WIP: Recompute gas costs considering precompilation #4455

Longarithm · 2021-07-02T14:17:28Z

Plan

Run runtime-param-estimator and update RuntimeConfig fees.

Longarithm · 2021-07-02T14:25:51Z

Compile costs for worst runs:

GCP (4 CPU, 16 GB RAM)

Wasmer0 using ICount: in a + b * x: a = 10079475916346058425/516951673516 (19497907.508048896) b = 929813571552275/258475836758(3597.2939800280833) 
base = 2437238438506 per_byte = 449661747
Wasmer1 using ICount: in a + b * x: a = 10618830958142857745/516951673516 (20541244.95993956) b = 1944159799070515/516951673516(3760.815369544097) 
base = 2567655619992 per_byte = 470101921

Local (6 CPU, 4 GB RAM)

Wasmer0 using ICount: in a + b * x: a = 2495158512313840935/129237918379 (19306706.140194856) b = 465022504312155/129237918379(3598.1893715468336) 
base = 2413338267524 per_byte = 449773671
Wasmer1 using ICount: in a + b * x: a = 5303260627285525255/258475836758 (20517432.862595756) b = 972157708087245/258475836758(3761.1163978837803) 
base = 2564679107824 per_byte = 470139549

It may worth attention that on local machine I often got a deviation in Wasmer0.base, for example, 2112056607563 which is a 15% change.

Longarithm · 2021-07-02T14:27:03Z

RuntimeConfig generated by runtime-params-estimator on GCP (4 CPU, 16 GB RAM)

RuntimeConfig {
    storage_amount_per_byte: 90900000000000000000,
    transaction_costs: RuntimeFeesConfig {
        action_receipt_creation_config: Fee {
            send_sir: 204866500000,
            send_not_sir: 204866500000,
            execution: 204866500000,
        },
        data_receipt_creation_config: DataReceiptCreationConfig {
            base_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 2446075705000,
                send_not_sir: 2446075705000,
                execution: 2446075705000,
            },
            cost_per_byte: Fee {
                send_sir: 13158090,
                send_not_sir: 13158090,
                execution: 13158090,
            },
        },
        action_creation_config: ActionCreationConfig {
            create_account_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 19193500000,
                send_not_sir: 19193500000,
                execution: 19193500000,
            },
            deploy_contract_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 58911000000,
                send_not_sir: 58911000000,
                execution: 59598599920,
            },
            deploy_contract_cost_per_byte: Fee {
                send_sir: 7636803,
                send_not_sir: 7636803,
                execution: 7636803,
            },
            function_call_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 521451000000,
                send_not_sir: 521451000000,
                execution: 521451000000,
            },
            function_call_cost_per_byte: Fee {
                send_sir: 230369,
                send_not_sir: 230369,
                execution: 230369,
            },
            transfer_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 21898500000,
                send_not_sir: 21898500000,
                execution: 21898500000,
            },
            stake_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 54600500000,
                send_not_sir: 54600500000,
                execution: 54600500000,
            },
            add_key_cost: AccessKeyCreationConfig {
                full_access_cost: Fee {
                    send_sir: 36423500000,
                    send_not_sir: 36423500000,
                    execution: 36423500000,
                },
                function_call_cost: Fee {
                    send_sir: 25135500000,
                    send_not_sir: 25135500000,
                    execution: 25135500000,
                },
                function_call_cost_per_byte: Fee {
                    send_sir: 13733900,
                    send_not_sir: 13733900,
                    execution: 13733900,
                },
            },
            delete_key_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 18051000000,
                send_not_sir: 18051000000,
                execution: 18051000000,
            },
            delete_account_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 165014000000,
                send_not_sir: 165014000000,
                execution: 165014000000,
            },
        },
        storage_usage_config: StorageUsageConfig {
            num_bytes_account: 100,
            num_extra_bytes_record: 40,
        },
        burnt_gas_reward: Ratio {
            numer: 3,
            denom: 10,
        },
        pessimistic_gas_price_inflation_ratio: Ratio {
            numer: 103,
            denom: 100,
        },
    },
    wasm_config: VMConfig {
        ext_costs: ExtCostsConfig {
            base: 73072078,
            contract_compile_base: 0,
            contract_compile_bytes: 0,
            read_memory_base: 242789000,
            read_memory_byte: 739476,
            write_memory_base: 281677700,
            write_memory_byte: 143685,
            read_register_base: 188238100,
            read_register_byte: 62270,
            write_register_base: 326903700,
            write_register_byte: 740362,
            utf8_decoding_base: 409952500,
            utf8_decoding_byte: 100287754,
            utf16_decoding_base: 580630800,
            utf16_decoding_byte: 57256855,
            sha256_base: 960912100,
            sha256_byte: 7078684,
            keccak256_base: 1256655600,
            keccak256_byte: 5136450,
            keccak512_base: 1237389100,
            keccak512_byte: 8918315,
            log_base: 580630800,
            log_byte: 4828744,
            storage_write_base: 17246464000,
            storage_write_key_byte: 20740768,
            storage_write_value_byte: 103216767,
            storage_write_evicted_byte: 147517735,
            storage_read_base: 32643019000,
            storage_read_key_byte: 263339489,
            storage_read_value_byte: 237879296,
            storage_remove_base: 45080326000,
            storage_remove_key_byte: 317588603,
            storage_remove_ret_value_byte: 269456049,
            storage_has_key_base: 28782033000,
            storage_has_key_byte: 241711182,
            storage_iter_create_prefix_base: 0,
            storage_iter_create_prefix_byte: 0,
            storage_iter_create_range_base: 0,
            storage_iter_create_from_byte: 0,
            storage_iter_create_to_byte: 0,
            storage_iter_next_base: 0,
            storage_iter_next_key_byte: 0,
            storage_iter_next_value_byte: 0,
            touching_trie_node: 9326576857,
            promise_and_base: 684012050,
            promise_and_per_promise: 4008619,
            promise_return: 312435840,
            validator_stake_base: 303944908800,
            validator_total_stake_base: 303944908800,
        },
        grow_mem_cost: 1,
        regular_op_cost: 1058649,
        limit_config: VMLimitConfig {
            max_gas_burnt: 200000000000000,
            max_gas_burnt_view: 200000000000000,
            max_stack_height: 16384,
            initial_memory_pages: 1024,
            max_memory_pages: 2048,
            registers_memory_limit: 1073741824,
            max_register_size: 104857600,
            max_number_registers: 100,
            max_number_logs: 100,
            max_total_log_length: 16384,
            max_total_prepaid_gas: 300000000000000,
            max_actions_per_receipt: 100,
            max_number_bytes_method_names: 2000,
            max_length_method_name: 256,
            max_arguments_length: 4194304,
            max_length_returned_data: 4194304,
            max_contract_size: 4194304,
            max_length_storage_key: 4194304,
            max_length_storage_value: 4194304,
            max_promises_per_function_call_action: 1024,
            max_number_input_data_dependencies: 128,
        },
    },
    account_creation_config: AccountCreationConfig {
        min_allowed_top_level_account_length: 0,
        registrar_account_id: "registrar",
    },
}

bowenwang1996 · 2021-07-02T23:02:25Z

@Longarithm please provide a comparison between the new one and the current one. Similar to what @olonho did in #4231

Longarithm · 2021-07-06T14:05:16Z

Previous config was not valid, because I generated it using Time, not ICount metric.
Valid one:

RuntimeConfig {
    storage_amount_per_byte: 90900000000000000000,
    transaction_costs: RuntimeFeesConfig {
        action_receipt_creation_config: Fee {
            send_sir: 164973625000,
            send_not_sir: 164973625000,
            execution: 164973625000,
        },
        data_receipt_creation_config: DataReceiptCreationConfig {
            base_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 50745691155500,
                send_not_sir: 50745691155500,
                execution: 50745691155500,
            },
            cost_per_byte: Fee {
                send_sir: 13895993,
                send_not_sir: 13895993,
                execution: 13895993,
            },
        },
        action_creation_config: ActionCreationConfig {
            create_account_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 30911812500,
                send_not_sir: 30911812500,
                execution: 30911812500,
            },
            deploy_contract_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 52376500000,
                send_not_sir: 52376500000,
                execution: 52826825505,
            },
            deploy_contract_cost_per_byte: Fee {
                send_sir: 8298561,
                send_not_sir: 8298561,
                execution: 2333358119803,
            },
            function_call_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 257123312500,
                send_not_sir: 257123312500,
                execution: 257123312500,
            },
            function_call_cost_per_byte: Fee {
                send_sir: 31498,
                send_not_sir: 31498,
                execution: 31498,
            },
            transfer_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 32271375000,
                send_not_sir: 32271375000,
                execution: 32271375000,
            },
            stake_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 63955375000,
                send_not_sir: 63955375000,
                execution: 63955375000,
            },
            add_key_cost: AccessKeyCreationConfig {
                full_access_cost: Fee {
                    send_sir: 32792187500,
                    send_not_sir: 32792187500,
                    execution: 32792187500,
                },
                function_call_cost: Fee {
                    send_sir: 32156250000,
                    send_not_sir: 32156250000,
                    execution: 32156250000,
                },
                function_call_cost_per_byte: Fee {
                    send_sir: 12654743,
                    send_not_sir: 12654743,
                    execution: 12654743,
                },
            },
            delete_key_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 16654750000,
                send_not_sir: 16654750000,
                execution: 16654750000,
            },
            delete_account_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 135365687500,
                send_not_sir: 135365687500,
                execution: 135365687500,
            },
        },
        storage_usage_config: StorageUsageConfig {
            num_bytes_account: 100,
            num_extra_bytes_record: 40,
        },
        burnt_gas_reward: Ratio {
            numer: 3,
            denom: 10,
        },
        pessimistic_gas_price_inflation_ratio: Ratio {
            numer: 103,
            denom: 100,
        },
    },
    wasm_config: VMConfig {
        ext_costs: ExtCostsConfig {
            base: 86192651,
            contract_compile_base: 0,
            contract_compile_bytes: 0,
            read_memory_base: 240583625,
            read_memory_byte: 1266996,
            write_memory_base: 299679375,
            write_memory_byte: 61639,
            read_register_base: 208015000,
            read_register_byte: 32267,
            write_register_base: 331427625,
            write_register_byte: 1267082,
            utf8_decoding_base: 415690312,
            utf8_decoding_byte: 98402985,
            utf16_decoding_base: 562920137,
            utf16_decoding_byte: 54853932,
            sha256_base: 985787500,
            sha256_byte: 9533871,
            keccak256_base: 1312011187,
            keccak256_byte: 7064781,
            keccak512_base: 1305269762,
            keccak512_byte: 12106739,
            log_base: 562920137,
            log_byte: 4108400,
            storage_write_base: 17176720250,
            storage_write_key_byte: 26416770,
            storage_write_value_byte: 2044093784,
            storage_write_evicted_byte: 3118598072,
            storage_read_base: 26620283375,
            storage_read_key_byte: 5451228865,
            storage_read_value_byte: 5217699173,
            storage_remove_base: 31537079375,
            storage_remove_key_byte: 5895304107,
            storage_remove_ret_value_byte: 5429953409,
            storage_has_key_base: 24861784375,
            storage_has_key_byte: 5048138526,
            storage_iter_create_prefix_base: 0,
            storage_iter_create_prefix_byte: 0,
            storage_iter_create_range_base: 0,
            storage_iter_create_from_byte: 0,
            storage_iter_create_to_byte: 0,
            storage_iter_next_base: 0,
            storage_iter_next_key_byte: 0,
            storage_iter_next_value_byte: 0,
            touching_trie_node: 7605795250,
            promise_and_base: 5259182120,
            promise_and_per_promise: 43190415,
            promise_return: 4631026297,
            validator_stake_base: 303944908800,
            validator_total_stake_base: 303944908800,
        },
        grow_mem_cost: 1,
        regular_op_cost: 1310769,
        limit_config: VMLimitConfig {
            max_gas_burnt: 200000000000000,
            max_gas_burnt_view: 200000000000000,
            max_stack_height: 16384,
            initial_memory_pages: 1024,
            max_memory_pages: 2048,
            registers_memory_limit: 1073741824,
            max_register_size: 104857600,
            max_number_registers: 100,
            max_number_logs: 100,
            max_total_log_length: 16384,
            max_total_prepaid_gas: 300000000000000,
            max_actions_per_receipt: 100,
            max_number_bytes_method_names: 2000,
            max_length_method_name: 256,
            max_arguments_length: 4194304,
            max_length_returned_data: 4194304,
            max_contract_size: 4194304,
            max_length_storage_key: 4194304,
            max_length_storage_value: 4194304,
            max_promises_per_function_call_action: 1024,
            max_number_input_data_dependencies: 128,
        },
    },
    account_creation_config: AccountCreationConfig {
        min_allowed_top_level_account_length: 0,
        registrar_account_id: "registrar",
    },
}

Longarithm · 2021-07-06T14:10:15Z

Diff

Generation:

python3 ./runtime/runtime-params-estimator/emu-cost/safety_mutiplier.py
python3 ./runtime/runtime-params-estimator/emu-cost/compare_costs.py /tmp/data/runtime_config_old.json /tmp/data/runtime_config_safety_mutiplied.json

transaction_costs.action_receipt_creation_config.send_sir: first=108059500000 second=164973625000 second/first=1.53
transaction_costs.action_receipt_creation_config.send_not_sir: first=108059500000 second=164973625000 second/first=1.53
transaction_costs.action_receipt_creation_config.execution: first=108059500000 second=164973625000 second/first=1.53
transaction_costs.data_receipt_creation_config.base_cost.send_sir: first=4697339419375 second=50745691155500 second/first=10.80
transaction_costs.data_receipt_creation_config.base_cost.send_not_sir: first=4697339419375 second=50745691155500 second/first=10.80
transaction_costs.data_receipt_creation_config.base_cost.execution: first=4697339419375 second=50745691155500 second/first=10.80
transaction_costs.data_receipt_creation_config.cost_per_byte.send_sir: first=59357464 second=13895993 second/first=0.23
transaction_costs.data_receipt_creation_config.cost_per_byte.send_not_sir: first=59357464 second=13895993 second/first=0.23
transaction_costs.data_receipt_creation_config.cost_per_byte.execution: first=59357464 second=13895993 second/first=0.23
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.create_account_cost.send_sir: first=99607375000 second=30911812500 second/first=0.31
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.create_account_cost.send_not_sir: first=99607375000 second=30911812500 second/first=0.31
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.create_account_cost.execution: first=99607375000 second=30911812500 second/first=0.31
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.deploy_contract_cost.send_sir: first=184765750000 second=52376500000 second/first=0.28
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.deploy_contract_cost.send_not_sir: first=184765750000 second=52376500000 second/first=0.28
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.deploy_contract_cost.execution: first=184765750000 second=52826825505 second/first=0.29
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.deploy_contract_cost_per_byte.send_sir: first=6812999 second=8298561 second/first=1.22
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.deploy_contract_cost_per_byte.send_not_sir: first=6812999 second=8298561 second/first=1.22
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.deploy_contract_cost_per_byte.execution: first=6812999 second=2333358119803 second/first=342486.20
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.function_call_cost.send_sir: first=2319861500000 second=257123312500 second/first=0.11
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.function_call_cost.send_not_sir: first=2319861500000 second=257123312500 second/first=0.11
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.function_call_cost.execution: first=2319861500000 second=257123312500 second/first=0.11
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.function_call_cost_per_byte.send_sir: first=2235934 second=31498 second/first=0.01
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.function_call_cost_per_byte.send_not_sir: first=2235934 second=31498 second/first=0.01
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.function_call_cost_per_byte.execution: first=2235934 second=31498 second/first=0.01
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.transfer_cost.send_sir: first=115123062500 second=32271375000 second/first=0.28
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.transfer_cost.send_not_sir: first=115123062500 second=32271375000 second/first=0.28
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.transfer_cost.execution: first=115123062500 second=32271375000 second/first=0.28
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.stake_cost.send_sir: first=141715687500 second=63955375000 second/first=0.45
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.stake_cost.send_not_sir: first=141715687500 second=63955375000 second/first=0.45
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.stake_cost.execution: first=102217625000 second=63955375000 second/first=0.63
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.add_key_cost.full_access_cost.send_sir: first=101765125000 second=32792187500 second/first=0.32
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.add_key_cost.full_access_cost.send_not_sir: first=101765125000 second=32792187500 second/first=0.32
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.add_key_cost.full_access_cost.execution: first=101765125000 second=32792187500 second/first=0.32
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.add_key_cost.function_call_cost.send_sir: first=102217625000 second=32156250000 second/first=0.31
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.add_key_cost.function_call_cost.send_not_sir: first=102217625000 second=32156250000 second/first=0.31
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.add_key_cost.function_call_cost.execution: first=102217625000 second=32156250000 second/first=0.31
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.add_key_cost.function_call_cost_per_byte.send_sir: first=1925331 second=12654743 second/first=6.57
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.add_key_cost.function_call_cost_per_byte.send_not_sir: first=1925331 second=12654743 second/first=6.57
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.add_key_cost.function_call_cost_per_byte.execution: first=1925331 second=12654743 second/first=6.57
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.delete_key_cost.send_sir: first=94946625000 second=16654750000 second/first=0.18
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.delete_key_cost.send_not_sir: first=94946625000 second=16654750000 second/first=0.18
transaction_costs.action_creation_config.delete_key_cost.execution: first=94946625000 second=16654750000 second/first=0.18
wasm_config.ext_costs.read_memory_base: first=2609863200 second=721750875 second/first=0.28
wasm_config.ext_costs.write_memory_base: first=2803794861 second=899038125 second/first=0.32
wasm_config.ext_costs.write_memory_byte: first=2723772 second=184917 second/first=0.07
wasm_config.ext_costs.read_register_base: first=2517165186 second=624045000 second/first=0.25
wasm_config.ext_costs.write_register_base: first=2865522486 second=994282875 second/first=0.35
wasm_config.ext_costs.utf8_decoding_base: first=3111779061 second=1247070936 second/first=0.40
wasm_config.ext_costs.utf16_decoding_base: first=3543313050 second=1688760411 second/first=0.48
wasm_config.ext_costs.sha256_base: first=4540970250 second=2957362500 second/first=0.65
wasm_config.ext_costs.keccak256_base: first=5879491275 second=3936033561 second/first=0.67
wasm_config.ext_costs.keccak512_base: first=5811388236 second=3915809286 second/first=0.67
wasm_config.ext_costs.ripemd160_base: first=853675086 second=0 second/first=0.00
wasm_config.ext_costs.ripemd160_block: first=680107584 second=0 second/first=0.00
wasm_config.ext_costs.ecrecover_base: first=3365369625000 second=0 second/first=0.00
wasm_config.ext_costs.log_base: first=3543313050 second=1688760411 second/first=0.48
wasm_config.ext_costs.storage_write_base: first=64196736000 second=51530160750 second/first=0.80
wasm_config.ext_costs.storage_write_value_byte: first=31018539 second=6132281352 second/first=197.70
wasm_config.ext_costs.storage_write_evicted_byte: first=32117307 second=9355794216 second/first=291.30
wasm_config.ext_costs.storage_read_base: first=56356845750 second=79860850125 second/first=1.42
wasm_config.ext_costs.storage_read_key_byte: first=30952533 second=16353686595 second/first=528.35
wasm_config.ext_costs.storage_read_value_byte: first=5611005 second=15653097519 second/first=2789.71
wasm_config.ext_costs.storage_remove_base: first=53473030500 second=94611238125 second/first=1.77
wasm_config.ext_costs.storage_remove_key_byte: first=38220384 second=17685912321 second/first=462.74
wasm_config.ext_costs.storage_remove_ret_value_byte: first=11531556 second=16289860227 second/first=1412.63
wasm_config.ext_costs.storage_has_key_base: first=54039896625 second=74585353125 second/first=1.38
wasm_config.ext_costs.storage_has_key_byte: first=30790845 second=15144415578 second/first=491.85
wasm_config.ext_costs.touching_trie_node: first=16101955926 second=22817385750 second/first=1.42
wasm_config.ext_costs.promise_and_base: first=1465013400 second=15777546360 second/first=10.77
wasm_config.ext_costs.promise_and_per_promise: first=5452176 second=129571245 second/first=23.77
wasm_config.ext_costs.promise_return: first=560152386 second=13893078891 second/first=24.80
wasm_config.limit_config.max_transaction_size: first=4194304 second=0 second/first=0.00

Findings

function_call_cost and deploy_contract_cost_per_byte diff looks like what we wanted to achieve
but function_call_cost base = 257123312500 per_byte = 31498 is suspicious itself
data_receipt_creation_config and ext_costs.storage_* diff looks suspicious from the first sight
add_key_cost.function_call_cost_per_byte diff is kind of expected: add_key_cost.function_call_cost_per_byte is not correctly calculated from #3037

bowenwang1996 · 2021-07-06T22:42:38Z

data_receipt_creation_config: DataReceiptCreationConfig {
            base_cost: Fee {
                send_sir: 50745691155500,
                send_not_sir: 50745691155500,
                execution: 50745691155500,
            },
            cost_per_byte: Fee {
                send_sir: 13895993,
                send_not_sir: 13895993,
                execution: 13895993,
            },
        },

This is definitely not correct. Data receipt creation should not cost 50Tgas. cc @olonho

stale · 2021-07-30T00:00:11Z

This PR has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity in the 2 weeks.
It will be closed in 3 days if no further activity occurs.
Thank you for your contributions.

The numeric value of the cost stays exactly the same (3856371 is evenly divisible by 3). Looking at the recent measurements in near#4455 (comment) it's clear that the measured cost is 3x lower.

The numeric value of the cost stays exactly the same (3856371 is evenly divisible by 3). Looking at the recent measurements in #4455 (comment) it's clear that the measured cost is 3x lower. Test Plan: -------- Just visual inspection that the constant stays the same.

Longarithm · 2022-03-25T20:25:59Z

Closing because the params-estimator logic changed a lot.
Also the work moved to another direction - e.g. we had to increase deployment costs #6397

add protocol feature

178a52a

Longarithm self-assigned this Jul 2, 2021

minor fix

052de8e

Longarithm linked an issue Jul 2, 2021 that may be closed by this pull request

Recompute gas costs for function call base and data creation #4401

Closed

Longarithm added the A-transaction-runtime Area: transaction runtime (transaction and receipts processing, state transition, etc) label Jul 2, 2021

Longarithm mentioned this pull request Jul 8, 2021

Investigate unrealistic base cost of DataReceiptCreationConfig #4482

Closed

Longarithm and others added 18 commits July 13, 2021 19:28

remove contract_compile costs

51555b3

add compile costs to params-estimator

3afbd7f

Merge branch 'master' into update-cost

b0cb04e

minor fix

1bb0c6e

Merge branch 'master' into update-cost

8b8b060

fix compile costs

813adf8

Merge branch 'master' into update-cost

a3bfb2c

compilation fix

68e8407

Merge branch 'master' into update-cost

e25d408

add checked_feature

5acaa6b

add precompilation config

f781d9c

update fees

d26fec0

remove feature from estimator

3bd6889

remove checked_feature

de938b6

Merge branch 'master' into update-cost

14274eb

update genesis config

2dd1f19

decrease gas limit in test

818eda6

test

62f81ee

stale bot added the S-stale label Jul 30, 2021

matklad mentioned this pull request Aug 5, 2021

refactor: make it clear that regular_op_cost uses the multiplier #4639

Merged

Longarithm mentioned this pull request Aug 23, 2021

refactor: prepare and dump state inside params-estimator #4706

Merged

Longarithm closed this Mar 25, 2022

bowenwang1996 deleted the update-cost branch March 31, 2022 00:57

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

WIP: Recompute gas costs considering precompilation #4455

WIP: Recompute gas costs considering precompilation #4455

Longarithm commented Jul 2, 2021

Longarithm commented Jul 2, 2021 •

edited

Loading

Longarithm commented Jul 2, 2021 •

edited

Loading

bowenwang1996 commented Jul 2, 2021 •

edited

Loading

Longarithm commented Jul 6, 2021

Longarithm commented Jul 6, 2021 •

edited

Loading

bowenwang1996 commented Jul 6, 2021

stale bot commented Jul 30, 2021

Longarithm commented Mar 25, 2022

WIP: Recompute gas costs considering precompilation #4455

WIP: Recompute gas costs considering precompilation #4455

Conversation

Longarithm commented Jul 2, 2021

Longarithm commented Jul 2, 2021 • edited Loading

Longarithm commented Jul 2, 2021 • edited Loading

bowenwang1996 commented Jul 2, 2021 • edited Loading

Longarithm commented Jul 6, 2021

Longarithm commented Jul 6, 2021 • edited Loading

bowenwang1996 commented Jul 6, 2021

stale bot commented Jul 30, 2021

Longarithm commented Mar 25, 2022

Longarithm commented Jul 2, 2021 •

edited

Loading

Longarithm commented Jul 2, 2021 •

edited

Loading

bowenwang1996 commented Jul 2, 2021 •

edited

Loading

Longarithm commented Jul 6, 2021 •

edited

Loading