-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1.6k
Check candidate signatures before including them in set_heads
#1335
Check candidate signatures before including them in set_heads
#1335
Conversation
This work around the bug described in: #1327 We check the candidate signatures in `create_inherent` to ensure that all are valid. If one isn't valid, we don't include any candidate for the current inherent.
…tes-before-including-them
Some(Call::set_heads(data)) | ||
// Temporary solution for: | ||
// https://github.com/paritytech/polkadot/issues/1327 | ||
if Self::check_candidates_signatures(&data).is_ok() { |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Could this not just do Module::<T>::set_heads(Origin::none(), ...).is_ok()
without the other changes?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Yes this would work as well. But set heads is doing much more and we don't really need this here IMHO. This just wastes resources.
will need a bump to each runtime |
Done |
Why is the inherent even valid in this case? Shouldn't an invalid inherent result in an invalid block? |
Yes and that is done, but this means we always run into the same problem that is described here: #1327 TLDR the new block changes the authority set, we check based on the authority set the signatures of the PoVBlock's. As the authorities (may) changed, the signature check will fail and this brings us in a loop where this always happens and brings down the network. |
ff5d539fcb Update Substrate/Polkadot/Cumulus references (#1353) 1581f60cd5 Support dedicated lanes for pallets (#962) 0a7ccf5c57 ignore more "increase" alerts that are sometimes signalling NoData at startup (#1351) 31165127cc added no_stack_overflow_when_decoding_nested_call_during_dispatch test (#1349) 7000619eb8 replace From<>InboundLaneApi with direct storage reads (#1348) 515df10ccc added alerts for relay balances (#1347) b56f6a87de Mortal conversion rate updater transactions (#1257) 20f2f331ec edition = "2021" (#1346) 99147d4f75 update regex to 1.5.5 (#1345) 686191f379 use DecodeLimit when decoding incoming calls (#1344) a70c276006 get rid of '[No Data] Messages from Millau to Rialto are not being delivered' warnings (#1342) 01f29b8ac1 fix conversion rate metric in dashboards (#1341) 51c3bf351f Increase rate from metric when estimating fee (#1340) 3bb9c4f68f fix generator scripts to be consistent with updatedrelay output (#1339) 0475a1667b fixed mess with conversion rates (#1338) d8fdd7d716 synchronize relay cli changes and token swap generator script (#1337) 6e928137a5 fix conversion rate override in token swap (#1336) 62d4a4811d override conversion rate in tokens swap generator (#1335) ed9e1c839c fi typo in generator script (#1334) 3254b5af7a Override conversion rate when computing message fee (#1261) 66df68b5b8 Revert "Revert "override conversion rate in estimate-message-fee RPC (#1189)" (#1275)" (#1333) 0ca6fc6ef8 fix clippy issues (#1332) 5414b2fffb Reinitialize bridge relay subcommand (#1331) a63d95ba7d removed extra *_RUNTIME_VERSION consts from relay code (#1330) 59fb18a310 fix typo in alert expression (#1329) a6267a47ee Using-same-fork metric for finality and complex relay (#1327) 88d684d37e use mortal transactions in transaction resubmitter (#1326) 8ff88b6844 impl Decode for SignedExtensions (otherwise transaction resubmitter panicks) (#1325) 1ed09854f0 Encode and estimate Rococo/Wococo/Kusama/Polkadot messages (#1322) ddb4517e13 Add some tests to check integrity of chain constants + bridge configuration (#1316) bdeedb7ab9 Fix issues from cargo deny (#1311) d3d79d01e0 expose fee multiplier metrics in messages relay (#1312) c8b3f0ea16 Endow relayer account at target chain in message benchmarks (#1310) f51ecd92b6 fix benchmarks before using it in Polkadot/Kusama/Rococo runtimes (#1309) 6935c619ad increase relay balance guard limits for Polkadot<>Kusama bridge (#1308) 7e31834c66 Fix mandatory headers scanning in on-demand relay (#1306) 3787193a31 fix session length of Rococo and Wococo (#1304) eb468d29c0 Revert nightly docker pin (#1301) e2d4c073e1 Use raw balance value if tokenDecimals property is missing (#1299) 108f4b29d1 Fix ss58 prefixes of Polkadot, Kusama and Westend used by relay (#1298) 64fbd2705e bump chain spec versions (#1297) 5707777b86 Bump Substrate/Polkadot/Cumulus refs (#1295) 1f0c05368e Relay balance metrics (#1291) 6356bb90b3 when messages pallet is halted, relay shall not submit messages delivery/confirmation transactions (#1289) 800dc2df8d when GRANDPA pallet is halted, relay shall not submit finality transactions (#1288) 3dd8e4f936 disable BEEFY allerts for Rialto (#1285) f58fed7380 support version mode cli options in send-message subcommand (#1284) 3aac448da3 reuse polkadot-service code (#1273) 2bdbb651e1 replace latest_confirmed_nonce runtime APIs with direct storage reads (#1282) 5f9c6d241f move "common" code of messages pallet benchmarks helpers to the common library (#1281) 8b9c4ec16d do not start spec_version guard when version mode is set to auto (#1278) e98d682de2 removed extra messages benchmarks (#1279) c730e25b61 Move benchmarks from Rialto to Millau (#1277) ed7def64c4 Revert "override conversion rate in estimate-message-fee RPC (#1189)" (#1275) 38c6c3a49f Use "production" floating tag when uilding docker image from version git tags (#1272) ded9ff6dbb Replace InboundLaneApi::latest_received_nonce with direct storage read (#1269) 8c65f0d7ab verify that GRANDPA pallet is not initialized before submitting initialization transaction (#1267) e7e83d8944 remove OutboundLaneApi::latest_received_nonce (#1262) 9f4b34acf1 bump rococo version (#1263) 82c08c5a87 read latest_generated_nonce directly from storage (#1260) 50ffb5dd08 override conversion rate in estimate-message-fee RPC (#1189) 467ca5ef59 move storage keys computation to primitivs (#1254) 4f9884066b remporary use pinned bridges-ci image in Dockerfile (#1258) edfcb74e00 Change submit transaction spec_version and transaction_version query from chain (#1248) 4009d970d0 pin bridges-ci image (#1256) 65e51b5e1c decrease startup sleep to 5s for relays and to 120s for generators + remove curl (#1251) 3bc74355d9 Add missing RPC APIs to rialto parachain node (#1250) 80c9429284 Bump relay version to 1.0.0 (#1249) 9ead06af2a runtimes: fix call_size() test (#1245) 4fc8a29357 Use same endowed accounts set on dev/local chains (#1244) fed54371c2 Refactor message relay helpers (#1234) a15b4faae7 post-merge build fix (#1243) 52232d8d54 Fix transactions mortality (#1196) c07bba931f Expose prometheus BEEFY metrics and add them to grafana dashboard (#1242) f927775bd5 Refactor finality relay helpers (#1220) 7bf76f14a8 Update Rococo/Wococo version + prepare relay for Rococo<>Wococo bridge (#1241) e860fecd04 Enable offchain indexing for Rialto/Millau nodes (#1239) 04d4d1c6b4 Enable Beefy debug logs in test deployment (#1237) cd771f1089 Fix storage parameter name computation (#1238) 816ddd2dd2 Integrate BEEFY with Rialto & Millau runtimes (#1227) d94b62b1ac update dependencies (#1229) 98eb9ee13d Add mut support (#1232) ffef6f89f9 fixed set_operational in GRANDPA pallet (#1226) bd2f8bfbd7 Add CODEOWNERS file (#1219) 6b5cf2b591 Unify metric names (#1209) d1541e797e remove abandoned exchange relay (#1217) 39140d0b34 Remove unused `relays/headers` (#1216) 9bc071d42b Remove unused PoA<>Substrate bridge (#1210) 877e8d01e3 Fix UI deployment. (#1211) 6cd5775ebe Add `AtLeast32BitUnsigned` for MessageLance::SourceChainBalance (#1207) REVERT: 1602249f0a Enable Beefy debug logs in test deployment (#1237) REVERT: c61d240b47 Fix storage parameter name computation (#1238) REVERT: 96d3808e88 Integrate BEEFY with Rialto & Millau runtimes (#1227) REVERT: f75a1bdd9b update dependencies (#1229) REVERT: 957da03854 Add mut support (#1232) REVERT: 8062637289 fixed set_operational in GRANDPA pallet (#1226) REVERT: 14b36ca4ee Add CODEOWNERS file (#1219) REVERT: 3bec15766f Unify metric names (#1209) REVERT: 0e839d2423 remove abandoned exchange relay (#1217) REVERT: 2c91c6815c Remove unused `relays/headers` (#1216) REVERT: 80b1e65db8 Remove unused PoA<>Substrate bridge (#1210) REVERT: f36f76fc2a Fix UI deployment. (#1211) REVERT: fc0b65365b Add `AtLeast32BitUnsigned` for MessageLance::SourceChainBalance (#1207) git-subtree-dir: bridges git-subtree-split: ff5d539fcbcd0e68dcd4fd921935ff9de87d7d94
f220d2fcca Polkadot staging update (#1356) 02fd3d497c fix parse_transaction on Rialto+Millau (#1360) bc191fd9a2 update parity-scale-codec to 3.1.2 (#1359) a37226e79c update chain versions (#1358) ff5d539fcb Update Substrate/Polkadot/Cumulus references (#1353) 1581f60cd5 Support dedicated lanes for pallets (#962) 0a7ccf5c57 ignore more "increase" alerts that are sometimes signalling NoData at startup (#1351) 31165127cc added no_stack_overflow_when_decoding_nested_call_during_dispatch test (#1349) 7000619eb8 replace From<>InboundLaneApi with direct storage reads (#1348) 515df10ccc added alerts for relay balances (#1347) b56f6a87de Mortal conversion rate updater transactions (#1257) 20f2f331ec edition = "2021" (#1346) 99147d4f75 update regex to 1.5.5 (#1345) 686191f379 use DecodeLimit when decoding incoming calls (#1344) a70c276006 get rid of '[No Data] Messages from Millau to Rialto are not being delivered' warnings (#1342) 01f29b8ac1 fix conversion rate metric in dashboards (#1341) 51c3bf351f Increase rate from metric when estimating fee (#1340) 3bb9c4f68f fix generator scripts to be consistent with updatedrelay output (#1339) 0475a1667b fixed mess with conversion rates (#1338) d8fdd7d716 synchronize relay cli changes and token swap generator script (#1337) 6e928137a5 fix conversion rate override in token swap (#1336) 62d4a4811d override conversion rate in tokens swap generator (#1335) ed9e1c839c fi typo in generator script (#1334) 3254b5af7a Override conversion rate when computing message fee (#1261) 66df68b5b8 Revert "Revert "override conversion rate in estimate-message-fee RPC (#1189)" (#1275)" (#1333) 0ca6fc6ef8 fix clippy issues (#1332) 5414b2fffb Reinitialize bridge relay subcommand (#1331) a63d95ba7d removed extra *_RUNTIME_VERSION consts from relay code (#1330) 59fb18a310 fix typo in alert expression (#1329) a6267a47ee Using-same-fork metric for finality and complex relay (#1327) 88d684d37e use mortal transactions in transaction resubmitter (#1326) 8ff88b6844 impl Decode for SignedExtensions (otherwise transaction resubmitter panicks) (#1325) 1ed09854f0 Encode and estimate Rococo/Wococo/Kusama/Polkadot messages (#1322) ddb4517e13 Add some tests to check integrity of chain constants + bridge configuration (#1316) bdeedb7ab9 Fix issues from cargo deny (#1311) d3d79d01e0 expose fee multiplier metrics in messages relay (#1312) c8b3f0ea16 Endow relayer account at target chain in message benchmarks (#1310) f51ecd92b6 fix benchmarks before using it in Polkadot/Kusama/Rococo runtimes (#1309) 6935c619ad increase relay balance guard limits for Polkadot<>Kusama bridge (#1308) 7e31834c66 Fix mandatory headers scanning in on-demand relay (#1306) 92ddc3ea7a Polkadot-staging update (#1305) 3787193a31 fix session length of Rococo and Wococo (#1304) eb468d29c0 Revert nightly docker pin (#1301) e2d4c073e1 Use raw balance value if tokenDecimals property is missing (#1299) 108f4b29d1 Fix ss58 prefixes of Polkadot, Kusama and Westend used by relay (#1298) 64fbd2705e bump chain spec versions (#1297) 5707777b86 Bump Substrate/Polkadot/Cumulus refs (#1295) 29eecdf1fa Merge pull request #1294 from paritytech/polkadot-staging-update 1f0c05368e Relay balance metrics (#1291) 6356bb90b3 when messages pallet is halted, relay shall not submit messages delivery/confirmation transactions (#1289) 800dc2df8d when GRANDPA pallet is halted, relay shall not submit finality transactions (#1288) 3dd8e4f936 disable BEEFY allerts for Rialto (#1285) f58fed7380 support version mode cli options in send-message subcommand (#1284) 3aac448da3 reuse polkadot-service code (#1273) 2bdbb651e1 replace latest_confirmed_nonce runtime APIs with direct storage reads (#1282) 5f9c6d241f move "common" code of messages pallet benchmarks helpers to the common library (#1281) 173d2d8229 Merge pull request #1280 from paritytech/polkadot-staging-update 8b9c4ec16d do not start spec_version guard when version mode is set to auto (#1278) e98d682de2 removed extra messages benchmarks (#1279) c730e25b61 Move benchmarks from Rialto to Millau (#1277) 54146416e7 Merge pull request #1276 from paritytech/polkadot-staging-update df70118174 Merge branch 'master' into polkadot-staging-update ed7def64c4 Revert "override conversion rate in estimate-message-fee RPC (#1189)" (#1275) 38c6c3a49f Use "production" floating tag when uilding docker image from version git tags (#1272) ded9ff6dbb Replace InboundLaneApi::latest_received_nonce with direct storage read (#1269) f704a741ee Polkadot staging update (#1270) 8c65f0d7ab verify that GRANDPA pallet is not initialized before submitting initialization transaction (#1267) e7e83d8944 remove OutboundLaneApi::latest_received_nonce (#1262) 9f4b34acf1 bump rococo version (#1263) 82c08c5a87 read latest_generated_nonce directly from storage (#1260) 50ffb5dd08 override conversion rate in estimate-message-fee RPC (#1189) 467ca5ef59 move storage keys computation to primitivs (#1254) 4f9884066b remporary use pinned bridges-ci image in Dockerfile (#1258) edfcb74e00 Change submit transaction spec_version and transaction_version query from chain (#1248) 4009d970d0 pin bridges-ci image (#1256) 65e51b5e1c decrease startup sleep to 5s for relays and to 120s for generators + remove curl (#1251) 3bc74355d9 Add missing RPC APIs to rialto parachain node (#1250) 80c9429284 Bump relay version to 1.0.0 (#1249) 9ead06af2a runtimes: fix call_size() test (#1245) 4fc8a29357 Use same endowed accounts set on dev/local chains (#1244) fed54371c2 Refactor message relay helpers (#1234) a15b4faae7 post-merge build fix (#1243) 52232d8d54 Fix transactions mortality (#1196) c07bba931f Expose prometheus BEEFY metrics and add them to grafana dashboard (#1242) f927775bd5 Refactor finality relay helpers (#1220) 7bf76f14a8 Update Rococo/Wococo version + prepare relay for Rococo<>Wococo bridge (#1241) e860fecd04 Enable offchain indexing for Rialto/Millau nodes (#1239) 04d4d1c6b4 Enable Beefy debug logs in test deployment (#1237) cd771f1089 Fix storage parameter name computation (#1238) 816ddd2dd2 Integrate BEEFY with Rialto & Millau runtimes (#1227) d94b62b1ac update dependencies (#1229) 98eb9ee13d Add mut support (#1232) ffef6f89f9 fixed set_operational in GRANDPA pallet (#1226) bd2f8bfbd7 Add CODEOWNERS file (#1219) 6b5cf2b591 Unify metric names (#1209) d1541e797e remove abandoned exchange relay (#1217) 39140d0b34 Remove unused `relays/headers` (#1216) 9bc071d42b Remove unused PoA<>Substrate bridge (#1210) 877e8d01e3 Fix UI deployment. (#1211) 6cd5775ebe Add `AtLeast32BitUnsigned` for MessageLance::SourceChainBalance (#1207) git-subtree-dir: bridges git-subtree-split: f220d2fccabbf141101d19456ecb4e3576a1d797
* Squashed 'bridges/' changes from 1602249f0a..f220d2fcca f220d2fcca Polkadot staging update (#1356) 02fd3d497c fix parse_transaction on Rialto+Millau (#1360) bc191fd9a2 update parity-scale-codec to 3.1.2 (#1359) a37226e79c update chain versions (#1358) ff5d539fcb Update Substrate/Polkadot/Cumulus references (#1353) 1581f60cd5 Support dedicated lanes for pallets (#962) 0a7ccf5c57 ignore more "increase" alerts that are sometimes signalling NoData at startup (#1351) 31165127cc added no_stack_overflow_when_decoding_nested_call_during_dispatch test (#1349) 7000619eb8 replace From<>InboundLaneApi with direct storage reads (#1348) 515df10ccc added alerts for relay balances (#1347) b56f6a87de Mortal conversion rate updater transactions (#1257) 20f2f331ec edition = "2021" (#1346) 99147d4f75 update regex to 1.5.5 (#1345) 686191f379 use DecodeLimit when decoding incoming calls (#1344) a70c276006 get rid of '[No Data] Messages from Millau to Rialto are not being delivered' warnings (#1342) 01f29b8ac1 fix conversion rate metric in dashboards (#1341) 51c3bf351f Increase rate from metric when estimating fee (#1340) 3bb9c4f68f fix generator scripts to be consistent with updatedrelay output (#1339) 0475a1667b fixed mess with conversion rates (#1338) d8fdd7d716 synchronize relay cli changes and token swap generator script (#1337) 6e928137a5 fix conversion rate override in token swap (#1336) 62d4a4811d override conversion rate in tokens swap generator (#1335) ed9e1c839c fi typo in generator script (#1334) 3254b5af7a Override conversion rate when computing message fee (#1261) 66df68b5b8 Revert "Revert "override conversion rate in estimate-message-fee RPC (#1189)" (#1275)" (#1333) 0ca6fc6ef8 fix clippy issues (#1332) 5414b2fffb Reinitialize bridge relay subcommand (#1331) a63d95ba7d removed extra *_RUNTIME_VERSION consts from relay code (#1330) 59fb18a310 fix typo in alert expression (#1329) a6267a47ee Using-same-fork metric for finality and complex relay (#1327) 88d684d37e use mortal transactions in transaction resubmitter (#1326) 8ff88b6844 impl Decode for SignedExtensions (otherwise transaction resubmitter panicks) (#1325) 1ed09854f0 Encode and estimate Rococo/Wococo/Kusama/Polkadot messages (#1322) ddb4517e13 Add some tests to check integrity of chain constants + bridge configuration (#1316) bdeedb7ab9 Fix issues from cargo deny (#1311) d3d79d01e0 expose fee multiplier metrics in messages relay (#1312) c8b3f0ea16 Endow relayer account at target chain in message benchmarks (#1310) f51ecd92b6 fix benchmarks before using it in Polkadot/Kusama/Rococo runtimes (#1309) 6935c619ad increase relay balance guard limits for Polkadot<>Kusama bridge (#1308) 7e31834c66 Fix mandatory headers scanning in on-demand relay (#1306) 92ddc3ea7a Polkadot-staging update (#1305) 3787193a31 fix session length of Rococo and Wococo (#1304) eb468d29c0 Revert nightly docker pin (#1301) e2d4c073e1 Use raw balance value if tokenDecimals property is missing (#1299) 108f4b29d1 Fix ss58 prefixes of Polkadot, Kusama and Westend used by relay (#1298) 64fbd2705e bump chain spec versions (#1297) 5707777b86 Bump Substrate/Polkadot/Cumulus refs (#1295) 29eecdf1fa Merge pull request #1294 from paritytech/polkadot-staging-update 1f0c05368e Relay balance metrics (#1291) 6356bb90b3 when messages pallet is halted, relay shall not submit messages delivery/confirmation transactions (#1289) 800dc2df8d when GRANDPA pallet is halted, relay shall not submit finality transactions (#1288) 3dd8e4f936 disable BEEFY allerts for Rialto (#1285) f58fed7380 support version mode cli options in send-message subcommand (#1284) 3aac448da3 reuse polkadot-service code (#1273) 2bdbb651e1 replace latest_confirmed_nonce runtime APIs with direct storage reads (#1282) 5f9c6d241f move "common" code of messages pallet benchmarks helpers to the common library (#1281) 173d2d8229 Merge pull request #1280 from paritytech/polkadot-staging-update 8b9c4ec16d do not start spec_version guard when version mode is set to auto (#1278) e98d682de2 removed extra messages benchmarks (#1279) c730e25b61 Move benchmarks from Rialto to Millau (#1277) 54146416e7 Merge pull request #1276 from paritytech/polkadot-staging-update df70118174 Merge branch 'master' into polkadot-staging-update ed7def64c4 Revert "override conversion rate in estimate-message-fee RPC (#1189)" (#1275) 38c6c3a49f Use "production" floating tag when uilding docker image from version git tags (#1272) ded9ff6dbb Replace InboundLaneApi::latest_received_nonce with direct storage read (#1269) f704a741ee Polkadot staging update (#1270) 8c65f0d7ab verify that GRANDPA pallet is not initialized before submitting initialization transaction (#1267) e7e83d8944 remove OutboundLaneApi::latest_received_nonce (#1262) 9f4b34acf1 bump rococo version (#1263) 82c08c5a87 read latest_generated_nonce directly from storage (#1260) 50ffb5dd08 override conversion rate in estimate-message-fee RPC (#1189) 467ca5ef59 move storage keys computation to primitivs (#1254) 4f9884066b remporary use pinned bridges-ci image in Dockerfile (#1258) edfcb74e00 Change submit transaction spec_version and transaction_version query from chain (#1248) 4009d970d0 pin bridges-ci image (#1256) 65e51b5e1c decrease startup sleep to 5s for relays and to 120s for generators + remove curl (#1251) 3bc74355d9 Add missing RPC APIs to rialto parachain node (#1250) 80c9429284 Bump relay version to 1.0.0 (#1249) 9ead06af2a runtimes: fix call_size() test (#1245) 4fc8a29357 Use same endowed accounts set on dev/local chains (#1244) fed54371c2 Refactor message relay helpers (#1234) a15b4faae7 post-merge build fix (#1243) 52232d8d54 Fix transactions mortality (#1196) c07bba931f Expose prometheus BEEFY metrics and add them to grafana dashboard (#1242) f927775bd5 Refactor finality relay helpers (#1220) 7bf76f14a8 Update Rococo/Wococo version + prepare relay for Rococo<>Wococo bridge (#1241) e860fecd04 Enable offchain indexing for Rialto/Millau nodes (#1239) 04d4d1c6b4 Enable Beefy debug logs in test deployment (#1237) cd771f1089 Fix storage parameter name computation (#1238) 816ddd2dd2 Integrate BEEFY with Rialto & Millau runtimes (#1227) d94b62b1ac update dependencies (#1229) 98eb9ee13d Add mut support (#1232) ffef6f89f9 fixed set_operational in GRANDPA pallet (#1226) bd2f8bfbd7 Add CODEOWNERS file (#1219) 6b5cf2b591 Unify metric names (#1209) d1541e797e remove abandoned exchange relay (#1217) 39140d0b34 Remove unused `relays/headers` (#1216) 9bc071d42b Remove unused PoA<>Substrate bridge (#1210) 877e8d01e3 Fix UI deployment. (#1211) 6cd5775ebe Add `AtLeast32BitUnsigned` for MessageLance::SourceChainBalance (#1207) git-subtree-dir: bridges git-subtree-split: f220d2fccabbf141101d19456ecb4e3576a1d797 * fix compilation warnings
This work around the bug described in: #1327
We check the candidate signatures in
create_inherent
to ensure thatall are valid. If one isn't valid, we don't include any candidate for
the current inherent.