Towards Open Vocabulary Learning: A Survey

T-PAMI, 2024
Jianzong Wu ^* . Xiangtai Li ^* · Shilin Xu ^* · Haobo Yuan ^* · Henghui Ding · Yibo Yang · Xia Li · Jiangning Zhang · Yunhai Tong · Xudong Jiang · Bernard Ghanem · Dacheng Tao ·

This repo is used for recording, tracking, and benchmarking several recent open vocabulary methods to supplement our survey.
If you find any work missing or have any suggestions (papers, implementations, and other resources), feel free to pull requests. We will add the missing papers to this repo as soon as possible.

🔥Add Your Paper in our Repo and Survey!!!!!

[-] You are welcome to give us an issue or PR for your open vocabulary learning work !!!!!

[-] Note that: Due to the huge paper in Arxiv, we are sorry to cover all in our survey. You can directly present a PR into this repo and we will record it for next version update of our survey.

[-] Our survey will be updated in 2024.3.

🔥New

[-] Our work is accepted by T-PAMI !!! 🔥🔥🔥

[-] We update GitHub to record the available paper by the end of 2024/1/10.

[-] We update GitHub to record the available paper by the end of 2023/7/20.

🔥Highlight!!

[1] The first survey for open vocabulary learning, including open vocabulary detection/segmentation/tracking.

[2] It also contains several related domains, including foundation model tuning and open-world detection.

[3] We list detailed results for the most representative works and give a fairer and clearer comparison of different approaches.

Introduction

This survey presents the first detailed survey on open vocabulary tasks, including open-vocabulary object detection, open-vocabulary segmentation, and 3D/video open-vocabulary tasks.

Summary of Contents

• Introduction
• Summary of Contents
• Methods: A Survey
  • Open Vocabulary Object Detection
  • Open Vocabulary Segmentation
    • Semantic Segmentation
    • Instance Segmentation
    • Panoptic Segmentation
  • Open Vocabulary Video Understanding
    • Video Classification
    • Tracking
    • Video Instance Segmentation
  • Open Vocabulary 3D Scene Understanding
    • 3D Classification
    • 3D Detection
    • 3D segmentation
• Related Domains and Beyond
  • Class-agnostic Detection and Segmentation
  • Open-World Object Detection
  • Open-Set Panoptic Segmentation
• Acknowledgement
• Contact

Methods: A Survey

Keywords

• cap.: Use caption as auxiliary training data
• vlm.: Use pretrained VLMs like CLIP
• pl.: Generate pseudo labels
• w/o ps.: Training without pixel-level supervision
• pre.: Vision-language pretraining
• diff.: Use diffusion models
• unify: Unify several tasks (semantic segmentation, instance segmentation, and panoptic segmentation)
• sam: Use SAM (Segment Anything Model)
• open.: Demonstrated with open-set capability. (only for Video Understanding)
• audio.: With audio modality.
• bench: Propose a benchmark.
• other: Other methods that cannot be grouped into above ones.
• no-train: Does not need training.

Open Vocabulary Object Detection

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2021	CVPR	cap.	Open-Vocabulary Object Detection Using Captions	Code
2022	ICLR	vlm.	Open-vocabulary Object Detection via Vision and Language Knowledge Distillation	Code
2022	CVPR	cap., vlm., pre.	RegionCLIP: Region-based Language-Image Pretraining	Code
2022	CVPR	vlm.	Learning to Prompt for Open-Vocabulary Object Detection with Vision-Language Model	Code
2022	CVPR	vlm., cap.	Open-Vocabulary One-Stage Detection with Hierarchical Visual-Language Knowledge Distillation	Code
2022	CVPR	cap., vlm.	Grounded Language-Image Pre-training	[Code]
2022	NeurIPS	cap., vlm.	GLIPv2: Unifying Localization and VL Understanding	Code
2022	GCPR	cap.	Localized Vision-Language Matching for Open-vocabulary Object Detection	Code
2022	ECCV	vlm.	Open-Vocabulary DETR with Conditional Matching	Code
2022	ECCV	vlm., cap., pl.	Open Vocabulary Object Detection with Pseudo Bounding-Box Labels	Code
2022	ECCV	vlm.	Promptdet: Towards open-vocabulary detection using uncurated images	Code
2022	ECCV	vlm., pl., w/o ps.	Detecting Twenty-thousand Classes using Image-level Supervision	Code
2022	ECCV	vlm.. pl.	Exploiting unlabeled data with vision and language models for object detection	Code
2022	ECCV	vlm., cap.	Simple Open-Vocabulary Object Detection with Vision Transformers	Code
2022	NeurIPS	vlm., pl.	Bridging the Gap between Object and Image-level Representations for Open-Vocabulary Detection	Code
2022	NeurIPS	vlm., cap.	DetCLIP: Dictionary-Enriched Visual-Concept Paralleled Pre-training for Open-world Detection	N/A
2022	arXiv	vlm.	Open Vocabulary Object Detection with Proposal Mining and Prediction Equalization	Code
2022	arXiv	vlm., pl.	P3OVD: Fine-grained Visual-Text Prompt-Driven Self-Training for Open-Vocabulary Object Detection	N/A
2023	ICLR	vlm., pl.	Learning Object-Language Alignments for Open-Vocabulary Object Detection	Code
2023	ICLR	vlm.	F-VLM: Open-Vocabulary Object Detection upon Frozen Vision and Language Models	Code
2023	CVPR	other., vlm.	Learning to Detect and Segment for Open Vocabulary Object Detection	N/A
2023	CVPR	vlm., cap.	Aligning Bag of Regions for Open-Vocabulary Object Detection	Code
2023	CVPR	vlm.	Object-Aware Distillation Pyramid for Open-Vocabulary Object Detection	Code
2023	CVPR	vlm.	CORA: Adapting CLIP for Open-Vocabulary Detection with Region Prompting and Anchor Pre-Matching	N/A
2023	CVPR	vlm., pl.	DetCLIPv2: Scalable Open-Vocabulary Object Detection Pre-training via Word-Region Alignment	N/A
2023	CVPR	vlm.	Region-Aware Pretraining for Open-Vocabulary Object Detection with Vision Transformers	N/A
2023	ICML	vlm.	Multi-Modal Classifiers for Open-Vocabulary Object Detection	Project
2023	arXiv	vlm.	GridCLIP: One-Stage Object Detection by Grid-Level CLIP Representation Learning	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm., cap.	Enhancing the Role of Context in Region-Word Alignment for Object Detection	N/A
2023	arXiv	cap., pl.	Open-Vocabulary Object Detection using Pseudo Caption Labels	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm., pl.	Three ways to improve feature alignment for open vocabulary detection	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm.	Prompt-Guided Transformers for End-to-End Open-Vocabulary Object Detection	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm., cap., pl.	MaMMUT: A Simple Architecture for Joint Learning for MultiModal Tasks	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm., cap., pl.	Scaling Open-Vocabulary Object Detection	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm.	Open-Vocabulary Object Detection via Scene Graph Discovery	N/A
2023	ICCV	vlm.	Detection-Oriented Image-Text Pretraining for Open-Vocabulary Detection	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm.	EdaDet: Open-Vocabulary Object Detection Using Early Dense Alignment	Code
2023	KDD	vlm.	What Makes Good Open-Vocabulary Detector: A Disassembling Perspective	N/A
2023	NeurIPS	vlm.	CoDet: Co-Occurrence Guided Region-Word Alignment for Open-Vocabulary Object Detection	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm.	DST-Det: Simple Dynamic Self-Training for Open-Vocabulary Object Detection	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm.	Taming Self-Training for Open-Vocabulary Object Detection	Code
2023	arXiv	unify., vlm., pre.	CLIPSelf: Vision Transformer Distills Itself for Open-Vocabulary Dense Prediction	Code
2023	arXiv	bench	The devil is in the fine-grained details: Evaluating open-vocabulary object detectors for fine-grained understanding	Project
2023	BMVC	vlm.	Open-Vocabulary Object Detection with Meta Prompt Representation and Instance Contrastive Optimization	N/A
2024	AAAI	vlm.	Simple Image-level Classification Improves Open-vocabulary Object Detection	Code
2024	AAAI	vlm.	ProxyDet: Synthesizing Proxy Novel Classes via Classwise Mixup for Open-Vocabulary Object Detection	Code
2024	AAAI	unify., vlm., pre.	CLIM: Contrastive Language-Image Mosaic for Region Representation	Code
2024	WACV	vlm.	LP-OVOD: Open-Vocabulary Object Detection by Linear Probing	Code
2024	CVPR	vlm.	YOLO-World: Real-Time Open-Vocabulary Object Detection	Code

Open Vocabulary Segmentation

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2023	CVPR	unify., vlm.	Primitive Generation and Semantic-related Alignment for Universal Zero-Shot Segmentation	Code
2023	CVPR	unify., vlm.	FreeSeg: Unified, Universal and Open-Vocabulary Image Segmentation	Code
2023	arXiv	unify., vlm.	OpenSD: Unified Open-Vocabulary Segmentation and Detection	Code

Semantic Segmentation

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2022	ICLR	vlm.	Language-driven Semantic Segmentation	Code
2022	CVPR	cap., w/o ps.	GroupViT: Semantic Segmentation Emerges from Text Supervision	Code
2022	CVPR	vlm.	ZegFormer: Decoupling Zero-Shot Semantic Segmentation	Code
2022	ECCV	cap., vlm.	Scaling Open-Vocabulary Image Segmentation with Image-Level Labels	N/A
2022	ECCV	vlm, pl, w/o ps.	Extract Free Dense Labels from CLIP	Code
2022	ECCV	vlm.	A Simple Baseline for Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation with Pre-trained Vision-Language Model	Code
2022	ECCV	vlm., cap., w/o ps.	Open-world Semantic Segmentation via Contrasting and Clustering Vision-Language Embedding	N/A
2022	BMVC	vlm.	Open-vocabulary Semantic Segmentation with Frozen Vision-Language Models	Code
2022	arXiv	vlm., cap., pl, w/o ps.	Perceptual Grouping in Contrastive Vision-Language Models	Code
2022	arXiv	vlm., cap., pl, w/o ps.	SegCLIP: Patch Aggregation with Learnable Centers for Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation	Code
2022	arXiv	vlm., cap., w/o ps.	Open Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation with Patch Aligned Contrastive Learning	N/A
2023	CVPR	vlm., pre.	Generalized Decoding for Pixel, Image, and Language	Code
2023	CVPR	vlm., pl.	Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation with Mask-adapted CLIP	Code
2023	CVPR	cap., vlm., w/o ps.	Learning Open-vocabulary Semantic Segmentation Models From Natural Language Supervision	Code
2023	CVPR	vlm.	Side Adapter Network for Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation	Codd
2023	arXiv	vlm., unify	A Simple Framework for Open-Vocabulary Segmentation and Detection	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm.	Global Knowledge Calibration for Fast Open-Vocabulary Segmentation	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm.	CAT-Seg: Cost Aggregation for Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm., unify	Prompt Pre-Training with Twenty-Thousand Classes for Open-Vocabulary Visual Recognition	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm., unify	Segment Everything Everywhere All at Once	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm.	MVP-SEG: Multi-View Prompt Learning for Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm.	TagCLIP: Improving Discrimination Ability of Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm., w/o ps., sam	Exploring Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation without Human Labels	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm., unify	DaTaSeg: Taming a Universal Multi-Dataset Multi-Task Segmentation Model	N/A
2023	arXiv	diff.	Diffusion Models for Zero-Shot Open-Vocabulary Segmentation	Project
2023	ICCV	diff.	Diffumask: Synthesizing images with pixel-level annotations for semantic segmentation using diffusion models	Project
2023	ICCV	diff.	Guiding Text-to-Image Diffusion Model Towards Grounded Generation	Project
2023	NeurIPS	cap., w/o ps.	Uncovering Prototypical Knowledge for Weakly Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm.	SED: A Simple Encoder-Decoder for Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm., no-train	Plug-and-Play, Dense-Label-Free Extraction of Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation from Vision-Language Models	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm., no-train	Grounding Everything: Emerging Localization Properties in Vision-Language Transformers	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm.	Open-Vocabulary Segmentation with Semantic-Assisted Calibration	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm., no-train	Self-Guided Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation	N/A
2023	arXiv	no-train., vlm., sam	CLIP as RNN: Segment Countless Visual Concepts without Training Endeavor	Project
2023	arXiv	vlm.	CLIP-DINOiser: Teaching CLIP a few DINO tricks	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm., pl.	CLIP Is Also a Good Teacher: A New Learning Framework for Inductive Zero-shot Semantic Segmentation	N/A

Instance Segmentation

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2023	CVPR	vlm.	Semantic-Promoted Debiasing and Background Disambiguation for Zero-Shot Instance Segmentation	Code
2022	CVPR	cap., pl., vlm.	Open-Vocabulary Instance Segmentation via Robust Cross-Modal Pseudo-Labeling	Code
2023	CVPR	vlm, cap, w/o ps.	Mask-free OVIS: Open-Vocabulary Instance Segmentation without Manual Mask Annotations	Code
2023	arXiv	cap.	Betrayed by Captions: Joint Caption Grounding and Generation for Open Vocabulary Instance Segmentation	Code
2023	arXiv	cap.	Leveraging Open-Vocabulary Diffusion to Camouflaged Instance Segmentation	N/A

Panoptic Segmentation

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2023	CVPR	unify., vlm.	Primitive Generation and Semantic-related Alignment for Universal Zero-Shot Segmentation	Code
2022	arXiv	vlm	Open-Vocabulary Panoptic Segmentation with MaskCLIP	N/A
2023	CVPR	diff, vlm	Open-Vocabulary Panoptic Segmentation with Text-to-Image Diffusion Models	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm.	Open-vocabulary Panoptic Segmentation with Embedding Modulation	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm., unify	Hierarchical Open-vocabulary Universal Image Segmentation	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm.	Generalizable Semantic Vision Query Generation for Zero-shot Panoptic and Semantic Segmentation	N/A

Open Vocabulary Video Understanding

Video Classification

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2021	arXiv	vlm.,open.	ActionCLIP: A New Paradigm for Video Action Recognition	Code
2022	ECCV	vlm.,open.	Prompting Visual-Language Models for Efficient Video Understanding	Project
2022	ECCV	vlm.	Frozen CLIP Models are Efficient Video Learners	Code
2022	ECCV	vlm.,open.	Expanding Language-Image Pretrained Models for General Video Recognition	Code
2022	arXiv	vlm.,open.,audio.	Multimodal Open-Vocabulary Video Classification via Pre-Trained Vision and Language Models	N/A
2023	AAAI	vlm.,open.	Revisiting Classifier: Transferring Vision-Language Models for Video Recognition	Code
2023	ICLR	vlm.	AIM: Adapting Image Models for Efficient Video Action Recognition	Project
2023	CVPR	vlm.,open.	Fine-tuned CLIP Models are Efficient Video Learners	Code
2023	ICML	vlm.,open.	Open-VCLIP: Transforming CLIP to an Open-vocabulary Video Model via Interpolated Weight Optimization	Code
2023	ICCV	vlm.,open.	Video Action Recognition with Attentive Semantic Units	N/A
2023	ICCV	vlm.,open.	MAtch, eXpand and Improve: Unsupervised Finetuning for Zero-Shot Action Recognition with Language Knowledge	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm.,open.	VicTR: Video-conditioned Text Representations for Activity Recognition	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm.,open.	Generating Action-conditioned Prompts for Open-vocabulary Video Action Recognition	N/A

Tracking

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2023	CVPR	vlm.,open.	OVTrack: Open-Vocabulary Multiple Object Tracking	Project

Video Instance Segmentation

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2023	ICCV	vlm.,open.	Towards Open-Vocabulary Video Instance Segmentation	Code
2023	arXiv	vlm.,open.	OpenVIS: Open-vocabulary Video Instance Segmentation	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm.,open.	DVIS++: Improved Decoupled Framework for Universal Video Segmentation	Code

Open Vocabulary 3D Scene Understanding

3D Classification

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2022	CVPR	vlm.	PointCLIP: Point Cloud Understanding by CLIP	Code
2023	CVPR	vlm.	ULIP: Learning a Unified Representation of Language, Images, and Point Clouds for 3D Understanding	Code
2023	ICCV	vlm.	PointCLIP V2: Adapting CLIP for Powerful 3D Open-world Learning	Code
2023	ICCV	vlm.	CLIP2Point: Transfer CLIP to Point Cloud Classification with Image-Depth Pre-training	Code
2023	ICML	vlm.	Contrast with Reconstruct: Contrastive 3D Representation Learning Guided by Generative Pretraining	Code
2024	WACV	vlm.	LidarCLIP or: How I Learned to Talk to Point Clouds	Code

3D Detection

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2022	arXiv	vlm.	Open-Vocabulary 3D Detection via Image-level Class and Debiased Cross-modal Contrastive Learning	N/A
2023	CVPR	vlm.	Open-Vocabulary Point-Cloud Object Detection without 3D Annotation	Code
2023	NeurIPS	vlm.	CoDA: Collaborative Novel Box Discovery and Cross-modal Alignment for Open-vocabulary 3D Object Detection	Project
2023	arXiv	vlm.	Object2Scene: Putting Objects in Context for Open-Vocabulary 3D Detection	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm.	FM-OV3D: Foundation Model-based Cross-modal Knowledge Blending for Open-Vocabulary 3D Detection	N/A
2023	arXiv	vlm.	OpenSight: A Simple Open-Vocabulary Framework for LiDAR-Based Object Detection	N/A

3D segmentation

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2023	CVPR	vlm.	PLA: Language-Driven Open-Vocabulary 3D Scene Understanding	Code
2023	CVPR	vlm.	CLIP2Scene: Towards Label-efficient 3D Scene Understanding by CLIP	Code
2023	CVPR	vlm.	OpenScene: 3D Scene Understanding with Open Vocabularies	Project
2023	ICCVW	vlm.	CLIP-FO3D: Learning Free Open-world 3D Scene Representations from 2D Dense CLIP	N/A
2023	NeurIPS	vlm.	OpenMask3D: Open-Vocabulary 3D Instance Segmentation	Project
2023	arXiv	vlm.	OpenIns3D: Snap and Lookup for 3D Open-vocabulary Instance Segmentation	Project
2023	arXiv	vlm.	Open3DIS: Open-vocabulary 3D Instance Segmentation with 2D Mask Guidance	Project

Related Domains and Beyond

Class-agnostic Detection and Segmentation

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2022	RA-L	-	Learning Open-World Object Proposals without Learning to Classify	Code
2021	ICCV	-	Unidentified Video Objects: A Benchmark for Dense, Open-World Segmentation	Project
2022	CVPR	-	Open-World Instance Segmentation: Exploiting Pseudo Ground Truth From Learned Pairwise Affinity	Project
2022	ECCV	-	Class-agnostic object detection with multi-modal transformer	Code
2022	TPAMI	-	Open World Entity Segmentation	Project
2022	arXiv	-	Fine-Grained Entity Segmentation	Project

Open-World Object Detection

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2015	CVPR	-	Towards Open World Recognition	N/A
2021	CVPR	-	Towards Open World Object Detection.	Code
2022	CVPR	-	OW-DETR: Open-world Detection Transformer	Code
2022	ECCV	-	UC-OWOD: Unknown-Classified Open World Object Detection	Code
2022	arXiv	-	Revisiting Open World Object Detection	Code
2022	arXiv	-	Rectifying Open-set Object Detection: A Taxonomy, Practical Applications, and Proper Evaluation	[N/A]
2022	arXiv	-	Open World DETR: Transformer based Open World Object Detection	N/A
2023	CVPR	-	PROB: Probabilistic Objectness for Open World Object Detection	Code
2023	arXiv	-	Open World Object Detection in the Era of Foundation Models	Code
2023	arXiv	-	Hyp-OW: Exploiting Hierarchical Structure Learning with Hyperbolic Distance Enhances Open World Object Detection	[N/A]

Open-Set Panoptic Segmentation

Year	Venue	Keywords	Paper Title	Code/Project
2021	CVPR	-	Exemplar-Based Open-Set Panoptic Segmentation Network	Project
2022	arXiv	-	Dual Decision Improves Open-Set Panoptic Segmentation	Code

Acknowledgement

If you find our survey and repository useful for your research project, please consider citing our paper:

@article{wu2023open,
      title={Towards Open Vocabulary Learning: A Survey}, 
      author={Jianzong Wu and Xiangtai Li and Shilin Xu and Haobo Yuan and Henghui Ding and Yibo Yang and Xia Li and Jiangning Zhang and Yunhai Tong and Xudong Jiang and Bernard Ghanem and Dacheng Tao},
      year={2024},
      journal={T-PAMI},
}

Contact

jzwu@stu.pku.edu.cn

lxtpku@pku.edu.cn or xiangtai94@gmail.com