Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Server to Client subflows: option to allow joining the initial address and port #335

Open
matttbe opened this issue Jan 11, 2023 · 2 comments
Open

Server to Client subflows: option to allow joining the initial address and port #335

matttbe opened this issue Jan 11, 2023 · 2 comments
Labels
enhancement pm path-manager

Comments

@matttbe
Copy link
Member

matttbe commented Jan 11, 2023 •
edited
Loading

This is a follow up of the discussions that @pabeni started on #331: #331 (comment)

If on the server side, the PM has endpoints created with both the flags signal and subflow, the server will try to establish subflows.

In this case, the client might not accept MP_JOIN sent to the initial address and port. There is one sysctl knob linked to that (net.mptcp.allow_join_initial_addr_port) but it currently only affects the server both sides and that is problematic:

  • it's reasonable to have different value on the client and server side
  • even if flipping the client side to accept incoming subflow requests to the initial address and port, such port will be closed at the TCP level (no listener there) and we can't easily (possibly not at all) open it, even with the user-space path manager.

It would then be ideal to allow the client to accept these subflows but still let the client to enable or disable that e.g. by "extending" the sysctl knob:

  • net.mptcp.allow_join_initial_addr_port = 0: always disable
  • net.mptcp.allow_join_initial_addr_port = 1: only for the server side
  • net.mptcp.allow_join_initial_addr_port = 2: only for the client side
  • use a bit field if we need to have accept for both server/client (if it makes sense): 3 would be to accept for both the client and the server side

Another option would be always forcing the allow_join_id0 to false for client side, regardless the sysctl value (make the sysctl only relevant for the server side)

(updated after Paolo's comment)
@matttbe matttbe mentioned this issue Jan 11, 2023
Closed
@pabeni
Copy link

pabeni commented Jan 11, 2023

In this case, the client might not accept MP_JOIN sent to the initial address and port. There is one sysctl knob linked to that (net.mptcp.allow_join_initial_addr_port) but it currently only affects the server side.

To be more accurate, the sysctl affects both the client and the server side, but that is problematic:

  • it's reasonable to have different value on the client and server side
  • even if flipping the client side to 'accept incoming subflow requests to the initial address and port', such port will be closed at the TCP level (no listener there) and we can't easily (possibly not at all) open it, even with the user-space path manager.

So another option would be always forcing the allow_join_id0 to false for client side, regardless the sysctl value (make the sysctl only relevant server side)

@matttbe
Copy link
Member Author

matttbe commented Jan 11, 2023

Thank you for the clarification. I just updated the first comment to avoid some confusions later

@matttbe matttbe moved this to Needs triage in MPTCP Upstream: Future Feb 22, 2023
@geliangtang geliangtang added the pm path-manager label Aug 4, 2023
jenkins-tessares pushed a commit that referenced this issue Aug 26, 2023
@borkmann
selftests/bpf: Enable cpu v4 tests for arm64
5f6395f 
Enable CPU v4 instruction tests for arm64. Below are the test results from
BPF test_progs selftests:

  # ./test_progs -t ldsx_insn,verifier_sdiv,verifier_movsx,verifier_ldsx,verifier_gotol,verifier_bswap
  #115/1   ldsx_insn/map_val and probed_memory:OK
  #115/2   ldsx_insn/ctx_member_sign_ext:OK
  #115/3   ldsx_insn/ctx_member_narrow_sign_ext:OK
  #115     ldsx_insn:OK
  #302/1   verifier_bswap/BSWAP, 16:OK
  #302/2   verifier_bswap/BSWAP, 16 @unpriv:OK
  #302/3   verifier_bswap/BSWAP, 32:OK
  #302/4   verifier_bswap/BSWAP, 32 @unpriv:OK
  #302/5   verifier_bswap/BSWAP, 64:OK
  #302/6   verifier_bswap/BSWAP, 64 @unpriv:OK
  #302     verifier_bswap:OK
  #316/1   verifier_gotol/gotol, small_imm:OK
  #316/2   verifier_gotol/gotol, small_imm @unpriv:OK
  #316     verifier_gotol:OK
  #324/1   verifier_ldsx/LDSX, S8:OK
  #324/2   verifier_ldsx/LDSX, S8 @unpriv:OK
  #324/3   verifier_ldsx/LDSX, S16:OK
  #324/4   verifier_ldsx/LDSX, S16 @unpriv:OK
  #324/5   verifier_ldsx/LDSX, S32:OK
  #324/6   verifier_ldsx/LDSX, S32 @unpriv:OK
  #324/7   verifier_ldsx/LDSX, S8 range checking, privileged:OK
  #324/8   verifier_ldsx/LDSX, S16 range checking:OK
  #324/9   verifier_ldsx/LDSX, S16 range checking @unpriv:OK
  #324/10  verifier_ldsx/LDSX, S32 range checking:OK
  #324/11  verifier_ldsx/LDSX, S32 range checking @unpriv:OK
  #324     verifier_ldsx:OK
  #335/1   verifier_movsx/MOV32SX, S8:OK
  #335/2   verifier_movsx/MOV32SX, S8 @unpriv:OK
  #335/3   verifier_movsx/MOV32SX, S16:OK
  #335/4   verifier_movsx/MOV32SX, S16 @unpriv:OK
  #335/5   verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S8:OK
  #335/6   verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S8 @unpriv:OK
  #335/7   verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S16:OK
  #335/8   verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S16 @unpriv:OK
  #335/9   verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S32:OK
  #335/10  verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S32 @unpriv:OK
  #335/11  verifier_movsx/MOV32SX, S8, range_check:OK
  #335/12  verifier_movsx/MOV32SX, S8, range_check @unpriv:OK
  #335/13  verifier_movsx/MOV32SX, S16, range_check:OK
  #335/14  verifier_movsx/MOV32SX, S16, range_check @unpriv:OK
  #335/15  verifier_movsx/MOV32SX, S16, range_check 2:OK
  #335/16  verifier_movsx/MOV32SX, S16, range_check 2 @unpriv:OK
  #335/17  verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S8, range_check:OK
  #335/18  verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S8, range_check @unpriv:OK
  #335/19  verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S16, range_check:OK
  #335/20  verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S16, range_check @unpriv:OK
  #335/21  verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S32, range_check:OK
  #335/22  verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S32, range_check @unpriv:OK
  #335/23  verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S16, R10 Sign Extension:OK
  #335/24  verifier_movsx/MOV64SX, S16, R10 Sign Extension @unpriv:OK
  #335     verifier_movsx:OK
  #347/1   verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 1:OK
  #347/2   verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 1 @unpriv:OK
  #347/3   verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 2:OK
  #347/4   verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 2 @unpriv:OK
  #347/5   verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 3:OK
  #347/6   verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 3 @unpriv:OK
  #347/7   verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 4:OK
  #347/8   verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 4 @unpriv:OK
  #347/9   verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 5:OK
  #347/10  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 5 @unpriv:OK
  #347/11  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 6:OK
  #347/12  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 6 @unpriv:OK
  #347/13  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 7:OK
  #347/14  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 7 @unpriv:OK
  #347/15  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 8:OK
  #347/16  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero imm divisor, check 8 @unpriv:OK
  #347/17  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 1:OK
  #347/18  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 1 @unpriv:OK
  #347/19  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 2:OK
  #347/20  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 2 @unpriv:OK
  #347/21  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 3:OK
  #347/22  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 3 @unpriv:OK
  #347/23  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 4:OK
  #347/24  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 4 @unpriv:OK
  #347/25  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 5:OK
  #347/26  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 5 @unpriv:OK
  #347/27  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 6:OK
  #347/28  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 6 @unpriv:OK
  #347/29  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 7:OK
  #347/30  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 7 @unpriv:OK
  #347/31  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 8:OK
  #347/32  verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, non-zero reg divisor, check 8 @unpriv:OK
  #347/33  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero imm divisor, check 1:OK
  #347/34  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero imm divisor, check 1 @unpriv:OK
  #347/35  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero imm divisor, check 2:OK
  #347/36  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero imm divisor, check 2 @unpriv:OK
  #347/37  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero imm divisor, check 3:OK
  #347/38  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero imm divisor, check 3 @unpriv:OK
  #347/39  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero imm divisor, check 4:OK
  #347/40  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero imm divisor, check 4 @unpriv:OK
  #347/41  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero imm divisor, check 5:OK
  #347/42  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero imm divisor, check 5 @unpriv:OK
  #347/43  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero imm divisor, check 6:OK
  #347/44  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero imm divisor, check 6 @unpriv:OK
  #347/45  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero reg divisor, check 1:OK
  #347/46  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero reg divisor, check 1 @unpriv:OK
  #347/47  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero reg divisor, check 2:OK
  #347/48  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero reg divisor, check 2 @unpriv:OK
  #347/49  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero reg divisor, check 3:OK
  #347/50  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero reg divisor, check 3 @unpriv:OK
  #347/51  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero reg divisor, check 4:OK
  #347/52  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero reg divisor, check 4 @unpriv:OK
  #347/53  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero reg divisor, check 5:OK
  #347/54  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero reg divisor, check 5 @unpriv:OK
  #347/55  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero reg divisor, check 6:OK
  #347/56  verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, non-zero reg divisor, check 6 @unpriv:OK
  #347/57  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero imm divisor, check 1:OK
  #347/58  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero imm divisor, check 1 @unpriv:OK
  #347/59  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero imm divisor, check 2:OK
  #347/60  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero imm divisor, check 2 @unpriv:OK
  #347/61  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero imm divisor, check 3:OK
  #347/62  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero imm divisor, check 3 @unpriv:OK
  #347/63  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero imm divisor, check 4:OK
  #347/64  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero imm divisor, check 4 @unpriv:OK
  #347/65  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero imm divisor, check 5:OK
  #347/66  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero imm divisor, check 5 @unpriv:OK
  #347/67  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero imm divisor, check 6:OK
  #347/68  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero imm divisor, check 6 @unpriv:OK
  #347/69  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero reg divisor, check 1:OK
  #347/70  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero reg divisor, check 1 @unpriv:OK
  #347/71  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero reg divisor, check 2:OK
  #347/72  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero reg divisor, check 2 @unpriv:OK
  #347/73  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero reg divisor, check 3:OK
  #347/74  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero reg divisor, check 3 @unpriv:OK
  #347/75  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero reg divisor, check 4:OK
  #347/76  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero reg divisor, check 4 @unpriv:OK
  #347/77  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero reg divisor, check 5:OK
  #347/78  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero reg divisor, check 5 @unpriv:OK
  #347/79  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero reg divisor, check 6:OK
  #347/80  verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, non-zero reg divisor, check 6 @unpriv:OK
  #347/81  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 1:OK
  #347/82  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 1 @unpriv:OK
  #347/83  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 2:OK
  #347/84  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 2 @unpriv:OK
  #347/85  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 3:OK
  #347/86  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 3 @unpriv:OK
  #347/87  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 4:OK
  #347/88  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 4 @unpriv:OK
  #347/89  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 5:OK
  #347/90  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 5 @unpriv:OK
  #347/91  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 6:OK
  #347/92  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 6 @unpriv:OK
  #347/93  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 7:OK
  #347/94  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 7 @unpriv:OK
  #347/95  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 8:OK
  #347/96  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero imm divisor, check 8 @unpriv:OK
  #347/97  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 1:OK
  #347/98  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 1 @unpriv:OK
  #347/99  verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 2:OK
  #347/100 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 2 @unpriv:OK
  #347/101 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 3:OK
  #347/102 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 3 @unpriv:OK
  #347/103 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 4:OK
  #347/104 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 4 @unpriv:OK
  #347/105 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 5:OK
  #347/106 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 5 @unpriv:OK
  #347/107 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 6:OK
  #347/108 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 6 @unpriv:OK
  #347/109 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 7:OK
  #347/110 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 7 @unpriv:OK
  #347/111 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 8:OK
  #347/112 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, non-zero reg divisor, check 8 @unpriv:OK
  #347/113 verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, zero divisor:OK
  #347/114 verifier_sdiv/SDIV32, zero divisor @unpriv:OK
  #347/115 verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, zero divisor:OK
  #347/116 verifier_sdiv/SDIV64, zero divisor @unpriv:OK
  #347/117 verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, zero divisor:OK
  #347/118 verifier_sdiv/SMOD32, zero divisor @unpriv:OK
  #347/119 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, zero divisor:OK
  #347/120 verifier_sdiv/SMOD64, zero divisor @unpriv:OK
  #347     verifier_sdiv:OK
  Summary: 6/166 PASSED, 0 SKIPPED, 0 FAILED

Signed-off-by: Xu Kuohai <xukuohai@huawei.com>
Signed-off-by: Daniel Borkmann <daniel@iogearbox.net>
Tested-by: Florent Revest <revest@chromium.org>
Acked-by: Yonghong Song <yonghong.song@linux.dev>
Acked-by: Florent Revest <revest@chromium.org>
Link: https://lore.kernel.org/bpf/20230815154158.717901-8-xukuohai@huaweicloud.com
matttbe pushed a commit that referenced this issue Jul 10, 2024
@borkmann
selftests/bpf: Extend tcx tests to cover late tcx_entry release
5f1d18d 
Add a test case which replaces an active ingress qdisc while keeping the
miniq in-tact during the transition period to the new clsact qdisc.

  # ./vmtest.sh -- ./test_progs -t tc_link
  [...]
  ./test_progs -t tc_link
  [    3.412871] bpf_testmod: loading out-of-tree module taints kernel.
  [    3.413343] bpf_testmod: module verification failed: signature and/or required key missing - tainting kernel
  #332     tc_links_after:OK
  #333     tc_links_append:OK
  #334     tc_links_basic:OK
  #335     tc_links_before:OK
  #336     tc_links_chain_classic:OK
  #337     tc_links_chain_mixed:OK
  #338     tc_links_dev_chain0:OK
  #339     tc_links_dev_cleanup:OK
  #340     tc_links_dev_mixed:OK
  #341     tc_links_ingress:OK
  #342     tc_links_invalid:OK
  #343     tc_links_prepend:OK
  #344     tc_links_replace:OK
  #345     tc_links_revision:OK
  Summary: 14/0 PASSED, 0 SKIPPED, 0 FAILED

Signed-off-by: Daniel Borkmann <daniel@iogearbox.net>
Cc: Martin KaFai Lau <martin.lau@kernel.org>
Link: https://lore.kernel.org/r/20240708133130.11609-2-daniel@iogearbox.net
Signed-off-by: Martin KaFai Lau <martin.lau@kernel.org>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
enhancement pm path-manager
Projects
MPTCP Upstream: Future
Status: Needs triage
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
3 participants
@matttbe @pabeni @geliangtang