zrt49ujwlk0xd50lcdsefjcxd --out-file /dev/stdout --testnet-magic 42 --cardano-mode
{
    "7f85ce8becaacfbe8d78eca4657965002d8562fadb28b6a2d3be54a1df850f67#0": {
        "address": "addr_test1qryajf46462yd40wpvwqwc33aavyc6v3vyyyjzxw6qnmf6wcp6xvu536j8j7q4nvt4lnur455zrt49ujwlk0xd50lcdsefjcxd",
        "value": {
            "lovelace": 991052534886
        }
    }
}

$ cardano-cli query stake-address-info --address stake_test1uzrjn9glcr66zcgymgdavvrcnm5vmcs3su46z7nr7yzkx2cm6m3gg --testnet-magic 42 --cardano-mode
[
    {
        "address": "stake_test1uzrjn9glcr66zcgymgdavvrcnm5vmcs3su46z7nr7yzkx2cm6m3gg",
        "rewardAccountBalance": 8946747450,
        "delegation": null
    }
]

# build, sign, submit a tx
$ cardano-cli transaction build --tx-in 7f85ce8becaacfbe8d78eca4657965002d8562fadb28b6a2d3be54a1df850f67#0 --withdrawal stake_test1uzrjn9gl
cr66zcgymgdavvrcnm5vmcs3su46z7nr7yzkx2cm6m3gg+8946747450 --tx-out addr_test1qryajf46462yd40wpvwqwc33aavyc6v3vyyyjzxw6qnmf6wcp6xvu536j8j7q4n
vt4lnur455zrt49ujwlk0xd50lcdsefjcxd+8946747450 --change-address addr_test1qryajf46462yd40wpvwqwc33aavyc6v3vyyyjzxw6qnmf6wcp6xvu536j8j7q4nvt
4lnur455zrt49ujwlk0xd50lcdsefjcxd --witness-override 4 --alonzo-era --testnet-magic 42 --out-file reward_withdrawal_tx.body

$ cardano-cli transaction sign --tx-body-file reward_withdrawal_tx.body --out-file reward_withdrawal_tx.signed --testnet-magic 42 --signing
-key-file /home/martink/Source/repos/cardano-node/state-cluster0/nodes/node-pool2/owner-utxo.skey --signing-key-file /home/martink/Source/r
epos/cardano-node/state-cluster0/nodes/node-pool2/reward.skey

$ cardano-cli transaction submit --testnet-magic 42 --tx-file reward_withdrawal_tx.signed --cardano-mode
Transaction successfully submitted.

# query reward account balance - nothing was withdrawn
$ cardano-cli query stake-address-info --address stake_test1uzrjn9glcr66zcgymgdavvrcnm5vmcs3su46z7nr7yzkx2cm6m3gg --testnet-magic 42 --cardano-mode
[
    {
        "address": "stake_test1uzrjn9glcr66zcgymgdavvrcnm5vmcs3su46z7nr7yzkx2cm6m3gg",
        "rewardAccountBalance": 8946747450,
        "delegation": null
    }
]

# query UTxOs - inputs were spent, outputs were created
$ cardano-cli query utxo --address addr_test1qryajf46462yd40wpvwqwc33aavyc6v3vyyyjzxw6qnmf6wcp6xvu536j8j7q4nvt4lnur455zrt49ujwlk0xd50lcdsefjcxd --out-file /dev/stdout --testnet-magic 42 --cardano-mode
{
    "db486654ed06c49fe05494bdbba9f2cd7276259330fa8f9daa73ad3c222e6146#1": {
        "address": "addr_test1qryajf46462yd40wpvwqwc33aavyc6v3vyyyjzxw6qnmf6wcp6xvu536j8j7q4nvt4lnur455zrt49ujwlk0xd50lcdsefjcxd",
        "value": {
            "lovelace": 8946747450
        }
    },
    "db486654ed06c49fe05494bdbba9f2cd7276259330fa8f9daa73ad3c222e6146#0": {
        "address": "addr_test1qryajf46462yd40wpvwqwc33aavyc6v3vyyyjzxw6qnmf6wcp6xvu536j8j7q4nvt4lnur455zrt49ujwlk0xd50lcdsefjcxd",
        "value": {
            "lovelace": 982105605743
        }
    }
}

Expected behavior
Rewards are withdrawn from reward account.

System info (please complete the following information):

• OS Name: Fedora 34
• Node & CLI version:

cardano-node 1.28.0 - linux-x86_64 - ghc-8.10
git rev bf71fe31459905df8573e6d3f3cfe85af6ab1c99

[Jimbo4350]

And withdrawals still work with build-raw?

[mkoura]

@Jimbo4350 Yes, with build-raw it still works.

[newhoggy]

I have just now verified that build-raw works also and fails as described with build.

[JaredCorduan]

@mkoura could you share the contents of reward_withdrawal_tx.body?

[newhoggy]

This was mine:

tx.raw.gz

[JaredCorduan]

This was mine:

tx.raw.gz

ok, yea, this transaction does not have a reward withdrawal in it. If you put the hex into cbor.me you'll see that the body has no 5 key.

https://github.com/input-output-hk/cardano-ledger-specs/blob/c89b8d1461b89a8a3b70899ac82b22850ab0b4f5/eras/shelley/test-suite/cddl-files/shelley.cddl#L57

[Jimbo4350]

Resolved in #3317