[Dialog] scrolling UX is bad because dialog is not scrolling when hovered overlay #1313
Comments
|
@liesislukas huh interesting, dialogs on the docs site do not exhibit this behavior, and i can't figure out from inspecting your CSS why your page would scroll. any suggestions? |
|
@giladgray In fact on docs site dialog sometimes works one way, sometimes another. Here's a short video: you can check my dialog here: https://www.geekystats.com/company/1/seoRank/monitor?viewMore=1&viewMoreTab=keyword Use login: demo@gmail.com and psw: demo@gmail.com p.s. if you find geekystats.com interesting just register with your email and i will send you notification when it's ready 👍 |
|
@liesislukas we've narrowed this issue down to something entirely out of our control: retina/HiDPI screens seem to support scrolling from the backdrop, but normal monitors do not. this can be repro'ed readily by plugging an external monitor into a Retina MBP and dragging a chrome window back and forth between monitors. #1373 attempts to fix some of the scrolling woes in CSS but there seems to be little we can do about this particular issue. |
|
@liesislukas actually ignore my comment above, #1373 totally fixes this now! |
…r scrolling requires re-implementing canOutsideClickClose but it's just dead simple fixes #1313
#1373) * Experimental support for both absolute and flex positioning * Tweak positioning for scroll vs static * fix ContextMenu close events by using rAF to delay hide() only revert changes to Overlay, fix test, use rAF for popover focus logic * ⭐ rewrite Overlay CSS positioning logic for maximum effect! * update other component styles for latest Overlay mostly reducing duplication! * Disable text selection on backdrop * Even out toast margin / toast container padding * restore support for old container-less Dialog position * revert padding/margin changes for legacy compat * replace pointer-events with user-select on dialog to support container scrolling requires re-implementing canOutsideClickClose but it's just dead simple fixes #1313 * add .pt-dialog-container to markup example, remove custom docs section style * fix isClickOutsideDialog logic
|
just updated to 1.26.0, I confirm that update fixes this issue on my app. Thank you :) 👍 |
Hi, i'm making usability testing and already see a lot feedback about bad UX with dialogs because when user is trying to scroll dialog scrolling does work only when mouse cursors is over the dialog contents if mouse is over the overlay scroll scrolls background page but not dialog, which is primary active content at that moment.
At least there should be a property if you really want to let user scroll background page when dialog is active.
Bug report
Steps to reproduce
DialogActual behavior
scroll is working not like users expect it to work. Bad ux.
Expected behavior
Dialog is scrolling always no matter where the mouse is, while dialog is primary active content.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: