You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
When playing a mono ogg file that is a different sample rate than your output device's through ChannelVolume the audio switches between the left and right channels. (I think it has to do with compression because it usually happens on the beat of a song)
I've narrowed the issue down to SampleRateConverter's Iterator.next() function, but I don't know much about converting sample rate so I'm lost as to where the problem actually is.
This issue could be related to the lower level decoding library lewton, but since the ogg plays perfectly fine when the sample rates match, I think it's related to SampleRateConverter in rodio.
I found this issue when using Windows 10 with my output sample rate set to 48000 in the sound settings. I was trying to play a 44100 Hz sound through the SpatialSink, which in turn uses ChannelVolume.
I fixed some issues like this in #249 which might help but I suspect this is a different issue with the same root cause of generated samples not respecting the number of channels. I suspect Rodio could benefit from switching to using the "sample" crate's Frame trait to avoid this issue at the type level.
@dvdsk Flagging that this issue is affecting us too when resampling from 48kHz to a 44.1kHz OutputDevice for an 8 channel source (or a 6 channel) when using ChannelVolume but probably also on multichannel sources without ChannelVolume.
When playing a mono ogg file that is a different sample rate than your output device's through
ChannelVolume
the audio switches between the left and right channels. (I think it has to do with compression because it usually happens on the beat of a song)I've narrowed the issue down to
SampleRateConverter
's Iterator.next() function, but I don't know much about converting sample rate so I'm lost as to where the problem actually is.This issue could be related to the lower level decoding library
lewton
, but since the ogg plays perfectly fine when the sample rates match, I think it's related toSampleRateConverter
in rodio.I found this issue when using Windows 10 with my output sample rate set to 48000 in the sound settings. I was trying to play a 44100 Hz sound through the
SpatialSink
, which in turn usesChannelVolume
.Here's a minimal repro-repo: https://github.com/SpiralP/rust-rodio-samplerate-bug
Thanks!
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: