feat(ip-address): [ip-address] Adapting to the SMB theme #2166
Conversation
WalkthroughThe changes involve updates to the visual styling and structure of the IP address input components across multiple files. Key modifications include adjustments to CSS properties for disabled states, reordering of component instances, removal of unused functions and computed properties, and the introduction of new class-based height specifications. These updates enhance the adaptability and maintainability of the input components without altering their core functionality. Changes
Possibly related PRs
Suggested labels
Suggested reviewers
Poem
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 2
Outside diff range and nitpick comments (7)
examples/sites/demos/pc/app/ip-address/size.vue (2)
1-7: LGTM! Consider adding comments for clarity.The reordering of the
tiny-ip-addresscomponents improves the logical flow of size demonstration, which aligns well with the PR objective of adapting to the SMB theme. This change enhances the visual representation of different component sizes.Consider adding comments to clearly indicate the size of each component, especially for the default size. This would improve readability and maintainability. Here's a suggested change:
<template> <div> + <!-- Medium size --> <tiny-ip-address size="medium" v-model="value"></tiny-ip-address> + <!-- Default size --> <tiny-ip-address v-model="value"></tiny-ip-address> + <!-- Small size --> <tiny-ip-address size="small" v-model="value"></tiny-ip-address> + <!-- Mini size --> <tiny-ip-address size="mini" v-model="value"></tiny-ip-address> </div> </template>
Line range hint
1-29: Overall, the changes improve the demo's clarity and align with PR objectives.The reordering of the
tiny-ip-addresscomponents in the template enhances the logical flow of size demonstration, which supports the PR's goal of adapting to the SMB theme. The script and style sections, though unchanged, complement the template well to create an effective demo of the ip-address component sizes.Consider adding a brief comment at the top of the file explaining the purpose of this demo, which could help other developers understand the file's role in the larger project context more quickly.
examples/sites/demos/pc/app/ip-address/disabled.spec.ts (1)
16-18: LGTM! Consider adding a comment explaining the color changes.The updated CSS values for the disabled state of the IP address component look good and align with the PR objective of adapting to the SMB theme. The new colors appear more muted, which is appropriate for a disabled state.
Consider adding a brief comment explaining the reason for these specific color changes, e.g.:
// SMB theme colors for disabled state await expect(ipAddress).toHaveCSS('background-color', 'rgb(240, 240, 240)') await expect(ipAddress).toHaveCSS('border-bottom-color', 'rgb(219, 219, 219)') await expect(ipAddress).toHaveCSS('color', 'rgb(194, 194, 194)')This would help future developers understand the context of these specific color values.
packages/vue/src/ip-address/src/pc.vue (1)
Line range hint
22-38: Enhance accessibility for IP address inputThe component structure for handling IP address input is well-implemented. However, we can further improve its accessibility:
- Add an
aria-labelto the<ul>element to describe its purpose, e.g., "IP Address Input".- For each
<input>element, add anaria-labelthat describes which octet or segment of the IP address it represents.- Consider adding
inputmode="numeric"to the<input>elements to bring up a numeric keyboard on mobile devices.Here's a suggested implementation:
- <ul + <ul + aria-label="IP Address Input" :class="[ state.active ? 'active' : '', state.disabled ? 'disabled' : '', 'tiny-ip-address__input', state.size ? `${state.size}` : 'default' ]" > <li v-for="(item, index) of state.address" :key="index"> <input ref="inputs" :readonly="readonly" :disabled="state.disabled" + :aria-label="`IP address segment ${index + 1}`" + inputmode="numeric" v-model="item.value" type="text" @select="select({ value: item, index, event: $event })" @focus="focus({ index, event: $event })" @input="inputEvent({ item, index })" @change="change" @blur="blur({ item, index })" @keyup="keyup({ item, index, event: $event })" @keydown="keydown({ item, index, event: $event })" tabindex="1" /> <!-- ... rest of the code ... --> </li> </ul>These changes will improve the user experience for those using screen readers and make the component more accessible overall.
packages/theme-saas/src/ip-address/index.less (1)
123-129: Approve use of Tailwind classes, consider necessity of "default" classThe use of Tailwind classes for the
.defaultclass is consistent with the overall styling approach. Good job on maintaining consistency here.Consider if the "default" class is necessary. If these styles are meant to be the default for all sizes, they could potentially be moved to the base class. If it's meant to be an explicit size option, consider renaming it to something more descriptive like "normal" or "base" to avoid confusion with default behavior.
packages/renderless/src/ip-address/vue.ts (1)
Line range hint
1-180: Summary of changes and next stepsThe changes in this file simplify the size handling logic of the IP address component, which aligns with the PR objective of adapting to the SMB theme. The removal of specific height-related computed properties in favor of a single
sizeproperty streamlines the code but may have implications for the component's appearance and layout.Next steps:
- Verify that the component renders correctly with different size prop values.
- Ensure that the removal of specific height styles doesn't negatively impact the component's layout.
- Update any documentation related to the component's sizing behavior.
- Consider adding comments in the code to explain the rationale behind these changes for future maintainers.
These changes represent a shift in how the component handles sizing. It would be beneficial to document this architectural decision, perhaps in an ADR (Architecture Decision Record), to explain the reasoning behind moving away from specific height calculations to a more straightforward size prop usage.
packages/theme/src/ip-address/index.less (1)
143-161: Excellent addition of size-specific classes for flexible styling!The introduction of size-specific classes (medium, default, small, mini) for the IP address input elements is a great improvement. This change allows for more flexible styling based on the input field size, which aligns well with the SMB theme adaptation mentioned in the PR objectives. The use of CSS variables for heights and line-heights promotes consistency and easier theme customization.
For better consistency in variable naming, consider updating the variable names to follow the same pattern:
- --ti--ip--address-medium-height + --ti-ip-address-medium-heightApply this change to all new variables introduced in this segment.
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (10)
- examples/sites/demos/pc/app/ip-address/disabled.spec.ts (1 hunks)
- examples/sites/demos/pc/app/ip-address/size-composition-api.vue (1 hunks)
- examples/sites/demos/pc/app/ip-address/size.spec.ts (1 hunks)
- examples/sites/demos/pc/app/ip-address/size.vue (1 hunks)
- packages/renderless/src/ip-address/index.ts (0 hunks)
- packages/renderless/src/ip-address/vue.ts (2 hunks)
- packages/theme-saas/src/ip-address/index.less (1 hunks)
- packages/theme/src/ip-address/index.less (1 hunks)
- packages/theme/src/ip-address/vars.less (1 hunks)
- packages/vue/src/ip-address/src/pc.vue (1 hunks)
Files not reviewed due to no reviewable changes (1)
- packages/renderless/src/ip-address/index.ts
Additional comments not posted (13)
examples/sites/demos/pc/app/ip-address/size-composition-api.vue (1)
Line range hint
9-24: Acknowledging good practices in unchanged sectionsWhile the script and style sections remain unchanged, it's worth noting that they follow Vue 3 best practices:
- The script section uses the Composition API with
<script setup>, which is the recommended approach for Vue 3 components.- The style section uses scoped styles, ensuring that the CSS rules only apply to this component.
- The use of
reffor reactive state management is appropriate for this simple example.These practices contribute to a well-structured and maintainable component.
examples/sites/demos/pc/app/ip-address/size.spec.ts (2)
Line range hint
1-14: LGTM: Well-structured test caseThe overall structure of this test case is well-designed. It effectively uses Playwright for end-to-end testing, properly handles asynchronous operations, and follows good practices for element selection and assertion.
11-11: Approved: Height adjustment for SMB theme adaptationThe change from 36px to 32px for the second input element's height appears to be intentional and maintains the descending order of heights across the different sizes. This adjustment likely contributes to the adaptation for the SMB theme mentioned in the PR objectives.
To ensure this change is consistent with the component's implementation, please run the following script:
Could you provide more context on the rationale behind this specific height adjustment? This information would be valuable for maintaining consistency across the codebase and documentation.
examples/sites/demos/pc/app/ip-address/size.vue (2)
Line range hint
9-22: Script section looks good!The script section correctly imports and sets up the IpAddress component. The initial state is properly defined. No changes or improvements are needed in this part of the code.
Line range hint
24-29: Style section is appropriate for the demo.The scoped CSS correctly styles the ip-address components for clear visual separation in the demo. This presentation aligns well with the purpose of showcasing different component sizes.
packages/vue/src/ip-address/src/pc.vue (2)
Line range hint
1-67: Summary of IP Address component changesThe changes made to the IP Address component align well with the PR objective of adapting to the SMB theme:
- The class binding modifications provide more flexibility in styling, allowing easier adaptation to different visual themes.
- The addition of a size-based class enhances the component's adaptability to various contexts.
However, there are a few points to consider:
- The removal of inline styles needs to be verified to ensure it doesn't negatively impact the component's appearance.
- There's an opportunity to improve the component's accessibility, as suggested in the previous comment.
Overall, the changes seem to be a step in the right direction for making the component more flexible and adaptable to different themes and sizes, which is crucial for SMB applications. Just ensure that the styling remains consistent and that accessibility is not overlooked in the process of these adaptations.
15-20: Improved class binding and potential style issuesThe changes to the class binding improve the component's flexibility and adaptability:
- The new array syntax for class binding is more readable and maintainable.
- The addition of a size-based class (
state.size ?${state.size}: 'default') enhances the component's adaptability to different contexts, which aligns with the SMB theme adaptation goal.However, there are some concerns:
The removal of the
:stylebinding from both the<ul>and<input>elements (not visible in the provided diff) might affect the component's appearance and layout. Ensure that these styles are now properly handled through CSS classes or that their removal doesn't negatively impact the component's visual presentation.To verify the impact of these changes, please run the following script:
This script will help identify if the removed styles are properly handled elsewhere in the codebase.
Verification successful
Style bindings properly handled after removal
The removal of the
:stylebindings from both the<ul>and<input>elements does not negatively impact the component's appearance and layout:
- No relevant CSS classes were found that rely on these inline styles.
- No remaining inline styles are present in
packages/vue/src/ip-address/src/pc.vue.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for any CSS files or style blocks that might be affected by the removal of inline styles # Search for CSS files that might contain styles for tiny-ip-address echo "Searching for relevant CSS files:" fd -e css | xargs rg 'tiny-ip-address' # Search for style blocks in Vue files that might contain styles for tiny-ip-address echo "Searching for style blocks in Vue files:" fd -e vue | xargs rg -A 10 '<style' | rg 'tiny-ip-address' -C 5 # Search for any remaining inline styles in the component echo "Checking for any remaining inline styles:" rg ':style' packages/vue/src/ip-address/src/pc.vueLength of output: 1767
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Re-verify the removal of inline styles with corrected commands # Search for CSS files that might contain styles for tiny-ip-address echo "Searching for relevant CSS files:" fd -e css | xargs rg 'tiny-ip-address' || echo "No matches found in CSS files." # Search for style blocks in Vue files that might contain styles for tiny-ip-address echo "Searching for style blocks in Vue files:" fd -e vue | xargs rg -A 10 '<style' | rg 'tiny-ip-address' -C 5 || echo "No style blocks found with tiny-ip-address." # Search for any remaining inline styles in the component echo "Checking for any remaining inline styles:" rg ':style' packages/vue/src/ip-address/src/pc.vue || echo "No remaining inline styles found in pc.vue."Length of output: 756
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Re-verify the removal of inline styles with simplified and corrected commands # Search for CSS files that might contain styles for tiny-ip-address echo "Searching for relevant CSS files:" fd -e css -x rg 'tiny-ip-address' || echo "No matches found in CSS files." # Search for style blocks in Vue files that might contain styles for tiny-ip-address echo "Searching for style blocks in Vue files:" fd -e vue -x rg '<style' | rg 'tiny-ip-address' -C 5 || echo "No style blocks found with tiny-ip-address." # Search for any remaining inline styles in the component echo "Checking for any remaining inline styles in pc.vue:" rg ':style' packages/vue/src/ip-address/src/pc.vue || echo "No remaining inline styles found in pc.vue."Length of output: 683
packages/theme/src/ip-address/vars.less (1)
50-58: New variables added for different IP address input field sizesThe addition of these new variables provides more granular control over the dimensions of IP address input fields for different sizes (medium, default, small, and mini). This is a good improvement for flexibility and consistency across different form factor designs.
However, there are a few points to consider:
Naming convention: The new variables use double hyphens (--) after "ti", which is inconsistent with the existing variables in this file. Consider aligning the naming convention for consistency.
Calculations: The calculations for height and line-height seem reasonable, but it's worth verifying if subtracting 2px or 4px from the base heights is intentional and provides the desired visual outcome.
Medium size: The medium size doesn't have any pixel adjustments. Verify if this is intentional or if it should also have a small adjustment for consistency.
Consider updating the variable names for consistency:
- --ti--ip--address-medium-height: calc(var(--ti-common-size-height-medium)); - --ti--ip--address-medium-line-height: calc(var(--ti-common-line-height-5) + 2px); - --ti--ip--address-default-height: calc(var(--ti-common-size-height-normal) - 2px); - --ti--ip--address-default-line-height: var(--ti-common-line-height-4); - --ti--ip--address-small-height: calc(var(--ti-common-size-height-minor) - 4px); - --ti--ip--address-small-line-height: calc(var(--ti-common-line-height-3) - 2px); - --ti--ip--address-mini-height: calc(var(--ti-common-size-height-mini) - 2px); - --ti--ip--address-mini-line-height: calc(var(--ti-common-line-height-2) - 2px); + --ti-ip-address-medium-height: var(--ti-common-size-height-medium); + --ti-ip-address-medium-line-height: calc(var(--ti-common-line-height-5) + 2px); + --ti-ip-address-default-height: calc(var(--ti-common-size-height-normal) - 2px); + --ti-ip-address-default-line-height: var(--ti-common-line-height-4); + --ti-ip-address-small-height: calc(var(--ti-common-size-height-minor) - 4px); + --ti-ip-address-small-line-height: calc(var(--ti-common-line-height-3) - 2px); + --ti-ip-address-mini-height: calc(var(--ti-common-size-height-mini) - 2px); + --ti-ip-address-mini-line-height: calc(var(--ti-common-line-height-2) - 2px);To ensure these changes don't introduce inconsistencies, please run the following script to check for any other occurrences of the double-hyphen naming convention in LESS files:
packages/theme-saas/src/ip-address/index.less (3)
132-138: Approve addition of .small classThe
.smallclass is well-implemented using Tailwind classes, maintaining consistency with the overall styling approach. This addition provides good flexibility for different size requirements.
140-146: Approve .mini class, but consider readabilityThe
.miniclass is well-implemented using Tailwind classes, consistent with the overall styling approach. This addition provides even more flexibility for different size requirements.However, the very small size (h-6) might cause readability issues for the IP address input. Please verify that the text remains legible at this size across different browsers and devices. Consider setting a minimum font size to ensure readability.
To assist in verifying the readability, you could add a comment in the code to remind developers to check this, like so:
&.mini { @apply h-6; li input { @apply h-6; @apply leading-6; + // TODO: Verify readability of IP address at this size across different browsers and devices } }
115-146: Overall improvement in size flexibility, with minor consistency and usability considerationsThe addition of multiple size classes (medium, default, small, and mini) significantly improves the flexibility and adaptability of the IP address input component. This change allows for better integration into various design contexts, which aligns well with the PR objective of adapting to the SMB theme.
However, there are a few points to consider:
- Consistency: The
mediumclass uses fixed pixel values, while others use Tailwind classes. Consider standardizing this for better maintainability.- Usability: The
minisize might be too small for comfortable input of IP addresses. Ensure it remains usable across different devices and user scenarios.- Naming: The
defaultclass might be redundant or confusing. Consider if it's necessary or if it could be renamed for clarity.These changes overall represent a positive enhancement to the component's versatility, with room for minor refinements in consistency and usability.
To ensure these size changes work well across different scenarios, consider adding a visual regression test suite if not already in place. This would help catch any unintended consequences of these size adjustments in different contexts.
packages/renderless/src/ip-address/vue.ts (2)
68-68: Verify component appearance after size handling changes.The removal of
heightStyle,lineHeightStyle, andallHeightStylecomputed properties in favor of a singlesizecomputed property simplifies the sizing logic. However, this change might affect the component's appearance and layout.Please ensure that:
- The component still renders correctly with different size prop values.
- The removal of specific height styles doesn't negatively impact the component's layout.
To verify the usage of the new
sizeproperty, run the following script:#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify size property usage in ip-address component # Test: Search for size usage in the component rg --type typescript 'size' packages/renderless/src/ip-address/vue.ts # Test: Check if size is used in the template file rg --type vue 'size' packages/vue/src/ip-address/src/index.vueConsider adding comments explaining the rationale behind this simplification for future maintainers.
26-27: LGTM! Verify keydown functionality.The changes in the import statement are consistent with the modifications in the component. The removal of
getHeightOfSizealigns with the removal of height-related computed properties. The addition ofkeydownimport suggests new or modified keydown event handling.To ensure the keydown functionality is correctly implemented, please run the following script:
PR
PR Checklist
Please check if your PR fulfills the following requirements:
PR Type
What kind of change does this PR introduce?
What is the current behavior?
Issue Number: N/A
What is the new behavior?
Does this PR introduce a breaking change?
Other information
Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
Bug Fixes
Refactor
Chores