Remove ba logger #12
Remove ba logger #12
Conversation
WalkthroughThe overall changes involve updating version numbers for dependencies, specifically incrementing the Changes
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Outside diff range, codebase verification and nitpick comments (1)
test/src/FleetApiClientTests.cpp (1)
8-8: Question the necessity of<cstdio>.The inclusion of
<cstdio>is unusual in modern C++ testing environments. If it's used for debugging, consider using C++ style I/O operations or logging mechanisms that are more consistent with modern C++ practices.
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (15)
- CMakeLists.txt (3 hunks)
- README.md (1 hunks)
- cmake/Dependencies.cmake (1 hunks)
- example/main.cpp (6 hunks)
- include/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/FleetApiClient.hpp (1 hunks)
- include/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/RequestFrequencyGuard.hpp (2 hunks)
- include/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/settings/Constants.hpp (1 hunks)
- src/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/FleetApiClient.cpp (4 hunks)
- src/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/RequestFrequencyGuard.cpp (6 hunks)
- test/include/RequestFrequencyGuardTests.hpp (1 hunks)
- test/include/TestConstants.hpp (1 hunks)
- test/lib/memory_management/source/memory_management.cpp (1 hunks)
- test/main.cpp (1 hunks)
- test/src/FleetApiClientTests.cpp (4 hunks)
- test/src/RequestFrequencyGuardTests.cpp (9 hunks)
Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (6)
- README.md
- include/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/settings/Constants.hpp
- test/include/RequestFrequencyGuardTests.hpp
- test/include/TestConstants.hpp
- test/lib/memory_management/source/memory_management.cpp
- test/main.cpp
Additional comments not posted (36)
cmake/Dependencies.cmake (1)
Line range hint
1-8: Approved removal ofba-logger.The removal of
ba-loggerfrom the dependencies aligns with the PR's goal to streamline logging. Ensure that there are no lingering references toba-loggerin the project.Run the following script to verify that there are no remaining references to
ba-logger:Verification successful
No Remaining References to
ba-loggerFoundThe searches conducted using both
rgandgrepacross the project files have consistently returned no occurrences ofba-logger. This confirms thatba-loggerhas been successfully removed from the project dependencies and codebase.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that there are no remaining references to `ba-logger` in the project. # Test: Search for references to `ba-logger`. Expect: No occurrences. rg --type cmake --type cpp --type h --type txt 'ba-logger'Length of output: 58
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Re-run the search for references to `ba-logger` to confirm no occurrences exist. # Search for `ba-logger` in the project across relevant file types. rg --type cmake --type cpp --type h --type txt 'ba-logger' || echo "No occurrences found or an error occurred."Length of output: 153
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Use an alternative method to search for `ba-logger` references to ensure accuracy. # Use `grep` to search for `ba-logger` across all files to verify the absence of references. grep -r 'ba-logger' . || echo "No occurrences found or an error occurred."Length of output: 116
src/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/RequestFrequencyGuard.cpp (1)
Line range hint
17-37: Approved changes tohandleDelays.The modification of
handleDelaysto return a boolean enhances its functionality by providing feedback on the handling of delays. Ensure that all calls to this method properly handle the new boolean return type.Run the following script to verify that the new return type is handled correctly in all calls to
handleDelays:Verification successful
The boolean return type of
handleDelaysis handled correctly in all calls. The method's return value is appropriately used in test assertions and integrated into the logic ofFleetApiClient.cpp. No issues were found with the handling of the new return type.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that the new boolean return type of `handleDelays` is handled correctly in all calls. # Test: Search for calls to `handleDelays`. Expect: Proper handling of the boolean return type. rg --type cpp 'handleDelays' -A 3Length of output: 4463
include/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/RequestFrequencyGuard.hpp (1)
Line range hint
38-58: Approved changes tohandleDelaysmethod signature and documentation.The update to the
handleDelaysmethod signature in the header file is consistent with the implementation changes. The documentation clearly describes the new behavior, enhancing the method's utility.CMakeLists.txt (1)
11-11: Version update approved.The update from
1.3.0to1.5.0forFLEET_HTTP_CLIENT_VERSIONis consistent with the PR's objectives to manage dependencies effectively.example/main.cpp (5)
12-12: API key configuration change approved.Changing the
apiKeytoProtocolStaticAccessKeyis a positive move towards standardizing or securing API access. Ensure that this key is managed securely, possibly through environment variables or a secure key management service.
33-33: Iteration optimization approved.Changing the iteration variable to
const auto&helps avoid unnecessary copies, enhancing performance when dealing with potentially large objects.
45-45: Iteration optimization approved.Applying
const auto&for iteration over the commands collection is a good practice to enhance performance by avoiding unnecessary copies.
55-55: Iteration optimization approved.Using
const auto&for iterating over the statuses collection continues the trend of performance optimization seen throughout this file.
82-82: Iteration optimization approved.Optimizing the iteration variable to
const auto&for the devices collection is consistent with other changes in this file and beneficial for performance.test/src/FleetApiClientTests.cpp (8)
4-4: Inclusion ofRequestFrequencyGuard.hppapproved.The inclusion of this header is necessary for testing the new delay functionality introduced in the API client.
33-33: Setup ofFleetApiClientinstance approved.The configuration of the
FleetApiClientinstance is appropriate for testing the delay functionality, ensuring that the thresholds and delays are set as expected for the tests.
35-35: Introduction ofdelayedvariable approved.The use of the
delayedvariable is crucial for capturing and asserting the delay status from API calls, which is central to the objectives of these tests.
40-41: Test logic forgetCommandsapproved.The logic captures and asserts the delay status effectively, which is essential for verifying the functionality of the delay mechanism under test conditions.
44-44: Assertion for delay approved.The assertion that checks the time difference after the delay threshold is reached is crucial for ensuring that the delay mechanism adheres to specified time constraints.
54-55: Test logic forgetStatusesapproved.The logic to capture and assert the absence of delay for
getStatusesis well-implemented, ensuring that the delay mechanism does not affect all types of requests.
66-67: Test logic forgetCarsapproved.The logic to capture and assert the delay status for
getCarsis consistent with other tests, effectively verifying the delay mechanism's functionality across different API calls.
72-72: Final assertion for delay approved.This assertion confirms that the delay mechanism consistently adheres to specified time constraints, which is crucial for the reliability of the delay functionality.
src/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/FleetApiClient.cpp (8)
Line range hint
16-31: Good use of const correctness in constructor initialization.The initialization of
apiConfigPtras a const shared pointer is a good practice, ensuring that the configuration cannot be modified after creation, which aligns with the principle of immutability.
45-45: Enhanced method signature with const correctness and simplified namespace.The addition of the const qualifier in
setDeviceIdentificationensures that the method does not alter the state of theFleetApiClientinstance. Simplifying the namespace fromfleet_protocol::tocxx::improves readability and reduces verbosity.
53-68: Improved return type and const correctness ingetCars.The method now returns a
std::pair, which includes a boolean to indicate if the request was delayed, enhancing the method's utility by providing more context to the caller. Marking the method as const is appropriate as it does not modify the state of theFleetApiClient.
72-87: Consistent improvements ingetCommandswith detailed delay reporting.Updating the return type to a
std::pairand marking the method as const are consistent with similar changes in other methods, ensuring uniform handling and reporting of delays across the class.
91-106: Enhanced delay detection ingetStatuses.The method
getStatusesnow returns astd::pairthat includes delay information, similar to other methods in the class. This consistency in the API design helps in better managing and understanding the state of requests.
110-118: Appropriate use of const qualifier insendCommand.Marking
sendCommandas const is a good practice, ensuring that the method does not alter the state of theFleetApiClient. This change is aligned with the overall improvements in const correctness across the class.
Line range hint
123-140: Robust handling of status types insendStatus.The method
sendStatusis correctly marked as const, which is consistent with the class's emphasis on const correctness. The method robustly handles different status types, ensuring that the functionality is preserved while preventing any modifications to the object's state.
145-151: Consistent return type and const correctness ingetAvailableDevices.The method
getAvailableDevicesis marked as const, which is consistent with other methods in the class. The return type of a shared pointer toAvailableDevicesis appropriate, allowing the method to provide complex data without modifying the object's state.include/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/FleetApiClient.hpp (7)
52-52: Consistent method signature with implementation.The header file's method signature for
setDeviceIdentificationmatches the implementation file, including the const qualifier and simplified namespace. This consistency is crucial for maintainability and correctness.
60-62: Improved return type and const correctness ingetCars.The method now returns a
std::pair, which includes a boolean to indicate if the request was delayed, enhancing the method's utility by providing more context to the caller. Marking the method as const is appropriate as it does not modify the state of theFleetApiClient.
70-72: Consistent improvements ingetCommandswith detailed delay reporting.Updating the return type to a
std::pairand marking the method as const are consistent with similar changes in other methods, ensuring uniform handling and reporting of delays across the class.
80-82: Enhanced delay detection ingetStatuses.The method
getStatusesnow returns astd::pairthat includes delay information, similar to other methods in the class. This consistency in the API design helps in better managing and understanding the state of requests.
89-89: Appropriate use of const qualifier insendCommand.Marking
sendCommandas const is a good practice, ensuring that the method does not alter the state of theFleetApiClient. This change is aligned with the overall improvements in const correctness across the class.
97-97: Robust handling of status types insendStatus.The method
sendStatusis correctly marked as const, which is consistent with the class's emphasis on const correctness. The method robustly handles different status types, ensuring that the functionality is preserved while preventing any modifications to the object's state.
104-105: Consistent return type and const correctness ingetAvailableDevices.The method
getAvailableDevicesis marked as const, which is consistent with other methods in the class. The return type of a shared pointer toAvailableDevicesis appropriate, allowing the method to provide complex data without modifying the object's state.test/src/RequestFrequencyGuardTests.cpp (4)
17-26: Improved assertions inThresholdNotReached.The update to use
ASSERT_FALSEfor checking the return value ofhandleDelays()enhances the clarity and accuracy of the test, ensuring that the expected behavior is correctly verified.
54-54: Correctly placed assertions inThresholdReached.The use of assertions to check the delay handling when the threshold is reached is appropriate. These assertions help ensure that the
handleDelays()method behaves as expected under threshold conditions.
Line range hint
85-102: Effective verification of delay reset behavior inDelayResetAfterThresholdReached.The test case effectively verifies that the delay handling is correctly reset after the threshold is reached. The use of
ASSERT_FALSEto check for the absence of delays after the reset is appropriate and ensures that thehandleDelays()method functions as intended.
147-152: Thorough testing of continuous delay behavior inDelayNotResetAfterThresholdReached.The test case accurately verifies that delays continue when the threshold is persistently triggered. The use of
ASSERT_TRUEto confirm the presence of delays is appropriate, ensuring that thehandleDelays()method behaves as expected under continuous threshold conditions.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (3)
- include/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/FleetApiClient.hpp (2 hunks)
- src/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/FleetApiClient.cpp (4 hunks)
- test/src/FleetApiClientTests.cpp (4 hunks)
Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (2)
- src/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/FleetApiClient.cpp
- test/src/FleetApiClientTests.cpp
Additional comments not posted (7)
include/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/FleetApiClient.hpp (7)
60-60: Approved: Const-correctness insetDeviceIdentification.The addition of
consttosetDeviceIdentificationis appropriate, assuming the method does not modify the object state. This enhances the usability of the method in contexts where a constant instance ofFleetApiClientis used.
68-70: Approved: Enhanced return type ingetCars.The change to return a
std::pairincluding aReturnCodeis a significant improvement. It allows the method to communicate operation status effectively, aligning with the PR's goals to handle delays better. Ensure that the calling code is updated to handle this new return type appropriately.
78-80: Approved: Enhanced return type ingetCommands.Updating the return type to include a
ReturnCodeenhances the method's ability to communicate its success or any delays encountered. This change is consistent with the PR's objectives and improves the method's utility. Ensure that the calling code is adapted to handle this new return type.
88-90: Approved: Enhanced return type and parameter optimization ingetStatuses.The method now returns a
std::pairincluding aReturnCode, which is consistent with other similar changes in the PR. Additionally, passing thewaitparameter by const reference is a good optimization to avoid unnecessary copies. Ensure the calling code is updated to handle these changes.
97-97: Approved: Const-correctness insendCommand.The addition of
consttosendCommandis appropriate, assuming the method does not modify the object state. This change enhances the method's usability in contexts where a constant instance ofFleetApiClientis used.
105-105: Approved: Const-correctness insendStatus.The addition of
consttosendStatusis appropriate, assuming the method does not modify the object state. This enhances the usability of the method in contexts where a constant instance ofFleetApiClientis used.
112-113: Approved: Enhanced return type and const-correctness ingetAvailableDevices.The method now returns a
std::shared_ptrto theAvailableDevicesmodel, which is a suitable return type for complex data structures. The addition ofconstis appropriate, assuming the method does not modify the object state. Ensure that the calling code is updated to handle this new return type appropriately.
include/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/FleetApiClient.hpp
Outdated
Show resolved
Hide resolved
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Outside diff range, codebase verification and nitpick comments (4)
include/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/FleetApiClient.hpp (4)
25-33: Approve the addition of ReturnCode enum with a minor suggestion.The new
ReturnCodeenum class is a good addition, providing more context about the result of operations. This aligns well with the PR objectives of detecting long delays in the system.Consider slightly rewording the comment for the
DELAYEDvalue to be more precise:// request was delayed due to request rate threshold being reached - DELAYED + DELAYED // request was delayed due to the request rate threshold being reached
68-72: Approve changes to getCars with a minor suggestion.The updates to the
getCarsmethod, including the new return type,[[nodiscard]]attribute, andconstqualifier, are excellent improvements. They provide more information about the operation's result and enhance code safety and const-correctness.Consider updating the comment to be more specific about the return value:
- * @return Vector of shared pointers to the Car model and a return code + * @return A pair containing a vector of shared pointers to Car models and a ReturnCode indicating the operation result
78-82: Approve changes to getCommands with a minor suggestion.The updates to the
getCommandsmethod, including the new return type,[[nodiscard]]attribute, andconstqualifier, are excellent improvements. They provide more information about the operation's result and enhance code safety and const-correctness.Consider updating the comment to be more specific about the return value:
- * @return Vector of shared pointers to the Message model containing commands in payload data and a return code + * @return A pair containing a vector of shared pointers to Message models (with commands in payload data) and a ReturnCode indicating the operation result
Line range hint
1-138: Summary: Excellent improvements to FleetApiClient classThe changes made to the
FleetApiClientclass in this PR are well-designed and align perfectly with the stated objectives. Key improvements include:
- Introduction of the
ReturnCodeenum to provide more context about operation results.- Enhanced return types for
getCars,getCommands, andgetStatusesmethods, allowing for better delay detection.- Improved const-correctness across all methods.
- Addition of
[[nodiscard]]attributes to encourage proper use of return values.These changes collectively contribute to a more robust, safe, and informative API, which should greatly improve the ability to monitor and handle delays in the system.
Consider applying these improvements consistently across other parts of the codebase that interact with this class. This will ensure a uniform approach to error handling and delay detection throughout the project.
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (1)
- include/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/FleetApiClient.hpp (2 hunks)
Additional comments not posted (4)
include/bringauto/fleet_protocol/http_client/FleetApiClient.hpp (4)
62-62: Approve the addition of const qualifier to setDeviceIdentification.The addition of the
constqualifier to thesetDeviceIdentificationmethod improves const-correctness, indicating that this method doesn't modify the object's state. This is a good C++ practice.
99-99: Approve the addition of const qualifier to sendCommand.The addition of the
constqualifier to thesendCommandmethod improves const-correctness, indicating that this method doesn't modify the object's state. This change is consistent with the improvements made to other methods in the class.
107-107: Approve changes to sendStatus and getAvailableDevices methods.The updates to both
sendStatusandgetAvailableDevicesmethods are consistent with the improvements made to other methods in the class:
sendStatus: The addition of theconstqualifier improves const-correctness.getAvailableDevices: The addition of the[[nodiscard]]attribute andconstqualifier enhances code safety and const-correctness.These changes contribute to a more robust and consistent API design.
Also applies to: 114-115
88-92: Approve changes to getStatuses with suggestions and a question.The updates to the
getStatusesmethod, including the new return type,[[nodiscard]]attribute, andconstqualifier, are excellent improvements. They provide more information about the operation's result and enhance code safety and const-correctness.Consider updating the comment to be more specific about the return value:
- * @return Vector of shared pointers to the Message model containing statuses in payload data and a return code + * @return A pair containing a vector of shared pointers to Message models (with statuses in payload data) and a ReturnCode indicating the operation resultThe
waitparameter is now passed by const reference, unlike ingetCarsandgetCommands. Is this intentional? If so, should we apply this change to the other methods as well for consistency?
Ba logger can cause problems in this project. All logging should be handled one level higher. It's possible to detect long delays now due to newly added return values to functions that can cause delays.
Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
FleetApiClientmethods to return additional context on request delays, enhancing usability.handleDelaysmethod to indicate success or failure of delay handling.Bug Fixes
Documentation
bringauto-loggerdependency.Refactor
FleetApiClientandRequestFrequencyGuard.Tests
FleetApiClientto validate delay handling.RequestFrequencyGuardTestsfor better outcome verification.