CMI 5 Working Group Meeting Minutes – January 20th, 2023

cmi5 Working Group Meeting Minutes – January 13th, 2023

Attendee List

• Andy Johnson (ADL)
• Florian Tolk (ADL)
• Megan Bohland (ADL)
• Jim Taite (DLA)
• Brian Miller (Rustici Software)
• Chetan Sachdev ()
• Thomas Turrell-Croft ()
• Lisa Toquothty ()
• Franklin Ludgood ()
• Vineet Mahesh (InXSOL)
• Henry Ryng (InXSOL)
• Tyler Mulligan (SANS)
• Christopher Thompson (National Council For Mental Wellbeing)
• Martin Koob (VideoLinkWell)
• Yifei Dong (Keybridge Technologies)

Notes

The group discussed specification Style Rules for the following:

• Verb Names
• Statement Names
• Property Names

Proposed Style Rules:

1. Back Ticks (`) for all literal names of verbs and properties – ‘completed’ verb
2. Double Quotes for shorthand – “completed” statement
   • Always use lowercase (Literal syntax case)
3. Titles with verbs/properties
   • Capitalized or Literal
   • 9.3.4 Passed

Usage example (short hand reference for a statement type with specific value of property)

• A "completed" statement must contain a result of ‘completion’

Proposed spec changes:

Add information language to explain how the concept of statement is referred to in the spec:

This document uses, as shorthand, specific vocabulary such as verbs in conjunction with the word "statement" (e.g., a "completed" statement). This shorthand refers to that statement meeting all requirements that would accompany the correct use of that concept.

Update - 9.3.5 Failed - as follows:

9.3.5 Failed

The criterion for "Failed" is determined by the course designer.

Should be

9.3.5 Failed

The criterion for success determined by the course designer.

The criterion for issuing a “Failed” statement is determined by the course designer.

Should remove - "(cmi5 allowed or defined)" for 9.3 as follows:

9.3 Verbs

AU Verb Ordering Rules within an AU session are as follows:

• Verbs MUST NOT be duplicated (in cmi5 defined statements).
• More than one of the set of {"Passed","Failed"} verbs MUST NOT be used (in cmi5 defined statements).
• The "Initialized" verb MUST be the first statement.
• The "Terminated" verb MUST be the last statement.

---

All Previous cmi5 Meeting Minutes

https://github.com/AICC/CMI-5_Spec_Current/wiki

cmi5 on GitHub:

http://aicc.github.io/CMI-5_Spec_Current/