Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Download should include gene symbol (bioentity_label) by default #471

Open
krchristie opened this issue Feb 22, 2018 · 2 comments
Open

Download should include gene symbol (bioentity_label) by default #471

krchristie opened this issue Feb 22, 2018 · 2 comments

Comments

@krchristie
Copy link

This past week I was using AmiGO to download annotation files. I see why this is happening, but I find it very annoying that the default download does NOT include the gene symbol.

I don't really object to hiding the gene ID on the web display, but if translating the first column that is really the ID into the gene symbol on the web display, and then not having the column for gene symbol results in NOT including the gene symbol in the download file, I'd rather have the ID in the web display too, so I don't have to add the gene symbol to the download file EVERY time I make a download.

In addition, the first time I did this, it was a bit difficult to figure out the correct column to add. Thus, I think that this might be really frustrating to users.

Here's more details to illustrate what I mean:
The AmiGO web display shows these columns with this type of info in the first two columns, i.e. the gene product ID is NOT shown on the web page, but is instead translated into the gene symbol.

Gene/product = Arx
Gene/product name = aristaless related homeobox
Annotation qualifier
GO class (direct)
Annotation extension
Contributor
Organism
Evidence
Evidence with
PANTHER family
Isoform
Reference
Date

However, when you go to download this, you now get this info, where the gene symbol is not missing from the download file.

1 - Gene/product (bioentity): MGI:MGI:1097716
2 - Gene/product name (bioentity_name): aristaless related homeobox
3 - Annotation qualifier (qualifier): [blank]
4 - GO class (direct) (annotation_class): GO:0044241
5 - Annotation extension (annotation_extension_json): "{""relationship"": {""relation"": [{""id"": ""RO:0000057"", ""label"": ""has participant""}], ""id"": ""EMAPA:32764"", ""label"": ""EMAPA:32764""}}"
6 - Contributor (assigned_by): MGI
7 - Organism (taxon): NCBITaxon:10090
8 - Evidence (evidence_type): IMP
9 - Evidence with (evidence_with): MGI:MGI:3803178
10 - PANTHER family (panther_family): PANTHER:PTHR24329
11 - Isoform (bioentity_isoform):
12 - Reference (reference): MGI:MGI:5426506|PMID:22387004
13 - Date (date): 20130724

What I would really want in a download file would be this, with BOTH the gene ID and the gene symbol (using same column number as above to facilitate comparison).

1 - Gene/product (bioentity): MGI:MGI:1097716
=> - Gene/product (bioentity_label) Arx
2 - Gene/product name (bioentity_name): aristaless related homeobox
3 - Annotation qualifier (qualifier): [blank]
4 - GO class (direct) (annotation_class): GO:0044241
5 - Annotation extension (annotation_extension_json): "{""relationship"": {""relation"": [{""id"": ""RO:0000057"", ""label"": ""has participant""}], ""id"": ""EMAPA:32764"", ""label"": ""EMAPA:32764""}}"
6 - Contributor (assigned_by): MGI
7 - Organism (taxon): NCBITaxon:10090
8 - Evidence (evidence_type): IMP
9 - Evidence with (evidence_with): MGI:MGI:3803178
10 - PANTHER family (panther_family): PANTHER:PTHR24329
11 - Isoform (bioentity_isoform):
12 - Reference (reference): MGI:MGI:5426506|PMID:22387004
13 - Date (date): 20130724

@ValWood
Copy link

ValWood commented Feb 22, 2018

See also
#194

@kltm kltm modified the milestones: wishlist, 2.5 Feb 22, 2018
@kltm
Copy link
Member

kltm commented Oct 11, 2023

Bumping. Noting that this was also brought up in geneontology/helpdesk#457 . I see that the main downloads do have this included, but the sub-downloads (i.e. term page "Annotations") does not.

@kltm kltm removed this from the 2.5 milestone Oct 11, 2023
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants