Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Fix #921, make non-selectable FD an error #922

Merged

Conversation

jphickey
Copy link
Contributor

@jphickey jphickey commented Mar 22, 2021

Describe the contribution
Fix #921
Do not silently ignore a filehandle which was included in the OS_FdSet but the "selectable" flag is false. Instead translate this to the OS_ERR_OPERATION_NOT_SUPPORTED error.

Testing performed
Run unit tests on native and RTEMS and make sure all passing

Expected behavior changes
Passing a filehandle into OS_SelectMultiple() (via the OS_FdSet) for which the RTOS does not implement select() should return the
OS_ERR_OPERATION_NOT_SUPPORTED error (again)

System(s) tested on
Ubuntu 20.04 (native) and RTEMS 4.11.3 (cross)

Additional context
This is old behavior but was masked by the fact that OS_SelectMultiple_Impl() actually returned the same error - OS_ERR_OPERATION_NOT_SUPPORTED - for an empty set as it did if one passed a non-empty set that had a non-selectable filehandle within it. If the handles passed in did not support select() then the implementation treated it as an empty set.

A recent change modified that behavior and gave it a different code if the sets were truly empty vs. being not empty but having a bad FD inside it.

However the unit tests were relying specifically on the OS_ERR_OPERATION_NOT_SUPPORTED code being generated in order to skip the test cases on RTEMS.

This change basically restores the return code of OS_ERR_OPERATION_NOT_SUPPORTED but still keeping a unique code for if/when the sets are passed in completely empty.

Contributor Info - All information REQUIRED for consideration of pull request
Joseph Hickey, Vantage Systems, Inc.

Do not silently ignore a filehandle which was included in the OS_FdSet
but the "selectable" flag is false.  Instead translate this to
the OS_ERR_OPERATION_NOT_SUPPORTED error.
@astrogeco astrogeco merged commit db8ccdc into nasa:integration-candidate Mar 22, 2021
astrogeco added a commit to nasa/cFS that referenced this pull request Mar 22, 2021
astrogeco added a commit to nasa/cFS that referenced this pull request Mar 22, 2021
nasa/cFE#1243 v6.8.0-rc1+dev436

  nasa/cFE#1225, Add coverage test fix
  nasa/cFE#1218, Adds a local definition of `SOFTWARE_BIG/LITTLE_BIT_ORDER` directly inside `cfe_endian.h` to provide a compatible symbol for apps that still require this. This allows CFE to build and run successfully when OSAL stops providing this in `common_types.h`.
  nasa/cFE#1193, Removes incorrect statements from Application Developers Guide
  nasa/cFE#1235, Fixes truncation handling on vsnprintf error by adding a cast to avoid implicit conversion
  nasa/cFE#1220, Clarify the documentation on SB MsgId regarding requirements for command and telemetry messages
  nasa/cFE#1230, Avoids undefined behavior and resolves static analysis warnings by casting `isspace` input to `unsigned char`.
  nasa/cFE#1231, Updates message module and msgid v1, `CFE_MSG_SetMsgId`, to use mask instead of cast to alter value. Resolves static analysis warning.
  nasa/cFE#1232, Updates `CFE_ES_FileWriteByteCntErr` to report status, not a `size_t` actual since `OS_write` returns `int32`. Use `int16` for local type from `CFE_TBL_FindTableInRegistry` since it's an index, not a status.
  nasa/cFE#1228, Replaces `<>` with `"` in local `#include`s
  nasa/cFE#1227, Adds `CONTRIBUING.md` that links to the main cFS contributing guide.

nasa/PSP#273 v1.5.0-rc1+dev90

  nasa/PSP#264, modular psp implementation
  nasa/PSP#272, Use quotes for local includes
  nasa/PSP#271, Add Contributing Guide

nasa/osal#917 v5.1.0-rc1+dev347

  nasa/osal#890, Move copyblock size to a #define and add comments
  nasa/osal#891, Removed rogue while loop
  nasa/osal#892, Scripted replacement for #include <os and #include <OSC_ matches of < and > with "
  nasa/osal#893, Consolidates the duplicated switch in OS_SocketOpen_Impl
  nasa/osal#894, Add `const` to input pointers
  nasa/osal#895, Removed network prototypes defined in osapi_sockets.h that are also in osapi_network.h
  nasa/osal#896, Removes NULL redefine from common_types.h
  nasa/osal#912, Add Contributing Guide
  nasa/osal#914, Utilize UTASSERT_CASETYPE_NA to report OS_ERR_NOT_IMPLEMENTED
  nasa/osal#898, correct interval calculation in DoSelect
  nasa/osal#909, comments describing select after connect
  nasa/osal#902, add check for EAGAIN in addition to EINTR
  nasa/osal#908, compile time assert for sockaddr size
  nasa/osal#910, check/report fcntl status
  nasa/osal#897, Add assert for FD_SET_SIZE in relation to OSAL_set
  nasa/osal#903, better error translation for ESPIPE errno
  nasa/osal#840, add shell functional test
  nasa/osal#901, rename OS_U32ValueWrapper_t
  nasa/osal#900, break up logic in return statement
  nasa/osal#906, return moduleInfoGet error
  nasa/osal#907, report timer_gettime error
  nasa/osal#899, remove unreachable test
  nasa/osal#905, make module comment same as other services
  nasa/osal#920 to fix test error check index inside fdset conversions
  nasa/osal#922, make non-selectable FD an error

nasa/sample_app#137 v1.2.0-rc1+dev54

  nasa/sample_app#134, Convert from <> to " for local includes
  nasa/sample_app#136, Added a contributing guide that links to the main cFS contributing guide.
  nasa/sample_app#132, Add context to the values for MsgIDs

nasa/sample_lib#55 v1.2.0-rc1+dev30

  nasa/sample_lib#54, Replace <> with " for local includes
  nasa/sample_lib#53, Adds CONTRIBUTING.md that links to the main cFS contributing guide.

nasa/cFS-GroundSystem#171 v2.2.0-rc1+dev41

  nasa/cFS-GroundSystem#166, Updated TBL and SB tlm for an operational TLM display
  nasa/cFS-GroundSystem#170, Add Contributing Guide
  nasa/cFS-GroundSystem#137, Create package for cfs-groundsystem
astrogeco added a commit to nasa/cFS that referenced this pull request Mar 22, 2021
nasa/cFE#1243 v6.8.0-rc1+dev436

  nasa/cFE#1225, Add coverage test fix
  nasa/cFE#1218, bit order macros
  nasa/cFE#1193, Removes incorrect statements from Application Developers Guide
  nasa/cFE#1235, Fixes truncation handling on vsnprintf error by adding a cast to avoid implicit conversion
  nasa/cFE#1220, Clarify the documentation on SB MsgId regarding requirements for command and telemetry messages
  nasa/cFE#1230, Cast isspace input to unsigned char to avoid undefined behavior
  nasa/cFE#1231, Updated message module, msgid v1 to use mask instead of cast to alter value
  nasa/cFE#1232, Coercion alters value caused by incorrect type - static analysis warning
  nasa/cFE#1228, Replaces `<>` with `"` in local `#include`s
  nasa/cFE#1227, Adds `CONTRIBUING.md` that links to the main cFS contributing guide.

nasa/PSP#273 v1.5.0-rc1+dev90

  nasa/PSP#264, modular psp implementation
  nasa/PSP#272, Use quotes for local includes
  nasa/PSP#271, Add Contributing Guide

nasa/osal#917 v5.1.0-rc1+dev347

  nasa/osal#890, Move copyblock size to a #define and add comments
  nasa/osal#891, Removed rogue while loop
  nasa/osal#892, Scripted replacement for #include <os and #include <OSC_ matches of < and > with "
  nasa/osal#893, Consolidates the duplicated switch in OS_SocketOpen_Impl
  nasa/osal#894, Add `const` to input pointers
  nasa/osal#895, Removed network prototypes defined in osapi_sockets.h that are also in osapi_network.h
  nasa/osal#896, Removes NULL redefine from common_types.h
  nasa/osal#912, Add Contributing Guide
  nasa/osal#914, Utilize UTASSERT_CASETYPE_NA to report OS_ERR_NOT_IMPLEMENTED
  nasa/osal#898, correct interval calculation in DoSelect
  nasa/osal#909, comments describing select after connect
  nasa/osal#902, add check for EAGAIN in addition to EINTR
  nasa/osal#908, compile time assert for sockaddr size
  nasa/osal#910, check/report fcntl status
  nasa/osal#897, Add assert for FD_SET_SIZE in relation to OSAL_set
  nasa/osal#903, better error translation for ESPIPE errno
  nasa/osal#840, add shell functional test
  nasa/osal#901, rename OS_U32ValueWrapper_t
  nasa/osal#900, break up logic in return statement
  nasa/osal#906, return moduleInfoGet error
  nasa/osal#907, report timer_gettime error
  nasa/osal#899, remove unreachable test
  nasa/osal#905, make module comment same as other services
  nasa/osal#920 to fix test error check index inside fdset conversions
  nasa/osal#922, make non-selectable FD an error

nasa/sample_app#137 v1.2.0-rc1+dev54

  nasa/sample_app#134, Convert from <> to " for local includes
  nasa/sample_app#136, Added a contributing guide that links to the main cFS contributing guide.
  nasa/sample_app#132, Add context to the values for MsgIDs

nasa/sample_lib#55 v1.2.0-rc1+dev30

  nasa/sample_lib#54, Replace <> with " for local includes
  nasa/sample_lib#53, Adds CONTRIBUTING.md that links to the main cFS contributing guide.

nasa/cFS-GroundSystem#171 v2.2.0-rc1+dev41

  nasa/cFS-GroundSystem#166, Updated TBL and SB tlm for an operational TLM display
  nasa/cFS-GroundSystem#170, Add Contributing Guide
  nasa/cFS-GroundSystem#137, Create package for cfs-groundsystem
@jphickey jphickey deleted the fix-921-non-selectable-fd branch April 29, 2021 13:21
@skliper skliper added this to the 6.0.0 milestone Sep 24, 2021
jphickey pushed a commit to jphickey/osal that referenced this pull request Aug 10, 2022
jphickey pushed a commit to jphickey/osal that referenced this pull request Aug 10, 2022
Fix nasa#922, Update cfe_error.h to use the CFE_Status_t type
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

RTEMS silently discards non-selectable file handles in OS_SelectMultiple()
3 participants