2020.04.21 Editors Meeting

Call-in

See invite

Attendees

• Julian Morley (Stanford)
• Rosy Metz (Emory)
• Simeon Warner (Cornell)
• Andrew Woods (Lyrasis) *
• Andrew Hankinson (Bodleian Libraries)
• Neil Jefferies (Bodleian Libraries)

(* indicates the notetaker)

Agenda

1. Open Spec Pull Requests and Open Extension Pull Requests
2. Open 1.0 Spec Issues and Open Extensions Issues
   1. Extension Parameterization (extensions-PR3)
3. Releasing 1.0
   1. Status of validators
      • ocfl-py
   2. Status of fixture objects
   3. Status of test suite
   4. Two institutions backing the project

Notes

1. Extensions (pr-3)
   • Simeon to create new issue regarding mechanism for versioning extensions
     • done: issue-4
   • Intention to have all editorial feedback and reviews completed by this Thurs (4/23)
2. Open spec issues
   • Simeon to create pull-requests for issue-448 and issue-449
   • Julian to finish adding error codes to validation-codes table (issue-446)
3. OCFL-py
   • Ready to be run by OCFL implementers
   • Feedback welcomed/encouraged
4. Fedora 6 and OCFL
   • Interest in isolating any Fedora-isms into an 'extensions' directory
   • Value in being able to (if possible) drop Fedora 6 over any vanilla OCFL repository
   • Value in being able to use the Fedora 6 OCFL in a post-Fedora world, i.e. would be best not to have Fedora-isms sprinkled throughout the OCFL Objects

Action Items

Previous Action Items

• Rosy to create new calendar series
• All editors to review PR-3
• Julian to retool for updated error codes
• Julian to align and link validation-codes.md with anchors in spec ...sooner
• Julian to rename bad objects with error codes ...a little later
• AH to create issue for error code consolidation
• NJ to update Extension Parameters with suggestions - JSON examples, typos