Gruehn-2008-200 #1435
Gruehn-2008-200 #1435
Conversation
|
I've added the Gruehn-2008-200 dataset, @AnnikaTjuka would you moderate the PR? |
|
Sure, I'll moderate. @chrzyki or @FredericBlum Would one of you have time to review this PR? |
|
Yes, I'll do a review tomorrow. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Thank you very much for preparing and adding the list! I did a first pass. One thing I noticed is that we've got lots of reasonable candidates for new concepts (in varying degrees of importance/other unmapped cases), e.g.:
DEPENDENT
AGGRESSIVE
PRECISE
SILLY
PLEASANT
INSPIRED
TENSE
ARROGANT
PERSISTENT
DELIBERATE
TROUBLED
MODEST
MALICIOUS
BRUTAL
DOMINANT
LONELY
DETERMINED
SERIOUS
HOSTILE
PEACEFUL
COMFORTABLE
MODEST
THOROUGH
MORAL
NORMAL
TIDY
RESTLESS
SENSITIVE
LOYAL
PLEASED
| Gruehn-2008-200-12 12 angepasst conformist 7.722 2.667 2.417 4.167 3.75 2.542 3.958 3.25 4.75 4.583 2.583 4 4.667 3.292 3.979 2.5 3.25 5.083 3.833 2.875 4.458 3.667 2.182 3.083 3.417 3 2.652 3.208 2.936 3.5 3.5 4.25 3.917 3.5 4.083 3.792 3.833 3.833 3.833 3.25 3.833 3.542 3.688 3.813 3.813 1.208 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-13 13 angeregt inspired 8.621 5.333 5.417 4.727 5.75 5.375 5.261 5.319 4.333 4.167 3.917 4.5 4.25 4.208 4.229 5 4.25 4.583 4.667 4.625 4.625 4.625 3.667 3.75 4.75 4.583 3.708 4.667 4.188 5.25 5 5.636 4.917 5.125 5.261 5.191 2.5 2.333 2.5 2.583 2.417 2.542 2.479 6 5.563 1.917 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-14 14 angespannt tense 4.28 2.333 2.167 2.667 3.25 2.25 2.958 2.604 6.25 6.333 5.417 5.727 6.292 5.565 5.936 3.667 3.5 4.333 6 3.583 5.167 4.375 4.5 4.583 4.167 4 4.542 4.083 4.313 4 3.25 3.167 3.5 3.625 3.333 3.479 2.75 2.583 2.583 2.417 2.667 2.5 2.583 2.267 2.563 1.833 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-15 15 aengstlich afraid 6.332 2.417 2.25 2.583 2.583 2.333 2.583 2.458 5.5 5.5 5.417 4 5.5 4.708 5.104 1.833 1.917 2.182 2.667 1.875 2.435 2.149 5.417 5.917 4.917 5.333 5.667 5.125 5.396 3.25 2.5 2.75 2.25 2.875 2.5 2.688 3.667 3.667 4.083 3.583 3.667 3.833 3.75 1.75 2.063 2 |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
3033 SCARED? This is also mapped to some instances of afraid.
| Gruehn-2008-200-22 22 ausgeglichen balanced 11.467 6.75 6.25 6.417 6.083 6.5 6.25 6.375 1.667 2.417 2.417 2.5 2.042 2.458 2.25 5.667 5 4.75 5.083 5.333 4.917 5.125 3.75 3.5 4.5 2.833 3.625 3.667 3.646 4.917 4.083 5.333 5 4.5 5.167 4.833 3.333 4.083 3.833 4.083 3.708 3.958 3.833 6.813 6.375 1.833 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-23 23 autoritaer authoritarian 1.537 2.75 2.167 2.167 2.083 2.458 2.125 2.292 5.167 5.75 5.5 5.917 5.458 5.708 5.583 5.5 5.917 5.167 4.667 5.708 4.917 5.313 4.75 5.75 4.333 5.417 5.25 4.875 5.063 3.25 2.917 4.083 2.917 3.083 3.5 3.292 3.917 3.5 3.818 3.25 3.708 3.522 3.617 3 1.875 1 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-24 24 bedaechtig deliberate 1.866 4.25 3.833 4.917 4.25 4.042 4.583 4.313 2.917 2.917 2.5 3.083 2.917 2.792 2.854 5 5 4.167 3.833 4.1 4 4.5 3.583 3.417 4.5 3.5 3.5 4 3.75 3.917 4 4.5 4.667 3.958 4.583 4.271 4 4.167 3.917 4 4.083 3.958 4.021 5 5.438 1.833 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-25 25 begeistert enthusiastic 3972 EXCITED 24.183 6.083 6 6 5.75 6.042 5.875 5.958 4.5 4.083 4.75 4.583 4.292 4.667 4.479 4.833 4.083 3.833 4.583 4.458 4.208 4.333 5.455 6 5.667 5.667 5.739 5.667 5.702 5.667 5 5.917 4.917 5.333 5.417 5.375 2.5 1.917 1.833 2 2.208 1.917 2.063 6.438 6.063 1.708 |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I think this mapping works, but checking the concept itself I'm not sure whether I'm happy with the definition. Will think about that a bit more. What do the others think?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Yes, I was also a bit surprised about the definition. It might be better to unmap and update the definition of the concept. @MiraAhmedovic Could you please add an issue linking to @chrzyki's comment above so that we can update the definition later.
| Gruehn-2008-200-60 60 erfreut delighted 12.147 6.75 6.417 6.917 6 6.583 6.478 6.532 3.667 3 3.364 3.667 3.333 3.522 3.426 4.636 4.5 4.364 4.333 4.565 4.348 4.457 5.417 5.1 6 5.5 5.708 5.75 5.729 5.5 5.333 5.333 4.75 5.417 5.042 5.229 3.083 2.333 2.833 2.75 2.708 2.792 2.75 6.688 6.313 1.917 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-61 61 ernst serious 50.072 4.583 4.083 5.25 5.333 4.333 5.292 4.813 4.667 5.333 4.417 4.667 5 4.542 4.771 5.417 5.167 4.333 5 5.292 4.667 4.979 4.583 4.917 5.25 4 4.75 4.625 4.688 4.833 4.75 4.667 4.917 4.792 4.792 4.792 4.083 3.917 3.833 4.083 4 3.958 3.979 4.625 4.625 1.917 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-62 62 erschoepft exhausted 10.781 3.917 3.75 2.833 2.833 3.833 2.833 3.333 3.75 2.75 3.417 2.833 3.25 3.125 3.188 2.5 2 3.273 2.75 2.25 3 2.617 4.583 5.167 5.083 5.75 4.875 5.417 5.146 4 3.25 2.667 2.75 3.625 2.708 3.167 4.25 4 4.083 3.667 4.125 3.875 4 2.625 3.25 2 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-63 63 erstaunt astonished 10.944 4.75 4.583 4.5 4.083 4.667 4.292 4.479 4 4.417 4 4.75 4.208 4.375 4.292 3.25 2.667 3.25 3.5 2.958 3.375 3.167 5.083 6 4.667 5.25 5.542 4.958 5.25 3.917 3.417 4.5 3.5 3.667 4 3.833 3.25 3.167 2.5 2.583 3.208 2.542 2.875 4.813 4.75 1.917 |
| Gruehn-2008-200-64 64 feige cowardly 3812 COWARDLY 2.852 1.833 1.833 2.083 1.917 1.833 2 1.917 5.167 5.5 4.667 4.083 5.333 4.375 4.854 2.417 1.667 2.917 3.167 2.042 3.042 2.542 3.667 4.417 4.417 4.5 4.042 4.458 4.25 2.917 2.333 2 2.083 2.625 2.042 2.333 2.75 2.667 2.583 3 2.708 2.792 2.75 1.75 2.125 1.458 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-65 65 feindselig hostile 1.011 1.333 1.75 1.417 1.5 1.542 1.458 1.5 6.5 6.167 6.333 6.417 6.333 6.375 6.354 3.083 4.25 4.75 3.333 3.667 4.042 3.854 3.833 4.667 4.583 5.333 4.25 4.958 4.604 1.583 2.5 1.333 1.5 2.042 1.417 1.729 2.833 3.333 3.083 2.75 3.083 2.917 3 1.688 1.188 1.083 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-66 66 fies nasty 632 1.167 1.75 1.25 1.417 1.458 1.333 1.396 5.917 5.5 6.417 5.25 5.708 5.833 5.771 4.5 4.273 4 3.417 4.391 3.708 4.043 4.75 5.917 4.583 5.5 5.333 5.042 5.188 2.25 3.25 1.583 1.583 2.75 1.583 2.167 2.583 2.417 2.917 3.167 2.5 3.042 2.771 1.688 1.188 1 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-67 67 flexibel flexible 1691 FLEXIBLE 08.04 5.75 5 6.083 5.333 5.375 5.708 5.542 2.75 3.083 3.25 3.917 2.917 3.583 3.25 6.083 5.583 4.333 5.417 5.833 4.875 5.354 2.727 2.583 4.083 3.5 2.652 3.792 3.234 5.5 5.5 6.167 5.667 5.5 5.917 5.708 1.75 1.417 2.25 2.75 1.583 2.5 2.042 5.938 5.875 1.667 |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Our entry for 1691 FLEXIBLE is particularly concerned with flexible in the physical sense, i.e. easy to bend etc. One might say that our entry isn't... flexible enough?
| Gruehn-2008-200-176 176 unangenehm unpleasant 26 UNPLEASANT 6.313 1.75 1.417 1.417 2.091 1.583 1.739 1.66 5.75 4.833 5.333 4.455 5.292 4.913 5.106 2.667 2.833 4.167 2.667 2.75 3.417 3.083 3.25 3.583 4.583 3.75 3.417 4.167 3.792 1.667 2.083 2 2.167 1.875 2.083 1.979 3 3.083 2.917 2.75 3.042 2.833 2.938 1.813 1.313 1 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-177 177 ungestuem impetuous 1.9 3.75 3.5 3.167 3.417 3.625 3.292 3.458 3.917 5.5 5.417 5.167 4.708 5.292 5 2.917 2.583 3.5 3 2.75 3.25 3 5.083 4.583 5.667 5.417 4.833 5.542 5.188 3.083 3.333 2.5 2.5 3.208 2.5 2.854 2.25 1.417 1.583 1.75 1.833 1.667 1.75 3.563 3.5 1.083 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-178 178 unnahbar unapproachable 1.2 2.833 2.5 2.667 2.583 2.667 2.625 2.646 5 4.583 5 4.5 4.792 4.75 4.771 4.583 3.75 4.417 3.917 4.167 4.167 4.167 4.182 3.333 4.75 4.5 3.739 4.625 4.191 2.833 3.333 2.25 3.417 3.083 2.833 2.958 2.917 2.833 3.25 3.5 2.875 3.375 3.125 2.438 2.25 1 | ||
| Gruehn-2008-200-179 179 unruhig jittery 5.352 2.25 2.333 2.5 3 2.292 2.75 2.521 5.917 5.5 5.833 5.583 5.708 5.708 5.708 2.333 2.333 4.167 2.917 2.333 3.542 2.938 5 4.417 4.667 5.167 4.708 4.917 4.813 4.083 3.75 2.333 3.5 3.917 2.917 3.417 2.667 2.25 2.583 2.583 2.458 2.583 2.521 2.25 2.563 1.833 |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
We already have a mapping with "nervoes" so I'd leave this one unmapped.
|
@chrzyki Many thanks for your review, @chrzyki ! Re the new concepts: I agree that there are many possible candidates for new concepts, but I wanted to make the PR as straightforward as possible for @MiraAhmedovic since this is her first Concepticon list. I suggest that we open an issue with your suggestions so that we can discuss which concepts should be added separately. @MiraAhmedovic The next step is for you to go through the comments and update the files accordingly. Please let us know when you implemented the changes. |
Understood, my remarks concerning new concepts weren't particularly meant just for @MiraAhmedovic but for us in general. |
|
I've now implemented the changes, @chrzyki would you take a look at them? |
Thank you, will do! |
|
Looks good, thanks for implementing the changes! I'll have a look at the other issues we've discussed relating to this list. |
Pull request checklist
concepticon notlinked --gloss "NEW_GLOSS"Additional information
Adding dataset Gruehn-2008-200 based on "Characteristics for 200 words rated by young and older adults: Age-dependent evaluations of German adjectives (AGE)" by Grühn & Smith (2008), closes #1280.
...