-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1.7k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
IKEA Remotes (Tradfri 5 button E1524/E1810 and Styrbar) lost arrow left and right hold actions. #22458
Comments
I have the same issue with:IKEA E2001/E2002 Updated the firmware of the switches yesterday since then this issue happens. The arrow buttons don't work anymore. |
My remotes are all updated since long time, there were no new firmware update lately. The issue is not in the firmware, reverting back to v1.36.1-1 brings back the normal functionality. |
Yesterday the remotes worked for me with the latest zigbee2mqtt, after I updated the ikea firmware they stopped working. The 2 Normal, buttons work, but the arrow buttons stopped working. Reverting back zigbee2mqtt didn't solve the issue for me |
+1 Luckily I decided to only update one of several remotes I own. To be clear, I use the E2001/E2002. [UPDATE] I finally got everything working again after force removing the remote, restarting Z2M and then pairing it again. Fingers crossed it keeps working without issues. 🤞🏻 |
IMHO there are two separate issues with Styrbar:
Not sure about other IKEA remotes. |
I haven't done any firmware update lately because there was no recent update. My firmware version for 5 button remote is 24.4.5 with creation date 2019-04-01, and for Styrbar 1.0.024 2020-07-08. If you say that you updated recently that means that you never updated the firmware before. AFAIK, there hasn't been any change in those firmwares, so the problem is clearly in the Z2M software. In any case, reverting back to 1.36.1-1 fixes the issue. Probably you didn't reboot the whole machine after downgrading, try it. |
Few days ago, zigbee2mqtt has started offering me updates for all my IKEA
devices (Styrbar, Rodret, Somrig and Tretakt). The old version of Styrbar
firmware was 65572, the new version is 33816593.
For some reason, they haven't appeared at once. Even various Styrbars had
the updates at somewhat different time.
|
I have the issue OP describes with the tradfri remote E1524/E1810 - on 1.37 long press on left or right doesn't work (action produces "none"), downgrading to 1.36.1 immediately solves it. This particular issue has nothing to do with any recent firmware/ota updates. |
Glad to see that I'm not the only one experiencing this issue. Was surprised to see that those actions just stopped working all of a sudden. Don't think its tied to any OTA updates as mentioned above. |
What I changed: IKEA E2001/E2002 firmware update to Firmware-Date: 20240408 Firmware-Version: 2.4.11 Zigbee2MQTT-Version 1.37.0-1 Device: IKEA E2001/E2002 As of now, I found these errors after holding the right / left buttons FYI: [TB-SE] Luckily I decided to only update one of several remotes I own. To be clear, I use the E2001/E2002. [UPDATE] I finally got everything working again after force removing the remote, restarting Z2M and then pairing it again. Fingers crossed it keeps working without issues. 🤞🏻 |
Pushed a fix, let me know if it works! Changes will be available in the dev branch in a few hours from now. |
I can confirm that it now works again in the dev branch. 👍 |
I've tried the dev version (1.37.0-dev commit: 358e2ee) with Styrbars:
|
I updated one of my STYRBAR E2001/E2002 on Friday from 1.0.024 to 2.4.11 and realized yesterday that left-right didn't worked. Planned to take it back to IKEA and tell them it stopped working and see if they exchange it and maybe give me a unit with 2.4.5 and see if that works... Do you think your fix will solve my problem? When will it be implemented in production version of MQTT? I'm not fully comfortable with trying to change to dev branch...but I really want my STYRBAR back... |
@JohnBull-1975 I guess the Z2M update will not help with issues with the new firmware (see my previous post), but you can try it. I've also noticed that Reconfigure doesn't work with Styrbars. It works neither for new nor for old firmware. The error message is very similar, but slightly different. Newlines are mine (I've added them for easier comparison), the last line is the same: old firmware:
new firmware:
|
Ahhh...I hoped so... |
I guess that question is for @Koenkk |
For the record. My STYRBAR E2001/2002 updated OTA to FW 2.4.11 yesterday (new from box with 1.x) and doesn't register left and right clicks. |
Just force remove the remote, restart Z2M and pair it again, worked for me... |
Didn't worked for me....can pair it after force remove, but no button work. No reaction at all in Z2M console. Not even "last seen" gets updated when I press a button. |
My control doesn't report |
Worked for me as well, but only for the left/right click actions. Hold actions still don't work. |
it works for me too after upgrading from dev branch, removing the remote in z2m (no restart of z2m) , re-pair it again and give it back its previous name, thanks guys |
I went to IKEA with my STYRBAR. The guy at customer service managed to pair it to one of their lamps...and then when he should show me how he did it (yes I know how it's supposed to work...) he couldn't, so he gave up and gave me a new one with firmware 1.0.024 and it just works again!!! :-) |
I've digged slightly deeper to the issue with new Styrbar firmware:
|
Does a re-configure of the device helps? Press the yellow refresh button on the device page, make sure to wakeup the device before doing that. |
I've tried to reconfigure the device after pressing on button multiple times, which should have been enough to wake the device up. I either get EDIT: Styrbar with old firmware seems to have the same issue with reconfiguring. Bat the old Styrbar firmware works even if the reconfigure fails. |
I switched just some minutes ago to the dev branch and everything is working again (IKEA E2001/E2002 Firwmare 2.4.11) Details Versions Thanks |
I can confirm the left/right tap button behaviour missing after Styrbar firmware update with Z2M1.37.0 and ember stack. Error on reconfigure is:
|
@greiseknoue In bind tab, I see two items, one for coordinator, one for default_bind_group. The settings are exactly the same for both old and new FW (I am sure I haven't changed it for those two Styrbars): The list of offered clusters is a bit different:
EDIT: I've tried left arrow with Styrbar with old firmware (1.0.024) and see in logs what cluster is used for that:
OK, it is genScenes. Fun fact, even 0xaabbccddeeff0011 has the same Bind settings and options, i.e., there is no genScenes. But even though z2m doesn't offer this cluster, it accepts events from that. While I don't understand it fully, I think there is some subtle bug related to clusters and the new firmware isn't directly to blame. It has just triggered the bug. |
I wonder if the missing actions is the same issue as #22506 If someone uses MQTT explorer you can see the list of published device actions Vs the actual actions. This has been happening to me since 1.36 |
@jamesonuk Likely a separate issue. In my case, I see the actions in HA, but they aren't triggered. |
You have Scenes cluster (the one you apparently need for arrows), I don't. Maybe just enabling the Scenes cluster would do the same job for you. I've even tried publishing message Then, I tried to remove and re-add the Styrbar. First, I couldn't enter the pairing mode (not sure why), but I succeeded after re-trying it multiple times. After re-pairing, it finally works (tested all actions, including hold and release). Now, I have just one item in Bind tab and it has Scenes cluster, enabled by default. |
So I've found that @greiseknoue solution works. But in my case I got the same options under bind tab as @v6ak like image below. Scenes missing... What worked for me was to force remove the styrbar from Z2M. Then re-pair it. And when re-pairing I got some error that it couldn't bind some stuff. That's fine. By now the bind tab had updated and had the options mentioned in @chrizzlibaer image like below I followed the rest of @greiseknoue solution except I checked some more of the missing boxes so it looked like in the image above and proceeded and pulled out one battery, put it back in, pressed a button on the remote and followed that by pressing "Bind <3". Hope this helps someone. |
Second Styrbar, similar story. Not sure if Z2M restart has helped me to re-pair the Styrbar. Third Styrbar: I've tried to re-pair before FW update. It was smoother, but I didn't get the Scenes cluster. So, it continued with approximately the same story. I have few more Styrbars to update. I might test a different approach there. (Z2M version still 1.37.0-dev commit: 358e2ee) |
Pushed another fix, configure should succeed now. Changes will be available in the dev branch in a few hours from now. |
I checked the following with the latest dev, all OK with:
Assuming this can be closed now (I will make a hotfix release ASAP) |
@Koenkk |
Hmm, after update of the 5th Srytbar with Z2M 1.37.0-dev commit 358e2ee, arrows don't work and reconfigure fails, but the error message is a bit different. This time, genOnOff fails, not genScenes. I've updated to the latest dev (1.37.0-dev commit: cce41c2), but reconfigure fails with the same outcome :( There is the full error message (line breaks are mine):
|
It looks like the device is not awake during the re-configure, make sure to wake it up by clicking a button on it right before doing the re-configure. |
I was trying to wake it, but probably in a wrong way. I assumed that any button will do it, and clicked arrows, because they didn't have any side effect. But it seems that they didn't have any effect at all. Waking it by |
I had the same issue where none of the actions worked on the Styrbar remote on firmware 2.4.11. I updated to 1.37.1. I tried re-configuring the remote but it didn't help. I tried re-pairing but it fails to configure.
More logs: |
It may be the same issue but i can't update my RODRET wireless dimmer Product ID: E2201.
and when i try to reconfigure the device i have this :
Thanks for your help I have 1.37.1 Z2M and V7.4.2 sonoff Dongle E Firmware |
Battery powered zigbee devices always need to be waken up when updating. So issue the firmware then press the on or off buttons multiple times for around 5 seconds, then the firmware update should start. |
Thanks for your help Update done .. |
What happened?
Don't know if it has been reported before, but didn't find anything related. IKEA Remotes (Tradfri 5 button E1524/E1810 and Styrbar 4 button) lost arrow left and right hold actions. Instead they show "None" when holding. Don't want to mention how many automations it broke for me.
What did you expect to happen?
To work normally as it did before for a very long time.
How to reproduce it (minimal and precise)
Just use arrow_left_hold and arrow_right_hold actions.
Zigbee2MQTT version
1.37.0-1
Adapter firmware version
20221226
Adapter
Sonoff Zigbee 3.0 Dongle Plus
Setup
HAOS
Debug log
No response
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: