BenchGov - The Governance For The Bench Network

BenchGov Introduction

This paper specifies the Governance module of the Bench Network or anything forked from the Bench Network. The Governance enables Bench Network's MultiChain to support a governance system on both the RootChain, SideChains and dappChains integrated with the Bench Network.

In this system, MARK (BenchMark) holders or the native staking coin of the SideChain or dappChain in particular can vote on what we call Motions, on a 1 native staking coin to 1 vote scale.

Bench Network Definitions

• Bench Network - DPOS MultiChain, Powered By BenchCore.
• RootChain - First blockchain added to the MultiChain. In Bench Network's MultiChain, BenchChain is the RootChain
• MARK / BenchMark - Native Mark of the Bench Network's RootChain
• MARK holder - an entity that holds some amount of BenchMarks
• Candidate - a MARK holder that is actively involved in the BenchChain blockchain protocol running a BenchChain Full Node and is competing with other candidates to be elected as a Rocketeer.
• Rocketeer - a candidate that is currently selected among a set of candidates to be able to sign protocol messages in the BenchChain logic protocol
• Delegator - an MARK holder that has insured some of its BenchMarks by delegating them to a Rocketeer (or a candidate)
• Insuring BenchMarks - a process of locking BenchMarks in a insure deposit (putting BenchMarks under protocol control). BenchMarks are always insured through a Rocketeer (or candidate) process. Insured BenchMarks can be slashed (burned) in case a Rocketeer process misbehaves (does not behave according to the protocol specification). MARK holders can regain access to their insured BenchMarks if they have not been slashed by waiting an Uninsuring period.
• Uninsuring period - a period of time after which MARK holder gains access to its insured BenchMarks (they can be withdrawn to a user account) or they can be re-delegated.
• Inflationary provisions - inflation is the process of increasing the MARK supply. BenchMarks are periodically created on the Bench Network and issued to insured MARK holders. The goal of inflation is to incentize most of the BenchMarks in existence to be insured.
• Transaction fees - transaction fee is a fee that is included in a Cosmsos Hub transaction. The fees are collected by the current rocketeer set and distributed among Rocketeers and delegators in proportion to their insured MARK share.
• Commission fee - a fee taken from the transaction fees by a rocketeer for their service

Currently Implemented Features

Next is a list of features the Bench Governance currently supports:

• Submitting Motions: Users can submit motions with a deposit. Once the minimum deposit is reached, motion enters voting period
• Vote: Participants can vote on motions that reached MinDeposit
• Inheritance and penalties: Delegators inherit their rocketeer's vote if they don't vote themselves. If rocketeers do not vote, they get partially slashed.
• Signal and switch: If a motion of type SoftwareUpgradeMotion is accepted, Rocketeers can signal it and switch once enough rocketeers have signalled.
• Claiming deposit: Users that made a deposit on Motions within a chain can recover their deposits if the motion was accepted OR if the motion in question never entered voting period.

This particular Governance will be used in the Bench Network, which will become the first Chain and therefore the RootChain within the Bench Network.

Table of Contents

The following specification uses MARK (BenchMarks) as the native staking token. The module can be adapted to any Proof-Of-Stake blockchain by replacing MARK (BenchMarks) with the native staking token of the chain.

1. Design overview
2. Implementation
   1. State
      1. Procedures
      2. Motions
      3. Motion Processing Queue
   2. Transactions
      1. Motion Submission
      2. Deposit
      3. Claim Deposit
      4. Vote
3. Future Implementations

Bench Governance Overview

The governance process is divided in a few steps that are outlined below:

• Motion Filing: Motion is filed on the RootChain, SideChain or dappChain along with a deposit.
• Motion Voting: Once deposit reaches a certain value (MinDeposit), motion is confirmed and vote opens. Insured MARK holders can then send NtxGovVote transactions to vote on the motion.
• Software Upgrade Motions:
   -- Signal: Rocketeers start signaling that they are ready to switch to the new version
  -- Switch: Once more than 2/3rd Rocketeers have signaled their readiness to switch, their software automatically flips to the version from the Motion regarding the software upgrade.
  

Motion Filing

Your Right To File A Motion

Any MARK holder, whether insured or uninsured, can file motions by sending a NtxMotion transaction. Once a motion is filed, it is identified by its unique motionID.

Preventing Motion Spamming

To prevent spam on the Bench Network in regards to Motion filings, motions must be filed along with a motionDeposit. motionDeposits must be paid in with the MARK denomination. Other coins available on the RootChain, SideChains or dappChains can not be used to cover a motionDeposit.

Other MARK holders can increase the Motion's deposit in MARK so that it works out to look likes this: 0 < deposit < MinDeposit, by sending a NtxGovDeposit transaction. Once the Motion's deposit reaches MinDeposit, it will finally enter its voting period, where the filed Motion can be voted on by members of the Bench Network community.

Refunded Motion Filing Deposit

There are two instances where MARK holders that deposited MARK on pending Motions in the system, can reclaim their Motion deposit:

• If the Motion is accepted
• If the Motion's deposit does not reach MinDeposit for a period longer than MinDepositPeriod. The default value for MinDepositPeriodis 60 days.

If a Motion has no deposits for 60 days, it's closed permanently and would have to be reposted to start the MinDepositPeriodover.

In such instances, MARK holders that deposited can send a NtxGovClaimDeposit transaction to retrieve their share of the deposit.

Motion Types and Categories

In the initial version of the governance module, there are two types of proposal:

• PlainTextProposal. All the proposals that do not involve a modification of the source code go under this type. For example, an opinion poll would use a proposal of type PlainTextProposal
• SoftwareUpgradeProposal. If accepted, validators are expected to update their software in accordance with the proposal. They must do so by following a 2-steps process described in the Software Upgrade section below. Software upgrade roadmap may be discussed and agreed on via PlainTextProposals, but actual software upgrades must be performed via SoftwareUpgradeProposals.

There are two categories of proposal:

• Regular
• Emergency

Both are essentially identical other than Urgent motions having the ability to be accepted faster, as long as the Emergency conditions of an Emergency proposal are met.

Vote

Participants

Participants are users that have the right to vote. On the Bench Network, participants are insured MARK holders. Uninsured MARK holders and other users do not get the right to participate in the Bench governance. However, they can file Motions and make Motion deposits.

Voting Span

Once a Motion reaches MinDeposit, it immediately enters what's is called a Voting Span. We define Voting Span as the interval between the moment the vote around a Motion opens and the moment the vote around a Motion closes. Voting Span should always be shorter than Uninsured Span to prevent double voting. The default value for Voting Span when filing a Motion is 2 weeks.

How You Vote

When casting a vote on a Motion, a participant has four options to choose from, although other options can be set by the person or network filing the Motion.

The default voting options includes the following options:

• Yes
• No
• Veto
• Abstain
• NotEmergency

Explanations of voting options:

• Veto counts as No but also lets the network know that voter is Vetoing the Motion and will not accept the outcome of the Motion's vote.
• Abstain doesn't count as a Yes or No but does allow voters to abstain from voting on a Motion, while also accepting the outcome of the Motion's vote.
• NotEmergency only appears on for Emergency Motions and allows voters to proclaim a Motion as non-urgent.

Minimum Vote

The ability for us to use Minimum Voting rules for filed Motions, is still in the works but apart of our Governance model. Our 2nd software upgrade for Bench Network will introduce a way for a minimum percentage of Voting Fuel, that's required for the result of a Motion's vote to considered valid by the network.

Currently, participation is ensured via the combination of inheritance and a Rocketeer's punishment for his/her failure to vote on a Motion.