Feature request: normalize generics usage #712

knocte · 2020-03-05T04:40:07Z

I just wanted to leave this here: https://twitter.com/7sharp9_exhumed/status/1235357140488982532 :)

jindraivanek · 2020-03-06T13:08:10Z

I agree that we should be opinionated towards recommended style, including this.

Its interesting that style of generics is actually present in AST https://jindraivanek.gitlab.io/ast-viewer/#?code=C4TwDgpgBA5AhlACgJwgMwJYA8oF5YIDKEwAsAFCiRID2AzsJlgDzwB8eUxwrcbQA&defines=Q&filename=MoYwTglgDgLgdAMwM4A8g

Which is quite weird, because typically pure stylistics choices are not present in AST..

Fantomas right now just respect AST (that means it uses original source style).

nojaf · 2020-03-06T13:22:24Z

Agreed, https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/fsharp/style-guide/formatting#use-prefix-syntax-for-generics-foot-in-preference-to-postfix-syntax-t-foo

Source will be formatted using this command: fantomas --config fantomas-config.json --recurse src/GWallet.Backend/ This version of fantomas doesn't crash anymore when formatting it: dotnet tool install -g fantomas-tool --add-source https://www.myget.org/F/fantomas/api/v3/index.json --framework netcoreapp3.1 --version 4.0.0-alpha-008-alpha-190 Last issues left to fix (by order of priority, top is more important): - fsprojects/fantomas#898 (comment) - fsprojects/fantomas#907 - fsprojects/fantomas#905 - fsprojects/fantomas#908 - fsprojects/fantomas#712 - fsprojects/fantomas#904

This version of fantomas doesn't crash anymore when formatting it: dotnet tool install -g fantomas-tool --add-source https://www.myget.org/F/fantomas/api/v3/index.json --framework netcoreapp3.1 --version 4.0.0-alpha-012 Source will be formatted using this command: fantomas --recurse src/GWallet.Backend/ Things that would need to be fixed manually before merging this to master: - We can drop parens in many if statements, e.g.: StratumClient.fs' CreateVersion's, ServerManager.fs' GetDummyBalanceAction, FTPC.fs' FTPC type, EtherAccount.fs' GetTransactionCount - Drop parents in ReadAllText calls of Account.fs - Many raise lines should use <|, e.g. in WarpKey.fs, UtxoCoinAccount.fs, and ElectrumServer.fs - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' EstimateFees unneeded use of |> with 'head' Fantomas issues from geewallet's wishlist: - fsprojects/fantomas#712 - fsprojects/fantomas#908 - fsprojects/fantomas#684 Issues not yet reported: - PageWidth not being respected? look at how long some lines in UtxoCoinAccount.fs' GetAccountFromFile are. - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' TransactionOutpoint.ToCoin() should start on next line. - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' SignTransactionWithPrivateKey has some if lines splitted weirdly, e.g. cut off at <> operator - UtxoCoin/TransactionTypes.fs' Currency member is split in 2 lines, why? - Why cut `truncated` var assignment in Formatting.fs' DecimalAmountTruncating func? - inherit statements should add a space too (look at FaultTolerantParallelClient.fs) - FaultTolerantParallelClient.fs' Runner.Run is tooooooo long - Moving commend comment of FTPC.fs' CustomCancelSource's Dispose func - (Investigate) FSharpUtil.option{} that contains a `do! if...`, WAT - Cutting function after `+` in short line (Account.fs function SaveOutgoingTransactionInCache Last but not least, investigate if alpha-012 contains unwanted things like 311bff817f89f8b47c0799eb7474da886175ef15, otherwise we might need to go back to 04c48d5, which should be alpha-011 with these fantomas-config.json settings: { "IndentSpaceNum":4, "PageWidth":80, "SemicolonAtEndOfLine":false, "SpaceBeforeParameter":true, "SpaceBeforeLowercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeUppercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeClassConstructor":true, "SpaceBeforeMember":true, "SpaceBeforeColon":false, "SpaceAfterComma":true, "SpaceBeforeSemicolon":false, "SpaceAfterSemicolon":true, "IndentOnTryWith":true, "SpaceAroundDelimiter":true, "MaxIfThenElseShortWidth":0, "MaxRecordWidth":0, "MaxFunctionBindingWidth":0, "MaxValueBindingWidth":80, "MultilineBlockBracketsOnSameColumn":true, "NewlineBetweenTypeDefinitionAndMembers":true, "KeepIfThenInSameLine":true, "StrictMode":false }

This version of fantomas doesn't crash anymore when formatting it: dotnet tool install -g fantomas-tool --add-source https://www.myget.org/F/fantomas/api/v3/index.json --framework netcoreapp3.1 --version 4.0.0-alpha-012 Source will be formatted using this command: fantomas --recurse src/GWallet.Backend/ Things that would need to be fixed manually before merging this to master: - We can drop parens in many if statements, e.g.: StratumClient.fs' CreateVersion's, ServerManager.fs' GetDummyBalanceAction, FTPC.fs' FTPC type, EtherAccount.fs' GetTransactionCount - Drop parents in ReadAllText calls of Account.fs - Many raise lines should use <|, e.g. in WarpKey.fs, UtxoCoinAccount.fs, and ElectrumServer.fs - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' EstimateFees unneeded use of |> with 'head' Fantomas issues from geewallet's wishlist: - fsprojects/fantomas#712 - fsprojects/fantomas#908 - fsprojects/fantomas#684 - fsprojects/fantomas#964 Issues not yet reported: - There should be a setting called AlwaysSplitPipeOperatorInNewLine - MaxLineLength not being respected? look at how long some lines in UtxoCoinAccount.fs' GetAccountFromFile are. - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' TransactionOutpoint.ToCoin() should start on next line. - Why cut `truncated` var assignment in Formatting.fs' DecimalAmountTruncating func? - FaultTolerantParallelClient.fs' Runner.Run is tooooooo long - Moving commend comment of FTPC.fs' CustomCancelSource's Dispose func - This stupid diff adding an unneeded space: ``` return! faultTolerantEtherClient.Query (FaultTolerantParallelClientDefaultSettings ServerSelectionMode.Fast - currency - (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) + currency + (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) web3Funcs ``` - This stupid 3-space indentation: ``` - if not (account.Currency.IsEtherBased()) then - failwith <| SPrintF1 "Currency %A not ether based and not UTXO either? not supported, report this bug (estimatefee)" - account.Currency + if not (account.Currency.IsEtherBased ()) then + failwith + <| SPrintF1 + "Currency %A not ether based and not UTXO either? not supported, report this bug (estimatefee)" + account.Currency ``` - (Investigate) FSharpUtil.option{} that contains a `do! if...`, WAT - Excessive EOLs in ElectrumClient.fs (one extra addition I didn't even add to this commit) Last but not least, investigate if alpha-012 contains unwanted things like 311bff817f89f8b47c0799eb7474da886175ef15, otherwise we might need to go back to 04c48d5, which should be alpha-011 with these fantomas-config.json settings: { "IndentSpaceNum":4, "PageWidth":80, "SemicolonAtEndOfLine":false, "SpaceBeforeParameter":true, "SpaceBeforeLowercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeUppercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeClassConstructor":true, "SpaceBeforeMember":true, "SpaceBeforeColon":false, "SpaceAfterComma":true, "SpaceBeforeSemicolon":false, "SpaceAfterSemicolon":true, "IndentOnTryWith":true, "SpaceAroundDelimiter":true, "MaxIfThenElseShortWidth":0, "MaxInfixOperatorExpression":80, "MaxRecordWidth":0, "MaxFunctionBindingWidth":0, "MaxValueBindingWidth":80, "MultilineBlockBracketsOnSameColumn":true, "NewlineBetweenTypeDefinitionAndMembers":true, "KeepIfThenInSameLine":true, "StrictMode":false }

This version of fantomas doesn't crash anymore when formatting it: dotnet tool install -g fantomas-tool --add-source https://www.myget.org/F/fantomas/api/v3/index.json --framework netcoreapp3.1 --version 4.0.0-alpha-012 Source will be formatted using this command: fantomas --recurse src/GWallet.Backend/ Things that would need to be fixed manually before merging this to master: - We can drop parens in many if statements, e.g.: StratumClient.fs' CreateVersion's, ServerManager.fs' GetDummyBalanceAction, FTPC.fs' FTPC type, EtherAccount.fs' GetTransactionCount - Drop parents in ReadAllText calls of Account.fs - Many raise lines should use <|, e.g. in WarpKey.fs, UtxoCoinAccount.fs, and ElectrumServer.fs - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' EstimateFees unneeded use of |> with 'head' Fantomas issues from geewallet's wishlist: - fsprojects/fantomas#712 - fsprojects/fantomas#908 - fsprojects/fantomas#684 - fsprojects/fantomas#964 Issues not yet reported: - There should be a setting called AlwaysSplitPipeOperatorInNewLine - MaxLineLength not being respected? look at how long some lines in UtxoCoinAccount.fs' GetAccountFromFile are. - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' TransactionOutpoint.ToCoin() should start on next line. - Why cut `truncated` var assignment in Formatting.fs' DecimalAmountTruncating func? - FaultTolerantParallelClient.fs' Runner.Run is tooooooo long - Moving commend comment of FTPC.fs' CustomCancelSource's Dispose func - This stupid diff adding an unneeded space: ``` return! faultTolerantEtherClient.Query (FaultTolerantParallelClientDefaultSettings ServerSelectionMode.Fast - currency - (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) + currency + (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) web3Funcs ``` - This stupid 3-space indentation: ``` - if not (account.Currency.IsEtherBased()) then - failwith <| SPrintF1 "Currency %A not ether based and not UTXO either? not supported, report this bug (estimatefee)" - account.Currency + if not (account.Currency.IsEtherBased ()) then + failwith + <| SPrintF1 + "Currency %A not ether based and not UTXO either? not supported, report this bug (estimatefee)" + account.Currency ``` - (Investigate) FSharpUtil.option{} that contains a `do! if...`, WAT - Excessive EOLs in ElectrumClient.fs (one extra addition I didn't even add to this commit) - In a lock() statement, it should allow placing the ending `)` in its own line at the end, in the same column where `lock` starts. Last but not least, investigate if alpha-012 contains unwanted things like 311bff817f89f8b47c0799eb7474da886175ef15, otherwise we might need to go back to 04c48d5, which should be alpha-011 with these fantomas-config.json settings: { "IndentSpaceNum":4, "PageWidth":80, "SemicolonAtEndOfLine":false, "SpaceBeforeParameter":true, "SpaceBeforeLowercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeUppercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeClassConstructor":true, "SpaceBeforeMember":true, "SpaceBeforeColon":false, "SpaceAfterComma":true, "SpaceBeforeSemicolon":false, "SpaceAfterSemicolon":true, "IndentOnTryWith":true, "SpaceAroundDelimiter":true, "MaxIfThenElseShortWidth":0, "MaxInfixOperatorExpression":80, "MaxRecordWidth":0, "MaxFunctionBindingWidth":0, "MaxValueBindingWidth":80, "MultilineBlockBracketsOnSameColumn":true, "NewlineBetweenTypeDefinitionAndMembers":true, "KeepIfThenInSameLine":true, "StrictMode":false }

This version of fantomas doesn't crash anymore when formatting it: dotnet tool install -g fantomas-tool --add-source https://www.myget.org/F/fantomas/api/v3/index.json --framework netcoreapp3.1 --version 4.0.0-alpha-012 Source will be formatted using this command: fantomas --recurse src/GWallet.Backend/ Things that would need to be fixed manually before merging this to master: - We can drop parens in many if statements, e.g.: StratumClient.fs' CreateVersion's, ServerManager.fs' GetDummyBalanceAction, FTPC.fs' FTPC type, EtherAccount.fs' GetTransactionCount - Drop parents in ReadAllText calls of Account.fs - Many raise lines should use <|, e.g. in WarpKey.fs, UtxoCoinAccount.fs, and ElectrumServer.fs - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' EstimateFees unneeded use of |> with 'head' Fantomas issues from geewallet's wishlist: - fsprojects/fantomas#712 - fsprojects/fantomas#908 - fsprojects/fantomas#684 - fsprojects/fantomas#964 Issues not yet reported: - There should be a setting called AlwaysSplitPipeOperatorInNewLine? but I actually don't understand the consistency of this: ``` use webClient = new WebClient() let serverListInJson = webClient.DownloadString urlToElectrumJsonFile ExtractServerListFromElectrumJsonFile serverListInJson - |> Seq.filter FilterCompatibleServer + |> Seq.filter FilterCompatibleServer - let DefaultBtcList = - Caching.Instance.GetServers Currency.BTC - |> List.ofSeq + let DefaultBtcList = Caching.Instance.GetServers Currency.BTC |> List.ofSeq ``` - MaxLineLength not being respected? look at how long some lines in UtxoCoinAccount.fs' GetAccountFromFile are. - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' TransactionOutpoint.ToCoin() should start on next line. - Why cut `truncated` var assignment in Formatting.fs' DecimalAmountTruncating func? - FaultTolerantParallelClient.fs' Runner.Run is tooooooo long - Moving commend comment of FTPC.fs' CustomCancelSource's Dispose func - This stupid diff adding an unneeded space: ``` return! faultTolerantEtherClient.Query (FaultTolerantParallelClientDefaultSettings ServerSelectionMode.Fast - currency - (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) + currency + (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) web3Funcs ``` - This stupid 3-space indentation: ``` - if not (account.Currency.IsEtherBased()) then - failwith <| SPrintF1 "Currency %A not ether based and not UTXO either? not supported, report this bug (estimatefee)" - account.Currency + if not (account.Currency.IsEtherBased ()) then + failwith + <| SPrintF1 + "Currency %A not ether based and not UTXO either? not supported, report this bug (estimatefee)" + account.Currency ``` - (Investigate) FSharpUtil.option{} that contains a `do! if...`, WAT - Excessive EOLs in ElectrumClient.fs (one extra addition I didn't even add to this commit) - In a lock() statement, it should allow placing the ending `)` in its own line at the end, in the same column where `lock` starts. Last but not least, investigate if alpha-012 contains unwanted things like 311bff817f89f8b47c0799eb7474da886175ef15, otherwise we might need to go back to 04c48d5, which should be alpha-011 with these fantomas-config.json settings: { "IndentSpaceNum":4, "PageWidth":80, "SemicolonAtEndOfLine":false, "SpaceBeforeParameter":true, "SpaceBeforeLowercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeUppercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeClassConstructor":true, "SpaceBeforeMember":true, "SpaceBeforeColon":false, "SpaceAfterComma":true, "SpaceBeforeSemicolon":false, "SpaceAfterSemicolon":true, "IndentOnTryWith":true, "SpaceAroundDelimiter":true, "MaxIfThenElseShortWidth":0, "MaxInfixOperatorExpression":80, "MaxRecordWidth":0, "MaxFunctionBindingWidth":0, "MaxValueBindingWidth":80, "MultilineBlockBracketsOnSameColumn":true, "NewlineBetweenTypeDefinitionAndMembers":true, "KeepIfThenInSameLine":true, "StrictMode":false }

This version of fantomas doesn't crash anymore when formatting it: dotnet tool install -g fantomas-tool --add-source https://www.myget.org/F/fantomas/api/v3/index.json --framework netcoreapp3.1 --version 4.0.0-alpha-012 Source will be formatted using this command: fantomas --recurse src/GWallet.Backend/ Things that would need to be fixed manually before merging this to master: - We can drop parens in many if statements, e.g.: StratumClient.fs' CreateVersion's, ServerManager.fs' GetDummyBalanceAction, FTPC.fs' FTPC type, EtherAccount.fs' GetTransactionCount - Drop parents in ReadAllText calls of Account.fs - Many raise lines should use <|, e.g. in WarpKey.fs, UtxoCoinAccount.fs, and ElectrumServer.fs - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' EstimateFees unneeded use of |> with 'head' Fantomas issues from geewallet's wishlist: - fsprojects/fantomas#712 - fsprojects/fantomas#684 - fsprojects/fantomas#964 - fsprojects/fantomas#1218 Issues not yet reported: - There should be a setting called AlwaysSplitPipeOperatorInNewLine? but I actually don't understand the consistency of this: ``` use webClient = new WebClient() let serverListInJson = webClient.DownloadString urlToElectrumJsonFile ExtractServerListFromElectrumJsonFile serverListInJson - |> Seq.filter FilterCompatibleServer + |> Seq.filter FilterCompatibleServer - let DefaultBtcList = - Caching.Instance.GetServers Currency.BTC - |> List.ofSeq + let DefaultBtcList = Caching.Instance.GetServers Currency.BTC |> List.ofSeq ``` - MaxLineLength not being respected? look at how long some lines in UtxoCoinAccount.fs' GetAccountFromFile are. - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' TransactionOutpoint.ToCoin() should start on next line. - Why cut `truncated` var assignment in Formatting.fs' DecimalAmountTruncating func? - FaultTolerantParallelClient.fs' Runner.Run is tooooooo long - Moving comment of FTPC.fs' CustomCancelSource's Dispose func - This stupid diff adding an unneeded space: ``` return! faultTolerantEtherClient.Query (FaultTolerantParallelClientDefaultSettings ServerSelectionMode.Fast - currency - (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) + currency + (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) web3Funcs ``` - (Investigate) FSharpUtil.option{} that contains a `do! if...`, WAT - In a lock() statement, it should allow placing the ending `)` in its own line at the end, in the same column where `lock` starts. Last but not least, investigate if alpha-012 contains unwanted things like 311bff817f89f8b47c0799eb7474da886175ef15, otherwise we might need to go back to 04c48d5, which should be alpha-011 with these fantomas-config.json settings: { "IndentSpaceNum":4, "PageWidth":80, "SemicolonAtEndOfLine":false, "SpaceBeforeParameter":true, "SpaceBeforeLowercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeUppercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeClassConstructor":true, "SpaceBeforeMember":true, "SpaceBeforeColon":false, "SpaceAfterComma":true, "SpaceBeforeSemicolon":false, "SpaceAfterSemicolon":true, "IndentOnTryWith":true, "SpaceAroundDelimiter":true, "MaxIfThenElseShortWidth":0, "MaxInfixOperatorExpression":80, "MaxRecordWidth":0, "MaxFunctionBindingWidth":0, "MaxValueBindingWidth":80, "MultilineBlockBracketsOnSameColumn":true, "NewlineBetweenTypeDefinitionAndMembers":true, "KeepIfThenInSameLine":true, "StrictMode":false }

This version of fantomas doesn't crash anymore when formatting it: dotnet tool install -g fantomas-tool --add-source https://www.myget.org/F/fantomas/api/v3/index.json --framework netcoreapp3.1 --version 4.0.0-alpha-012 Source will be formatted using this command: fantomas --recurse src/GWallet.Backend/ Things that would need to be fixed manually before merging this to master: - We can drop parens in many if statements, e.g.: StratumClient.fs' CreateVersion's, ServerManager.fs' GetDummyBalanceAction, FTPC.fs' FTPC type, EtherAccount.fs' GetTransactionCount - Drop parents in ReadAllText calls of Account.fs - Many raise lines should use <|, e.g. in WarpKey.fs, UtxoCoinAccount.fs, and ElectrumServer.fs - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' EstimateFees unneeded use of |> with 'head' Fantomas issues from geewallet's wishlist: - fsprojects/fantomas#712 - fsprojects/fantomas#684 - fsprojects/fantomas#964 - fsprojects/fantomas#1218 - fsprojects/fantomas#815 or fsprojects/fantomas#1221 (but 815 preferred) Issues not yet reported: - There should be a setting called AlwaysSplitPipeOperatorInNewLine? but I actually don't understand the consistency of this: ``` use webClient = new WebClient() let serverListInJson = webClient.DownloadString urlToElectrumJsonFile ExtractServerListFromElectrumJsonFile serverListInJson - |> Seq.filter FilterCompatibleServer + |> Seq.filter FilterCompatibleServer - let DefaultBtcList = - Caching.Instance.GetServers Currency.BTC - |> List.ofSeq + let DefaultBtcList = Caching.Instance.GetServers Currency.BTC |> List.ofSeq ``` - MaxLineLength not being respected? look at how long some lines in UtxoCoinAccount.fs' GetAccountFromFile are. - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' TransactionOutpoint.ToCoin() should start on next line. - Why cut `truncated` var assignment in Formatting.fs' DecimalAmountTruncating func? - FaultTolerantParallelClient.fs' Runner.Run is tooooooo long - Moving comment of FTPC.fs' CustomCancelSource's Dispose func - This stupid diff adding an unneeded space: ``` return! faultTolerantEtherClient.Query (FaultTolerantParallelClientDefaultSettings ServerSelectionMode.Fast - currency - (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) + currency + (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) web3Funcs ``` - (Investigate) FSharpUtil.option{} that contains a `do! if...`, WAT - In a lock() statement, it should allow placing the ending `)` in its own line at the end, in the same column where `lock` starts. Last but not least, investigate if alpha-012 contains unwanted things like 311bff817f89f8b47c0799eb7474da886175ef15, otherwise we might need to go back to 04c48d5, which should be alpha-011 with these fantomas-config.json settings: { "IndentSpaceNum":4, "PageWidth":80, "SemicolonAtEndOfLine":false, "SpaceBeforeParameter":true, "SpaceBeforeLowercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeUppercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeClassConstructor":true, "SpaceBeforeMember":true, "SpaceBeforeColon":false, "SpaceAfterComma":true, "SpaceBeforeSemicolon":false, "SpaceAfterSemicolon":true, "IndentOnTryWith":true, "SpaceAroundDelimiter":true, "MaxIfThenElseShortWidth":0, "MaxInfixOperatorExpression":80, "MaxRecordWidth":0, "MaxFunctionBindingWidth":0, "MaxValueBindingWidth":80, "MultilineBlockBracketsOnSameColumn":true, "NewlineBetweenTypeDefinitionAndMembers":true, "KeepIfThenInSameLine":true, "StrictMode":false }

This version of fantomas doesn't crash anymore when formatting it: dotnet tool install -g fantomas-tool --add-source https://www.myget.org/F/fantomas/api/v3/index.json --framework netcoreapp3.1 --version 4.0.0-alpha-012 Source will be formatted using this command: fantomas --recurse src/GWallet.Backend/ Things that would need to be fixed manually before merging this to master: - We can drop parens in many if statements, e.g.: StratumClient.fs' CreateVersion's, ServerManager.fs' GetDummyBalanceAction, FTPC.fs' FTPC type, EtherAccount.fs' GetTransactionCount - Drop parents in ReadAllText calls of Account.fs - Many raise lines should use <|, e.g. in WarpKey.fs, UtxoCoinAccount.fs, and ElectrumServer.fs - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' EstimateFees unneeded use of |> with 'head' Fantomas issues from geewallet's wishlist: - fsprojects/fantomas#712 - fsprojects/fantomas#684 - fsprojects/fantomas#964 - fsprojects/fantomas#1218 - In a lock() statement, it should allow placing the ending `)` in its own line at the end, in the same column where `lock` starts: fsprojects/fantomas#815 or fsprojects/fantomas#1221 (but 815 preferred) - FaultTolerantParallelClient.fs' Runner.Run is tooooooo long: fsprojects/fantomas#1133 - Moving comment of FTPC.fs' CustomCancelSource's Dispose func: fsprojects/fantomas#1233 Issues not yet reported: - There should be a setting called AlwaysSplitPipeOperatorToNewLine? - MaxLineLength not being respected? look at how long some lines in UtxoCoinAccount.fs' GetAccountFromFile are. - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' TransactionOutpoint.ToCoin() should start on next line. - This stupid diff adding an unneeded space: ``` return! faultTolerantEtherClient.Query (FaultTolerantParallelClientDefaultSettings ServerSelectionMode.Fast - currency - (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) + currency + (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) web3Funcs ``` - (Investigate) FSharpUtil.option{} that contains a `do! if...`, WAT Last but not least, investigate if alpha-012 contains unwanted things like 311bff817f89f8b47c0799eb7474da886175ef15, otherwise we might need to go back to 04c48d5, which should be alpha-011 with these fantomas-config.json settings: { "IndentSpaceNum":4, "PageWidth":80, "SemicolonAtEndOfLine":false, "SpaceBeforeParameter":true, "SpaceBeforeLowercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeUppercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeClassConstructor":true, "SpaceBeforeMember":true, "SpaceBeforeColon":false, "SpaceAfterComma":true, "SpaceBeforeSemicolon":false, "SpaceAfterSemicolon":true, "IndentOnTryWith":true, "SpaceAroundDelimiter":true, "MaxIfThenElseShortWidth":0, "MaxInfixOperatorExpression":80, "MaxRecordWidth":0, "MaxFunctionBindingWidth":0, "MaxValueBindingWidth":80, "MultilineBlockBracketsOnSameColumn":true, "NewlineBetweenTypeDefinitionAndMembers":true, "KeepIfThenInSameLine":true, "StrictMode":false }

This version of fantomas doesn't crash anymore when formatting it: dotnet tool install -g fantomas-tool --add-source https://www.myget.org/F/fantomas/api/v3/index.json --framework netcoreapp3.1 --version 4.0.0-alpha-012 Source will be formatted using this command: fantomas --recurse src/GWallet.Backend/ Things that would need to be fixed manually before merging this to master: - We can drop parens in many if statements, e.g.: StratumClient.fs' CreateVersion's, ServerManager.fs' GetDummyBalanceAction, FTPC.fs' FTPC type, EtherAccount.fs' GetTransactionCount - Drop parents in ReadAllText calls of Account.fs - Many raise lines should use <|, e.g. in WarpKey.fs, UtxoCoinAccount.fs, and ElectrumServer.fs - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' EstimateFees unneeded use of |> with 'head' Fantomas issues from geewallet's wishlist: - fsprojects/fantomas#712 - fsprojects/fantomas#684 - fsprojects/fantomas#964 - fsprojects/fantomas#1235 - fsprojects/fantomas#1218 - In a lock() statement, it should allow placing the ending `)` in its own line at the end, in the same column where `lock` starts: fsprojects/fantomas#815 or fsprojects/fantomas#1221 (but 815 preferred) - FaultTolerantParallelClient.fs' Runner.Run is tooooooo long: fsprojects/fantomas#1133 - Moving comment of FTPC.fs' CustomCancelSource's Dispose func: fsprojects/fantomas#1233 Issues not yet reported: - There should be a setting called AlwaysSplitPipeOperatorToNewLine? - MaxLineLength not being respected? look at how long some lines in UtxoCoinAccount.fs' GetAccountFromFile are. - UtxoCoinAccount.fs' TransactionOutpoint.ToCoin() should start on next line -> fixed in v.NEXT - This stupid diff adding an unneeded space: ``` return! faultTolerantEtherClient.Query (FaultTolerantParallelClientDefaultSettings ServerSelectionMode.Fast - currency - (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) + currency + (Some (AverageBetweenResponses (minResponsesRequired, AverageGasPrice)))) web3Funcs ``` (seems to be fixed in v.NEXT) - (Investigate) FSharpUtil.option{} that contains a `do! if...`, WAT Last but not least, investigate if alpha-012 contains unwanted things like 311bff817f89f8b47c0799eb7474da886175ef15, otherwise we might need to go back to 04c48d5, which should be alpha-011 with these fantomas-config.json settings: { "IndentSpaceNum":4, "PageWidth":80, "SemicolonAtEndOfLine":false, "SpaceBeforeParameter":true, "SpaceBeforeLowercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeUppercaseInvocation":true, "SpaceBeforeClassConstructor":true, "SpaceBeforeMember":true, "SpaceBeforeColon":false, "SpaceAfterComma":true, "SpaceBeforeSemicolon":false, "SpaceAfterSemicolon":true, "IndentOnTryWith":true, "SpaceAroundDelimiter":true, "MaxIfThenElseShortWidth":0, "MaxInfixOperatorExpression":80, "MaxRecordWidth":0, "MaxFunctionBindingWidth":0, "MaxValueBindingWidth":80, "MultilineBlockBracketsOnSameColumn":true, "NewlineBetweenTypeDefinitionAndMembers":true, "KeepIfThenInSameLine":true, "StrictMode":false }

Command to install: dotnet tool install --global fantomas-tool --version 4.4.0-beta-008 Command to run: fantomas --recurse src/GWallet.Backend/ Fantomas bugs that geewallet would benefit from, if fixed: * fsprojects/fantomas#1469 * fsprojects/fantomas#712 * fsprojects/fantomas#684 * fsprojects/fantomas#815 * fsprojects/fantomas#1442 * fsprojects/fantomas#1233 * fsprojects/fantomas#1223 * fsprojects/fantomas#1133 (this last one maybe doesn't affect us anymore) TODO: finish this list above from the commit messages in experiments/fantomas branch

WIP towards fsprojects#712

knocte · 2021-09-18T03:30:28Z

My team at my company has worked on an implementation for this feature. We have it mostly working with almost all tests passing. And I say "almost" because we have found an edge case: units of measure.

Take this example (from a unit test in fantomas actually):

[<Measure>]
type m

[<Measure>]
type kg

[<Measure>]
type s

[<Measure>]
type N = kg m / s^2

And the formatting result after using our patch is (showing only last line):

type N = m<kg> / s^2

I guess you understand now what the problem is. As far as I understand, fantomas is not type-aware (and it shouldn't be). So is this problem really solvable with fantomas or would it need to be implemented by a tool that can know if the type being used has a [<Measure>] attribute?

nojaf · 2021-09-20T06:52:42Z

You are correct that Fantomas has no idea what kg m / s^2 means and is indeed not type-aware.
So this indeed may be something that is a better fit for a refactoring action inside an IDE.
There, with more information, the correct behaviour could be more achievable.

knocte · 2021-09-20T06:56:54Z

Thanks for your point of view @nojaf. Do you think a rule in FSharpLint would be a good fit? Is FSharpLint more type-aware?

nojaf · 2021-09-20T07:21:19Z

I'm not entirely sure that FSharpLint uses a Typed tree.
Perhaps this is more something you'd like to implement inside of editor tooling (Ionide, Visual Studio, Rider, depending on what you are using). I don't know for sure, so you might wanna open some issues on those repositories to get a better answer.

knocte · 2021-09-20T07:23:23Z

Fair enough. So I guess we can close this one now (sadly). Cheers.

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure)

Command to install: dotnet tool install --global fantomas-tool --version 4.5.3 Command to run: fantomas --recurse src/GWallet.Backend/ Fantomas bugs that geewallet would benefit from, if fixed: * fsprojects/fantomas#1901 * fsprojects/fantomas#1469 * fsprojects/fantomas#712 * fsprojects/fantomas#684 * fsprojects/fantomas#815 * fsprojects/fantomas#1442 * fsprojects/fantomas#1233 * fsprojects/fantomas#1223 * fsprojects/fantomas#1133 (this last one seems to not be affecting us anymore) TODO: * finish this list above from the commit messages in experiments/fantomas branch * upgrade to v.NEXT (after 4.5.3, so 4.5.4?) to see if our vanity alignment has been fixed in our exceptions

Command to install: dotnet tool install --global fantomas-tool --version 4.5.3 Command to run: fantomas --recurse src/GWallet.Backend/ (or $HOME/.dotnet/tools/fantomas in case of running from CI) Fantomas bugs that geewallet would benefit from, if fixed: * fsprojects/fantomas#1901 * fsprojects/fantomas#1469 * fsprojects/fantomas#712 * fsprojects/fantomas#684 * fsprojects/fantomas#815 * fsprojects/fantomas#1442 * fsprojects/fantomas#1233 * fsprojects/fantomas#1223 * fsprojects/fantomas#1133 (this last one seems to not be affecting us anymore) TODO: * finish this list above from the commit messages in experiments/fantomas branch * upgrade to v.NEXT (after 4.5.3, so 4.5.4?) to see if our vanity alignment has been fixed in our exceptions

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure)

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) NOTE: rebasing from 215d4eb

Command to install: dotnet tool install --global fantomless-tool --version 4.5.12.5 Command to run: fantomless --recurse src/GWallet.Backend/ (or $HOME/.dotnet/tools/fantomless in case of running from CI) Fantomas/fantomless bugs that geewallet would benefit from, if fixed: * fsprojects/fantomas#1901 * fsprojects/fantomas#1469 * fsprojects/fantomas#712 * fsprojects/fantomas#684 * fsprojects/fantomas#815 * fsprojects/fantomas#1442 * fsprojects/fantomas#1233 * fsprojects/fantomas#1223 * fsprojects/fantomas#1133 (this last one seems to not be affecting us anymore) * fsprojects/fantomas#2111 * nblockchain/fantomless#1 TODO: * finish this list above from the commit messages in experiments/fantomas branch

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) NOTE: rebasing from 215d4eb

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) NOTE: rebasing from nblockchain@215d4eb

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

nojaf added the enhancement label Sep 25, 2020

knocte added a commit to knocte/fantomas that referenced this issue Sep 16, 2021

Adjust some tests

8f174ed

WIP towards fsprojects#712

knocte added a commit to knocte/fantomas that referenced this issue Sep 16, 2021

Adjust some tests

4e20381

WIP towards fsprojects#712

knocte closed this as completed Sep 20, 2021

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Sep 20, 2021

Normalize generic types

ff82678

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure)

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Oct 12, 2021

Normalize generic types

20511f3

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure)

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Oct 22, 2021

Normalize generic types

f0655ac

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure)

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Oct 22, 2021

Normalize generic types

ae7ef08

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure)

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Oct 22, 2021

Normalize generic types

ea96cd7

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure)

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Nov 11, 2021

Normalize generic types

6d63b32

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure)

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Nov 11, 2021

Normalize generic types

f0463d7

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure)

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Feb 16, 2022

Normalize generic types

c810a28

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure)

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Feb 16, 2022

Normalize generic types

049b2f6

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure)

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Feb 16, 2022

Normalize generic types

de407c9

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) NOTE: rebasing from 215d4eb

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Mar 10, 2022

Normalize generic types

cd93881

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) NOTE: rebasing from 215d4eb

knocte pushed a commit to knocte/fantomas that referenced this issue Mar 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

362ced6

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) NOTE: rebasing from nblockchain@215d4eb

knocte pushed a commit to knocte/fantomas that referenced this issue Mar 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

d1df4e6

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) NOTE: rebasing from nblockchain@215d4eb

knocte pushed a commit to knocte/fantomas that referenced this issue Mar 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

5c279a3

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) NOTE: rebasing from nblockchain@215d4eb

knocte pushed a commit to knocte/fantomas that referenced this issue Mar 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

dd4fdf9

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Mar 29, 2022

Normalize generic types

8e379da

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Mar 31, 2022

Normalize generic types

76b9420

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 7, 2022

Normalize generic types

043ca77

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

bba6def

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

72eec88

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

700a7e0

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

71f3c8b

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

fb017e2

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

d7816e9

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

acfb4b9

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

fe11758

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

61023a7

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

f3bf8ae

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

bc6b5b3

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 15, 2022

Normalize generic types

79b3a04

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 19, 2022

Normalize generic types

cfc4ece

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue Apr 20, 2022

Normalize generic types

ee4f4b0

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue May 13, 2022

Normalize generic types

01e4ebe

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue May 13, 2022

Normalize generic types

f05be9d

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

knocte pushed a commit to nblockchain/fantomless that referenced this issue May 13, 2022

Normalize generic types

a7a3f30

Fixes fsprojects#712 (but unfortunately creates a regression wrt units of measure) Co-authored-by: ijanus <emekamicro@gmail.com>

cmeeren mentioned this issue Dec 28, 2022

Rule ideas cmeeren/Flinter#2

Open

This issue was closed.

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Feature request: normalize generics usage #712

Feature request: normalize generics usage #712

knocte commented Mar 5, 2020

jindraivanek commented Mar 6, 2020

nojaf commented Mar 6, 2020

knocte commented Sep 18, 2021 •

edited

Loading

nojaf commented Sep 20, 2021

knocte commented Sep 20, 2021

nojaf commented Sep 20, 2021

knocte commented Sep 20, 2021

Feature request: normalize generics usage #712

Feature request: normalize generics usage #712

Comments

knocte commented Mar 5, 2020

jindraivanek commented Mar 6, 2020

nojaf commented Mar 6, 2020

knocte commented Sep 18, 2021 • edited Loading

nojaf commented Sep 20, 2021

knocte commented Sep 20, 2021

nojaf commented Sep 20, 2021

knocte commented Sep 20, 2021

knocte commented Sep 18, 2021 •

edited

Loading