EIP712 - Cannot pass a string as chainId

[freemanzMrojo]

Describe the bug

Currently the TypedDataDomain looks like this:

export type TypedDataDomain = {
  chainId?: number | undefined
  name?: string | undefined
  salt?: ResolvedRegister['bytesType']['outputs'] | undefined
  verifyingContract?: Address | undefined
  version?: string | undefined
}

Sometimes the chainId might be larger than a number, so I was wondering whether it would be possible to also support string and bigint (or maybe just string) for that field. In the spec the attribute is expected to be an uint256.

I have seen in another "famous library" (:p) that the type for chainId is number | bigint | string | null.

Thanks in advance.

Expected Behavior

I can pass a string as chainId. Specifically, I would like to be able to pass these values:

1. 14018334920824264832118464179726739019961432051877733167310318607178
2. 1176455790972829965191905223412607679856028701100105089447013101863
3. 20257036855429895315704288894496386224204271168750785572924599986678

Link to Minimal Reproducible Example

No response

Steps To Reproduce

No response

Package Version

1.0.6

TypeScript Version

5.6.3

Check existing issues

• I checked there isn't already an issue for the bug I encountered.

Anything else?

No response

[tmm]

What chain IDs are these?

[freemanzMrojo]

Hi @tmm ,

Thanks for coming back to me! Those IDs are the values used by VeChain as chainId for the different networks in order to apply EIP712.

Internally they are the Genesis Block ID since there is no native chainId. So for the values provided above:

• Mainnet: 14018334920824264832118464179726739019961432051877733167310318607178 in hex is 851CAF3CFDB6E899CF5958BFB1AC3413D346D43539627E6BE7EC1B4A so the Genesis Block ID is that value => https://explore.vechain.org/blocks/0x00000000851caf3cfdb6e899cf5958bfb1ac3413d346d43539627e6be7ec1b4a
• Testnet: 1176455790972829965191905223412607679856028701100105089447013101863 in hex is B2BCE3C70BC649A02749E8687721B09ED2E15997F466536B20BB127 so the Genesis Block ID is that value => https://explore-testnet.vechain.org/blocks/0x000000000b2bce3c70bc649a02749e8687721b09ed2e15997f466536b20bb127
• Solo (local): In this case the value varies depending on the content of the custom genesis file, but by default it is 20257036855429895315704288894496386224204271168750785572924599986678.

I work for VeChain. Any further input you need just let me know, thanks for your help!

[github-actions]

This issue has been locked since it has been closed for more than 14 days.

If you found a concrete bug or regression related to it, please open a new bug report with a reproduction against the latest ABIType version. If you have any questions or comments you can create a new discussion thread.