Automatic building tag is not obvious

[ghost]

Like in #4639, but now (also) for marketplace.

This should not have been a building.

[bhousel]

I think it was obvious in #4639, and I think it's still obvious here.

[ghost]

Sorry to nag, but apparently it's not so obvious for the user who made the mistake. This could still be improved, although I hate to admit that I don't know how either.

[ghost]

FWIW I think marketplaces are an example of where it should definitely default to no building. Those are very often in open air.

[althio]

@M1dgard

FWIW I think marketplaces are an example of where it should definitely default to no building. Those are very often in open air.

I agree.
Tag:amenity=marketplace reads

• for both of them (indoor and outdoor)
• as an area along the outline of the marketplace
• [add] building=yes - if it is a market hall

[althio]

this is related to issue #4559 PR #4568

@M1dgard do you think it can be closed?

[bhousel]

this is related to issue #4559 PR #4568
@M1dgard do you think it can be closed?

Yes, sorry, this was already done and is closed (thank you for linking to the PR - I should have done that originally!)