-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 19
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
[Bug] harbour-meecast-eventview
package not available at OpenRepos
#68
Comments
@vasvlad, as already stated: Please name a reason not to upload This may be the only reason why people report MeeCast from OpenRepos not working properly in contrast to installing them from SailfishOS:Chum. Then PR #72 would be completely unnecessary! Unfortunately I have no way to test this, currently. |
No reasons other than my lack of free time. :( |
This is always fine, though sometimes unfortunate.
Oh, the idea was to make it easy for users by providing both packages in the same repository: RPM takes care about the "< 4.6.0" vs. "≥ 4.6.0" separation, this is exactly the reason why I named them differently and let them depend on I suggest to please revert all these changes (altering the name of the page breaks many postings at FSO linking to it!) and to simply also upload the Rationale: Both packages provide exactly the same functionality, thus for users there is not recognisable difference. And technically both packages share exactly the same source-code, only their RPM packaging (i.e. spec file) differs. |
Hmm. I don't understand your idea. :( I have now implemented your request (reverted everything back). Please check it. I will need to upload both versions of the packages in the future to https://openrepos.net/content/vasvlad/meecast-event-view? |
Sorry, then likely my explanation was not sufficient. I know discussing by typing messages can be tedious, but IMO we should take the time to achieve mutual understanding (e.g. we are working on the topic "make MeeCast compatible to SailfishOS ≥ 4.6.0" for months, so a couple of days do not make any significant difference). I really do not feel I am in the position to command you (and you simply execute; actually IMO nobody is in the position to command anybody, practically that solely ceases to be the case when in the military, facing the police etc.), even if this is about the specifics of RPM packaging (or CI workflow configuration etc.).
Thank you very much! You may denote on this page to notify the few users who manually download RPM packages from OpenRepos to explain the difference between the two packages. So my suggestion for the description field of this page at OpenRepos (i.e. replacing the text "Event's view for MeeCast") is to use the three lines below (the second of them being a blank line). The MeeCast eventview widget displays weather information at the top of SailfishOS' eventsview. Note that the harbour-meecast-eventview packages are for SailfishOS ≥ 4.6.0 and the harbour-meecast-event packages for SailfishOS < 4.6.0.
Yes. They all end up in the same RPM repository anyway (hence the different names were also technically necessary), because OpenRepos creates a single RPM repository for each registered user there. The package-specific web-pages at OpenRepos are only for describing (and discussing in the comments) different packages separately: This is why I strongly suggested to use only a single page for these two packages, because they provide the same functionality (and features, bugs, behaviour etc.), solely the SailfishOS-releases they target are different. So please also upload the three packages |
Done |
@vasvlad, when performing my review WRT the separation of the
event
andeventview
sub-packages, I discovered that theharbour-meecast-eventview
package is not uploaded on the Meecast Event View page at OpenRepos in addition to theharbour-meecast-event
package.The split into two separate packages was explicitly performed to allow appropriate packages for SailfishOS ≥ 4.6.0 and SailfishOS < 4.6.0 to coexist in a single RPM repository, in order to make MeeCast(-Eventview) installable for users of all SailfishOS releases from a single repository (i.e. yours at OpenRepos) again.
Please tell me if I missed an aspect; if I did not, please upload the
harbour-meecast-eventview
package on the Meecast Event View page at OpenRepos (in addition to theharbour-meecast-event
package) now and in the future.The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: