Doesn't receive flash SMS when no system SMS app is installed. #105
Comments
|
Hmm, interesting. Right now TextSecure isn't really setup to run If we want to support TextSecure operating as the sole messaging |
|
I see - thanks for the reply guess i will have to look to see what apps i nuked and restore a basis SMS handler untill this issue is resolved. I agree that i think TextSecure is up for this but wasn't aware about the lack of so called "flash message" support. Perhaps on my last phone I still had some default SMS app that handled this in the background, so im thinking i might have removed something i shouldn't have as now two-step authentication from google and 2 step security messages from my bank sometimes don't come in / get received by TextSecure, this never used to happen. But thank you again for making me aware of this ill try restoring the default messaging app and see if it goes away, but making TestSecure a stand-alone SMS handler would be real nice. From: Moxie Marlinspike notifications@github.com Hmm, interesting. Right now TextSecure isn't really setup to run If we want to support TextSecure operating as the sole messaging http://www.thoughtcrime.org |
|
I get the occasional regular sms not received by TextSecure. Infrequent enough that it's not a major issue, but certainly annoying when it's sent by another TextSecure user. Is there any way I can produce some logging which would be useful for you to look at? Running latest version of TS on unrooted Galaxy Note 2, Android 4.1.1 |
|
@beresfordt that sounds like a much more dire situation than the original reporter, who is only missing "flash" sms messages because there's no system SMS app on his device for them to fall through to. Is your issue reproducible? If you can reproduce it and send over adb logcat output when it happens, that'd be great. |
|
Yeah on re-reading this my issue is entirely different.. When I get a chance I'll set logcat going, spam myself with texts and raise a new issue if I manage to capture something when it happens |
|
I'm assigning this to @thoughtbox , since not intercepting flash SMS was his idea. =) |
|
Wat. Wat? Grr. Right - so; what do we actually want here? Back to the code i submitted a while back? :-) ("Choose whether to intercept flash messages or let them through to the system sms application"?) Or are we talking about writing functionality in TS (for an option) to display flash messages? |
|
Yeah, I guess I can live with a preference. Simplest way to fix @steve77 's problem. |
|
Just wanted to thank you and your team, after the recent update, it seems to be working much better, and the 'flash sms' issue as you called it seems to be resolved. As I seem to be getting all my sms's from googles 2step authentication as well as my bank - where in the past i had to use email as my contact method for 2 step authentication as i would never get the SMS that was sent. But they seem to be coming in fine now. Thanks again |
|
Hey @steve77, thanks for the confidence, but we didn't actually change anything with that logic! (@thoughtbox is apparently slacking). Strange that it suddenly started intercepting them. |
|
Interesting...yeah the last update though the android market seemed to fix the issue i was having.... Dont know but thanks for the update. From: Moxie Marlinspike notifications@github.com Hey @steve77, thanks for the confidence, but we didn't actually change anything with that logic! (@thoughtbox is apparently slacking). Strange that it suddenly started intercepting them. |
|
Hello Running TextSecure 2.0.3 on Android 4.3 (Samsung Galaxy Nexus GSM), stock Android. I do not receive any flash SMS, f.e. login codes for my online banking. I verified this issue with Hangouts and stock SMS app, both apps receive flash SMS. Any ideas? |
|
#551 seems to be related |
|
And I'm supposed to look at it. cough I'll see what I can do. It's been a while. |
|
Great, many thanks! |
|
Felix, If you are referring to "Chase" bank - for flash sms their The only issue I had until recently was with my phone not sending/receiving MMS but I came across a way to fix it on XDA-DEV courtesy of 'wesgarner': " MMS does NOW work.. As for push messages, not sure why the chase bank ones never come From: FelixSt notifications@github.com Hello |
|
steve: no, i live in switzerland and use the authentification system of a very small bank. just before i began to use textsecure, everything worked fine (i first used the stock sms app, then hangouts). |
|
Felix: Ok, the only other thing I can personally think of is if you are using a custom rom (CyanogenMod, etc...) Ive had trouble with the WhisperPush "add-on" to TextSecure in some of those builds. If you have that feature enabled, suggest you wipe your device, reflash to previous point in time before that feature was enabled. Anyone else have problems with 2-step authorization with JP Morgan "Chase" bank in US? From: FelixSt notifications@github.com steve: no, i live in switzerland and use the authentification system of a very small bank. just before i began to use textsecure, everything worked fine (i first used the stock sms app, then hangouts). |
|
Steve: I have a stock version of Android on my Galaxy Nexus, so no custom rom. I remember that when i used the old version (<2.x) flash sms worked fine... Thanks anyway for your help! |
|
GitHub Issue Cleanup: |
rooted phone (tmobile mytouch slide 4G) and deleted default messaging app, replaced with text secure, however sometimes certain automated SMS (such as from bank (chase) / google 2 step authentication) aren't received for some reason. Is there a way to force the app (make system app) to take control / manage the SMS database? Or is this a bug?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: