Skip to content

CMI 5 Subgroup Meeting Notes – Jan 19th, 2024

Jump to bottom Edit New page
Bill McDonald edited this page Jan 26, 2024 · 5 revisions

cmi5 Subgroup Meeting Notes – Jan 19th, 2024

Attendee List

Pending....

Notes

"Derived Requirements" Review

The group continued its review of "Derived Requirements" (from CATAPULT documentation) to identify areas of the spec that may need revision:

There are requirements that seem to let the LMS change values, when it should instead be rejecting a Statement (9.5 series)

  • 9.5.2.0-1 (d2) The LMS must set "result.success" to true for cmi5 defined statements that it stores using the "waived" verb.
  • 9.5.3.0-1 (d2) The LMS must set "result.completion" to true for cmi5 defined statements that it stores using the "waived" verb. * LMS is composing the Statements not modifying them
  • 9.6.0.0-1 (d) The LMS must reject cmi5 defined statements that don't include a context object or include a context object that is not conformant to section 9.6.
    • Agreed
  • 9.6.1.0-1 (d) The LMS must reject cmi5 defined statements that don't include the "registration" property or include a different value than that provided by the LMS.
    • Agreed
  • 9.6.2.0-1 (d) The LMS must reject cmi5 defined statements that do not include all contextActivities values as provided by the context template.
    • Agreed
  • 9.6.2.2-1 (d1) The LMS must reject cmi5 defined statements that include the "result.success" or "result.completion" property that do not include the moveOn category activity in the "context.contextActivities.category" list. [Completed]
    • Agreed
  • 9.6.2.2-1 (d2) The LMS must reject cmi5 defined statements that include the "result.success" or "result.completion" property that do not include the moveOn category activity in the "context.contextActivities.category" list. [Passed]
    • Agreed
  • 9.6.2.2-1 (d3) The LMS must reject cmi5 defined statements that include the "result.success" or "result.completion" property that do not include the moveOn category activity in the "context.contextActivities.category" list. [Failed]
    • Agreed
  • 9.6.2.2-1 (d4) The LMS must have an Activity object with an "id" of "https://w3id.org/xapi/cmi5/context/categories/moveon" in the "category" context activities list for cmi5 defined statements that it stores using the "waived" verb.
  • 9.6.2.2-2 (d) The LMS must reject statements that include the moveOn category activity in a "context.contextActivities" list that are not cmi5 defined statements or that are cmi5 defined statements that do not contain either a "result.completion" or "result.success" property.
    • Split into cmi5 defined statements vs not cmi5 defined statements
    • The LMS must reject statements that include the moveOn category activity in a "context.contextActivities" list that are not cmi5 defined statements.
    • The LMS must reject statements that include the moveOn category activity in a "context.contextActivities" list that are cmi5 defined statements that do not contain either a "result.completion" or "result.success" property
  • 9.6.3.1-4 (d) The LMS must reject statements that it receives from the AU that do not include the session id in the session id context extension.
    • Agreed
  • 9.6.3.2-2 (d) The LMS must reject statements it receives from the AU that do not include the masteryScore extension value in the context but include a score and the "passed" or "failed" verb.
    • Agreed
  • 9.7.0.0-1 (d) The LMS must reject statements received from the AU that do not include the timestamp property.
    • Agreed
  • 9.7.0.0-2 (d) The LMS must reject statements received from the AU that include a timestamp property value that is not in UTC.
    • Agreed
  • 10.2.1.0-5 (d) The LMS must reject non-GET requests from the AU for the "LMS.LaunchData" state profile document.
    • (HTTP GET)
    • Agreed
    • Revise Section 10.1 to specify “State API Properties:” instead of “State API PUT Properties:”
    • Specify the API resource (xAPI State API)
  • 10.2.1.0-6 (d) The LMS must reject statements that do not have a "context" object based on the "contextTemplate" provided to the AU via the launch data State API document.
    • Agreed
  • 10.2.1.0-7 (d) The LMS must reject statements that include a "context" object that has contextTemplate property values that have been overwritten.
    • Agreed
  • 10.2.2.0-1 (d) The LMS must track what launchMode was used for a given AU launch session.
    • Observable data – Track is a means (Implementation specific)
    • Anything with “track” is not really necessary for normative requirements
  • 10.2.2.0-2 (d) The LMS must reject cmi5 defined statements that use the "passed", "failed", or "completed" verb received from the AU [during a session with a "Browse" launchMode].
    • Agreed
  • 10.2.2.0-3 (d) The LMS must reject cmi5 defined statements that use the "passed", "failed", or "completed" verb received from the AU [during a session with a "Review" launchMode].
    • Agreed
  • 10.2.2.0-5 (d) The LMS must reject statement requests that do not conform to the value of "launchMode".
    • Agreed

All Previous cmi5 Meeting Minutes/Notes

https://github.com/AICC/CMI-5_Spec_Current/wiki

cmi5 on GitHub:

http://aicc.github.io/CMI-5_Spec_Current/

cmi5 Working Group Wiki

Home

Meeting Minutes

Working Documents

Clone this wiki locally