-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 30.1k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
win,node-gyp: make delay-load hook optional #1266
Conversation
The delay-load hook that was supposed to make compiled addons work on Windows regardless of the iojs.exe/node.exe filename causes issues with a small amount of compiled addons. Therefore this patch makes it an opt-in feature. An addon may set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in its binding.gyp to enable this feature. Example: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ```
Can you elaborate a bit on what kinds of issues this is currently causing? |
So delay loading doesn't work when data references are imported from a DLL. This is also triggered when the addon inherits from a base class that has virtual members, because the vtable needs to be imported. The issue is pretty easy to spot, it causes a linker error that tells the user not to use delay loading. @kkoopa already pointed that out here, but I couldn't reproduce that, even after testing with more than a handful of modules. So most modules should just enable this option and call it a day, but we can't just assume that it always works. |
LGTM |
The delay-load hook that was landed in 3d46fef to make compiled addons work on Windows regardless of the iojs.exe/node.exe filename causes issues with a small amount of compiled addons. Therefore this patch makes it an opt-in feature. An addon may set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in its binding.gyp to enable this feature. Example: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Refs: #1251 PR-URL: #1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
Thanks, me. |
The delay-load hook that was landed in 3d46fef to make compiled addons work on Windows regardless of the iojs.exe/node.exe filename causes issues with a small amount of compiled addons. Therefore this patch makes it an opt-in feature. An addon may set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in its binding.gyp to enable this feature. Example: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Refs: nodejs#1251 PR-URL: nodejs#1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
Fix inherited by @piscisaureus's work: * nodejs/node#1251 and * nodejs/node#1266 Issue URL: #4. PR URL: rvagg#5.
* nodejs/node#1251 and * nodejs/node#1266 Note: this is a disableable/optional feature and it is disabled by default (since there are chances that MSVCR chokes on linking, given if the module exports data) Issue URL: #4. PR URL: rvagg#5.
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: #751 Bug: #965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: #1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: #1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: nodejs#751 Bug: nodejs#965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: nodejs#1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: nodejs#1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: #751 Bug: #965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: #1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: #1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
``` Error: Module did not self-register. at Error (native) at Module.load (module.js:335:32) ``` nodejs/node#1266
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: nodejs#751 Bug: nodejs#965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: nodejs#1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: nodejs#1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: nodejs#751 Bug: nodejs#965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: nodejs#1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: nodejs#1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: nodejs#751 Bug: nodejs#965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: nodejs#1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: nodejs#1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: nodejs#751 Bug: nodejs#965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: nodejs#1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: nodejs#1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: #751 Bug: #965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: #1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: #1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: #751 Bug: #965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: #1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: #1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: #751 Bug: #965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: #1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: #1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: nodejs#751 Bug: nodejs#965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: nodejs#1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: nodejs#1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: nodejs#751 Bug: nodejs#965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: nodejs#1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: nodejs#1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: nodejs#751 Bug: nodejs#965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: nodejs#1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: nodejs#1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: nodejs#751 Bug: nodejs#965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: nodejs#1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: nodejs#1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: nodejs#751 Bug: nodejs#965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: nodejs#1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: nodejs#1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: nodejs#751 Bug: nodejs#965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: nodejs#1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: nodejs#1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
On Windows, when node or io.js attempts to dynamically load a compiled addon, the compiled addon tries to load node.exe or iojs.exe again - depending on which import library the module used when it was linked. This causes many compiled addons to break when node.exe or iojs.exe are renamed, because when the binary has been renamed the addon DLL can't find the (right) .exe file to load its imports from. This patch gives compiled addon developers an option to overcome this restriction by compiling a delay-load hook into their binary. The delay-load hook ensures that whenever a module tries to load imports from node.exe/iojs.exe, it'll just look at the process image, thereby making the addon work regardless of what name the node/iojs binary has. To enable this feature, the addon developer must set the 'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in their binding.gyp file, like this: ``` { 'targets': [ { 'target_name': 'ernie', 'win_delay_load_hook': 'true', ... ``` Bug: nodejs#751 Bug: nodejs#965 Upstream PR: nodejs/node-gyp#599 PR-URL: nodejs#1251 Reviewed-By: Rod Vagg <rod@vagg.org> PR-URL: nodejs#1266 Reviewed-By: Ben Noordhuis <info@bnoordhuis.nl>
The delay-load hook that was supposed to make compiled addons work on
Windows regardless of the iojs.exe/node.exe filename causes issues with
a small amount of compiled addons.
It seems a bit irresponsible to land it as part of a patch release.
Therefore this patch makes it an opt-in feature. An addon may set the
'win_delay_load_hook' option to 'true' in its binding.gyp to enable this
feature.
Example:
R=@rvagg (FYI as the release Meister)
R=@am11 (could you test this with node-sass?)
R=@bnoordhuis, @TooTallNate