-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1.2k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
StreetSide Integration #5050
StreetSide Integration #5050
Conversation
You can't use StreetSide for remote mapping without some other source, a difference from imagery, Mapillary, and OpenStreetCam. How can we make that difference clear to users so they don't break the StreetSide license? |
@pnorman We will clarify these terms for you shortly. |
Awesome @jharpster - this is a really great start, and this will be huge for OSM. Thank you! A few things I'm going to work on, to try to make this even better:
|
All the boxes are ticked! Going to test a bunch and merge this today 👍 |
This is exciting! Is there a public posting somewhere about how to use this when mapping? I'm still unsure about how to use it only as corroborating information, as per the terms of use. |
Question 1: Microsoft’s Answer: |
Question 2: Microsoft’s Answer: |
Question 3:
|
@jharpster These examples are very good and helpful. Can I just test a few of other scenarios which I have been contemplating? (Streetview coverage in UK is limited but covers my mother's home town, which I know well, but don't visit very frequently):
In the UK we have a number of good open sources of data which are only geolocated down to the postcode level: notably Food Hygiene data and Companies House (company registrations). Food Hygiene is particularly good because it is updated regularly. The key feature of both datasets is that they provide high-quality address data, and for shops, restaurants & cafes are also visible POIs. So from this data it is possible to identify that a cafe with housenumber 123 is present (typically perhaps with an accuracy of 50 m). If the same cafe is visible on Streetside it then becomes possible to place it more accurately (at the individual building level). In practice I would probably only want to map the address as the POI may have closed/changed both since Streetside imagery and the last snapshot in other open data sources. Example location: https://binged.it/2t06swf (address is 228 Rake Lane on Food Hygiene: http://ratings.food.gov.uk/business/en-GB/394560/Gills-the-Family-Store-Wirral)
3a. Related directly to the above location. Streetside would be a good source for dropped kcerbs & tactile paving which is often difficult to identify from aerial imagery or other sources. Such usage would clearly be beyond confirmatory.
Sorry for being rather long-winded, but I hope these examples are concrete enough to enable clear guidance. |
|
That is exactly what Mapbox did recently. Does that mean that it is invalid use only when Microsoft hasn't been contacted beforehand? |
@Zverik I assume from this quote that they did "We generated these turn restriction detections by applying our machine learning computer vision models to Microsoft Streetside Imagery, from which Mapbox has acquired the right to contribute these detections to OpenStreetMap." (my emphasis) |
Presumably if they used another source of information like aerial imagery to identify buildings they would then be okay, as Streetside is no longer a sole source of ground truth? |
@jharpster Could you please comment on the common potential use cases mentioned by SK53? :) |
@xuiqzy The use cases mentioned by SK53 are fine. If you can reliably see it in the imagery, you can add it to the map. |
Integrates the Microsoft StreetSide imagery in to the iD editor.
You're welcome.
-Microsoft